Cannan v Nyrstar Hobart Pty Ltd [2014] FWC 5072

Fair Work Commission|2014-09-19|Before: Deputy President Wells, President Wells

(#P32_910) Exhibit R4 - Statement of Timothy Wilson-Haffenden, 7 April 2014 Attachments TWH-29 and TWH-32

(#P41_2594) Transcript - PN70-72

(#P52_3704) Exhibit A1 - Statement of Marshall Reeves, 28 April 2014 Attachment MRR-1

(#P76_7646) Exhibit R4 - Attachment TWH-24

(#P83_8739) Exhibit R4 - Attachments TWH-29 and TWH-32

(#P90_8886) Exhibit A1

(#P92_8950) Exhibit A2 - Statement of Noel Cannan, 28 April 2014

(#P94_9063) Exhibit A4 - Statement of Kevin Fuller, 28 April 2014

(#P96_9177) Exhibit A5 - Statement of Gardner Cox, 28 April 2014

(#P101_9351) Exhibit R3 - Statement of Victoria Newton, 7 April 2014

(#P103_9489) Exhibits R4 & R21 - Supplementary statement of Tim Wilson-Haffenden, 26 May 2014

(#P105_9634) Exhibit R5 - Statement of Craig Wells, 29 May 2014

(#P107_9830) Exhibit R6 - Statement of Joshua Fraraccio, 7 April 2014

(#P109_10021) Exhibit R7 - Statement of William Hinds, 13 June 2013

(#P111_10146) Exhibit R8 - Statement of Kerry Seabourne, 28 August 2013

(#P113_10282) Exhibit R9 - Statement of Steven Phillips, 7 July 2014

(#P115_10401) Exhibit R10 - Statement of Cade Terry, 29 August 2013

(#P117_10533) Exhibit R11 - Statement of Adrian Mudge, 29 August 2013

(#P119_10677) Exhibit R12 - Statement of Ricky Schultz, 8 May 2014

(#P121_10788) Exhibit R13 - Statement of David King, 1 August 2013

(#P123_10910) Exhibit R14 - Statement of Stuart Moore, 29 August 2013

(#P125_11032) Exhibit R15 - Statement of Alexandra Williams, 16 August 2013

(#P127_11147) Exhibit R16 - Statement of Grant Seward, 12 May 2014

(#P129_11267) Exhibit R17 - Statement of Terence Hinds, 2 May 2014

(#P131_11401) Exhibit R18 - Statement of Craig Rainbird, 7 April 2014 with attachments CR-2A and CR2B & Exhibit R19 - Supplementary Statement of Craig Rainbird, 23 May 2014

