//
© 2026 Zoe. All rights reserved.
Zoe is a legal information platform. Always consult the Federal Register of Legislation for authoritative text.
[2010] FWA 9440
Fair Work Australia
2010-12-08
Original judgment source is linked above.
(#P27_969) In accordance with s.399 (Hearings).
(#P32_1589) Exhibit G4, Attachment L.
(#P57_4370) McHugh and Gummow JJ, [1995] HCA 24; (1995) 185 CLR 410 at 465.
(#P82_6146) A Note to the provision states that: "The expression 'fair go all round' was used by Sheldon J in Re Loty and Holloway v Australian Workers Union [1971] AR (NSW) 95.'
(#P87_6695) Print S4213, 17 March 2000, per Ross VP, Williams SDP and Hingley C.
(#P94_7937) [1938] HCA 34; (1938) 60 CLR 336.
(#P95_8128) Ibid, per Dixon J at p 363.
(#P96_8273) Ibid, per Dixon J at p 362.
(#P97_8422) Ibid, per Rich J at p 350.
(#P100_8469) [2007] AIRCFB 797, 5 October 2007, per Giudice P, Lacy SDP, Cargill C.
(#P129_10988) PN249 and Written Submissions of the Applicant, para 58.
(#P134_11578) PN901.
(#P137_11767) PN898 & PN1516.
(#P140_12129) PN1001.
(#P141_12184) Exhibit G3, para 28.
(#P142_12292) PN2247.
(#P149_13355) PN1531.
(#P150_13435) PN1554.
(#P151_13606) PN1530.
(#P154_13915) PN1572-PN1573.
(#P157_14031) Exhibit G2, Attachment A.
(#P158_14976) Exhibit G3, para 4.
(#P159_15098) Exhibit G2, para 4.
(#P162_15472) Exhibit G2, para 5.
(#P171_16735) Exhibit G3, Attachment B.
(#P174_17143) Exhibit G3, Attachment C.
(#P177_17485) PN1006 - PN1008.
(#P180_17685) Exhibit G3, para 16.
(#P183_18057) Which describes itself on its website as 'one of the largest producers and resellers of quarried, recycled and landscape products in NSW.'
(#P196_18823) Exhibit G3, Attachment D.
(#P203_19610) Respondent's Outline of Submissions, para 21.
(#P222_21039) Exhibit G3, Attachment E.
(#P233_22002) Exhibit C2, Attachment G.
(#P250_23449) Exhibit G3, Attachment G.
(#P273_25445) Exhibit C2, Attachment K.
(#P290_26824) Exhibit G4, Attachment G.
(#P295_27199) Exhibit C2, Attachment M.
(#P298_27364) Exhibit G4, Attachment I.
(#P307_28191) Exhibit G4, Attachment K.
(#P314_28710) Exhibit G4, Attachment L.
(#P341_30528) PN729.
(#P346_30946) PN798 & PN802.
(#P359_32594) (1995) 62 IR 371, 373.
(#P364_33534) PN1004.
(#P367_34176) PN837.
(#P368_34284) PN838 and photograph in Exhibit C5, Attachment A (page 5 of exhibit).
(#P369_34423) PN844 - PN845 & PN1123.
(#P374_34851) PN846 - PN847.
(#P377_34996) PN1026 and PN1072.
(#P378_35356) It was never put directly to Mr Walker that his method of adding gear oil could not have resulted in gear oil of approximately 1.25 litres in his 5 litre container on 2 July 2010, i.e. 25%.
(#P385_36405) PN1657 & PN1661 - PN1663.
(#P388_36691) PN1665.
(#P389_36788) PN1675.
(#P390_36956) Exhibit G3, Attachment B.
(#P391_37136) PN1654.
(#P394_37428) PN1623.
(#P401_37995) Exhibit G3, para 28.
(#P404_38107) PN2247.
(#P409_38436) PN1674 & PN1675. Also PN1703.
(#P410_38598) PN1622 - PN1623.
(#P413_38739) Clearly Mr Arber was not a witness to the discussion as although he was close by he wouldn't have heard anything.
(#P414_39008) PN1649 - PN1653.
(#P415_39351) PN1838 - PN1877.
(#P416_39657) Exhibit G4, para 4.
(#P431_40458) PN2000 - PN2004.
(#P444_41020) PN2042 - PN2046.
(#P447_41200) PN2130.
(#P455_41514) PN2106 - PN2108.
(#P460_41789) Exhibit G3, para 19.
(#P463_42004) PNPN1786 - PN1793.
(#P464_42165) PN1800 & PN1814.
(#P473_42919) PN1740.
(#P476_43378) Exhibit G3, Attachment A.
(#P483_44054) Exhibit C2, para 16 & PN1707.