(#P138_12747) Exhibit R15, paragraph 6

(#P141_13282) Transcript, PN 2541-2542

(#P144_13485) Transcript, PN4962

(#P147_13897) Exhibit R6 - Attachment JF-9

(#P148_13997) Transcript, PN4563, PN4574

(#P149_14148) Exhibit A2 - paragraph 12

(#P150_14618) Exhibit A2 - paragraph 9

(#P153_14774) Transcript, PN4499

(#P154_14893) Transcript, PN5142, PN5150, PN5152

(#P155_15043) Transcript, PN5195

(#P158_15374) Transcript, PN2680, PN1171

(#P161_15613) Transcript, PN2662

(#P164_15882) Transcript, PN4815

(#P167_16010) Exhibit R11, paragraph 27

(#P168_16260) Transcript, PN5070-5073, PN5087-5088, PN5083

(#P171_16505) Transcript, PN5896

(#P174_17080) Transcript, PN6272

(#P177_17491) Transcript, PN6814

(#P186_19062) Exhibit R7, paragraph 18

(#P187_19279) Transcript, PN4768-4770, PN4766

(#P190_19489) Transcript, PN4072

(#P191_19600) Exhibit R3, Attachment VN-8

(#P192_19713) Transcript, PN4274

(#P195_20468) Transcript, PN732

(#P198_20920) Transcript, PN4236-4237

(#P199_21410) Transcript, PN4309

(#P202_21753) Exhibit R6, paragraph 46

(#P207_22035) Exhibit R18, paragraph 54

(#P214_23281) Transcript, PN1882

(#P225_25296) Transcript, PN6714

(#P226_25483) Exhibit R18, paragraph 50

(#P231_25954) Transcript, PN779 -782

(#P232_26226) Transcript, PN2411

(#P235_26566) Exhibit R18 - Attachments CR-2A, paragraph 25 & CR-2B, paragraph 5

(#P240_26901) Exhibit R6, paragraph 19

(#P241_26983) Exhibit R6, paragraph 27

(#P244_27675) Transcript, PN2585

(#P245_27902) Transcript, PN2590, PN2604

(#P248_28213) Transcript, PN5432

(#P249_28399) Transcript, PN5303

(#P254_29329) Exhibit R12 - Attachment RDS-1, paragraph 11.

(#P255_29573) Exhibit R10, paragraph 20

(#P258_29787) Exhibit R11, paragraph 7

(#P269_31532) Transcript, PN6417, PN6415-6416

(#P270_31653) Transcript, PN5144

(#P275_32183) Exhibit R6, paragraphs 63 and 64

(#P276_32838) Exhibit A2 - paragraph 14

(#P279_33210) Exhibit A5 - paragraph 4

(#P286_34938) Transcript, PN5912

(#P287_35105) Transcript, PN1026

(#P290_36060) Transcript, PN5309

(#P295_36658) Transcript, PN4751

(#P296_36838) Transcript, PN1295

(#P303_37986) Transcript, PN1022

(#P306_38700) Exhibit A2 - Attachment NAC-2

(#P307_38822) Transcript, PN1060

(#P310_39150) Transcript, PN937

(#P317_39502) Exhibit R6, paragraphs 31

(#P318_39680) Exhibit A4 - paragraph 15

(#P327_41687) Exhibit R6, Attachment JF-2

(#P328_42146) Exhibit R6, paragraph 37

(#P329_42747) Transcript, PN4455-4456

(#P334_43700) Transcript, PN5949, PN5954

(#P335_44509) Transcript, PN1778-1779

(#P336_44610) Transcript, PN1773

(#P337_44796) Exhibit A3

(#P340_45114) Transcript, PN6843

(#P343_45311) Transcript, PN2001

(#P346_45732) Exhibit R2 - Progressive Discipline Report, Zinifex Ltd, employee Kevin Fuller, dated 5 July 2006

(#P347_46017) Exhibit R21 - Supplementary Statement of Tim Wilson-Haffenden, dated 26 May 2014, paragraph 22

(#P350_46419) Transcript, PN1795

(#P351_46775) Transcript, PN1808

(#P352_46936) Exhibit A4 - Attachment KMF-2, Nyrstar Hobart Smelter Performance Based Pay Performance Review Form Operator, Kevin Fuller