(#P490_44715) PN2171
(#P493_45248) Exhibit G2, para 6.
(#P494_45337) PN1587.
(#P495_45519) PN1684.
(#P498_45808) Mr Walker was unwavering under cross-examination - PN1109 - PN1115.
(#P503_46224) Written Submissions of Applicant, paras 134-140.
(#P504_46375) [1998] ACTSC 89 (4 September 1998).
(#P507_46864) Print S4213, 17 March 2000, per Ross VP, Williams SDP, Hingley C.
(#P510_47626) (1987) 19 IR 153 at 155, per Fisher P, Bauer & Glynn JJ.
(#P517_48158) [1978] HCA 22; (1978) 141 CLR 54.
(#P518_48241) Robinson v Woolworths Ltd, [2005] NSWCCA 426; (2005) 227 ALR 353; (2005) NSWLR 612.
(#P519_48508) R v Swaffield; Pavic v R, [1998] HCA 1; 192 CLR 159, paras 69-70, per Toohey, Gaudron and Gummow JJ.
(#P522_48630) Op cit.
(#P550_50850) ALRC Report 102, 13 February 2006.
(#P557_51595) Klein v Brand, op cit, at para 44.
(#P558_51737) PR948938, 12 July 2004, Ross VP, Duncan SDP, Bacon C, at para 56.
(#P559_51963) [2001] FCA 1164; (2001) 111 FCR 20.
(#P562_52184) Australian Securities & Investment Commission v McDonald (No5), [2008] NSWSC 1169, at para 27.
(#P563_52296) (1996) 86 A Crim R 188.
(#P566_53181) At 196.
(#P583_56843) PN1986-1989.
(#P594_59755) Exhibit C2, para 10 and PN1133.
(#P597_60179) Exhibit C2, para 17 - which was not denied in Exhibit G3, para 30.
(#P598_60334) PN1986 - PN1988.
(#P599_60453) Compare Exhibit G3, para 7 with PN1651.
(#P600_60693) Exhibit G3, para 7.
(#P601_60859) Respondent's Outline of Submissions, para 15.
(#P610_62015) Based on the model guidelines recommended by Macken J of the NSW Industrial Commission for major employers in the retail industry in NSW in re Security Arrangements in Retail Stores, [1979] AR 72, at 89.
(#P613_62327) Ibid.
(#P616_62772) At 79.
(#P631_64353) Decision of the Full Bench in P Crozier v Palazzo Corporation Pty Limited t/as Noble Park Storage and Transport, Print S5897, 11 May 2000, per Ross VP, Acton SDP and Cribb C, at para 64. Endorsed by the Full Bench decision in Ben Clifton Sabeto v Waterloo Car Centre Pty Limited trading as Red Spot Rentals, PR930816, 20 May 2003, per Acton SDP, O'Callaghan SDP and Foggo C, at para 8.
(#P632_64809) P Crozier v Palazzo Corporation Pty Limited t/as Noble Park Storage and Transport, op cit, at para 73. Also endorsed in Ben Clifton Sabeto v Waterloo Car Centre Pty Limited trading as Red Spot Rentals, op cit, at para 8.
(#P641_65864) Crozier v Palazzo Corporation Pty Limited t/as Noble Park Storage and Transport, op cit, at para 75.
(#P642_66048) Tenix Defence Systems Pty Ltd v Fearnley, Print S6238, 22 May 2000, per Ross VP, Polites SDP, Smith C, at para 83.
(#P645_66677) Ross VP, in Shorten and Others v Australian Meat Holdings Pty Ltd, (1996) 70 IR 360, 361.
(#P648_67433) Wadey v YMCA Canberra [1996] IRCA 568 (12 November 1996).
(#P663_69329) Re: P. Annetta, op cit, at para 16.
(#P676_70390) Ms Marten's evidence included: 'I'm a payroll officer. I don't deal with HR issues very often.' (PN2468)
(#P677_70805) PN2403.
(#P678_70922) PN2289 & PN2899.
(#P755_77701) Exhibit C2, Attachment D.
(#P782_80122) PN2905 - PN2923.
(#P793_80734) [2010] FWAFB 8868, 2 December 2010, per Kaufman SDP, Richards SDP, Hampton C.
Printed by authority of the Commonwealth Government Printer
Walker
Mittagong Sands Pty Limited t/as Cowra Quartz [2010] FWA 9440
(1996) 70 IR 360
(1938) 60 CLR 336
(1995) 60 IR 1
(1999) 196 CLR 297
(1995) 185 CLR 410
(1995) 62 IR 371
(1987) 19 IR 153
(1978) 141 CLR 54
(2005) 227 ALR 353
(2001) 111 FCR 20