(#P353_47258) Exhibit R6 - Attachments JF-4 and JF-7

(#P358_47826) Exhibit R7, paragraph 13

(#P363_48673) Exhibit R9, paragraph 15

(#P364_48776) Transcript, PN5296

(#P367_49090) Exhibit R17 - Attachment TH-1, paragraph 7

(#P370_49836) Transcript, PN1756

(#P373_50076) Transcript, PN4320, PN4332

(#P385_50868) Transcript, PN4416-4418, PN4437

(#P392_51410) Exhibit R21, paragraphs 17 to 27

(#P395_51760) Transcript, PN4348, PN4540

(#P396_52063) Transcript, PN4434, PN4363

(#P399_52592) Transcript, PN5757-5758

(#P400_52979) Exhibit R12 - Attachment RDS-2 to RDS-5

(#P403_53484) Transcript, PN1360

(#P406_53955) Exhibit R16, paragraphs 10 to 13

(#P409_54830) Exhibit R19, paragraph 6

(#P410_55041) Transcript, PN6870

(#P417_55798) Transcript, PN2844

(#P420_55994) Exhibit R4, paragraph 19

(#P421_56239) Exhibit R3, Attachment sVN-12, VN-13, VN-14

(#P424_56685) Exhibit R3, paragraph 35

(#P427_56989) Exhibit A3

(#P428_57031) Exhibit R4, paragraph 29 and Attachment TWH-9

(#P431_57505) Exhibit R3, paragraph 50

(#P433_57855) Exhibit R3, Attachment VN-31

(#P440_58350) Exhibit R4 - Attachment TWH-12

(#P447_59356) Exhibit R4 - Attachment TWH-13

(#P448_59582) Exhibit R4, paragraph 45

(#P449_59703) Exhibit R4 - Attachment TWH-15

(#P452_60099) Exhibits A6 & A7

(#P454_60197) Transcript, PN3438-3439

(#P456_60310) Exhibit R4 - Attachment TWH-19

(#P460_60674) Exhibit R4 - Attachment TWH-24

(#P465_61625) Exhibit R4 - Attachment TWH-20

(#P466_61751) Exhibit R4 - Attachment TWH-21

(#P471_61967) Exhibit R4 - Attachment TWH-25

(#P474_62481) Transcript, PN3347

(#P482_63270) Transcript, PN1558

(#P485_63540) Transcript, PN3369

(#P486_63768) Transcript, PN3886-3887

(#P487_63935) Transcript, PN3857

(#P490_64148) Transcript, PN2345

(#P493_64678) Exhibit R4, paragraph 66

(#P494_64898) Transcript, PN3291-3292

(#P497_65132) Exhibit A4, paragraph 31 & Exhibit A8 - Transcribed section of interview with Mr Simmonds

(#P500_65504) Exhibit R4, paragraphs 63 and 67

(#P505_66100) Transcript, PN3198-3199

(#P508_66363) Transcript, PN3214

(#P509_66551) Transcript, PN3931

(#P510_66647) Transcript, PN3216

(#P511_66834) Transcript, PN3267, PN3277

(#P514_67501) Exhibit A8 - Transcript of Mr Fuller's apology during interview with Mr Simmonds

(#P515_67665) Transcript, PN3882

(#P520_68531) Transcript, PN1150-1151

(#P527_69068) Exhibit R5 - paragraph 12, Attachment CGW-1, page 1, paragraph 3 and page 6, paragraph 46

(#P528_69323) Exhibit R5 - Attachment CGW-1, page 7, paragraph 4

(#P529_69762) Exhibit R5, paragraphs 5 and 6

(#P530_69917) Transcript, PN4027

(#P533_70465) Exhibit R5 - Attachment CGW-1, page 3, paragraph 18 and page 10, paragraphs 22 and 23

(#P536_70925) Transcript, PN4037, PN4097 and PN4088-4089

(#P539_71557) Exhibit R7, paragraph 5

(#P542_71897) Transcript, PN4893, PN4899, PN4909-4910, PN4914

(#P555_73225) Transcript, PN4944-4946, PN4949

(#P564_74185) Exhibit R11, paragraphs 28 and 29

(#P569_75291) Exhibit R12, paragraph 29

(#P572_75421) Exhibit R14, paragraph 6

(#P575_76236) Exhibit R14, paragraph 13

(#P578_76567) Transcript, PN6019

(#P579_77073) Transcript, PN6373-6377

(#P582_77218) Transcript, PN6546-6547

(#P583_77402) Exhibit R18 - Attachment CR-2A, paragraph 31

(#P584_77655) Exhibit R18 - Attachment CR-2A, paragraph 5

(#P593_78550) Transcript, PN6818-PN6821

(#P600_79364) Transcript, PN295

(#P605_80667) Transcript, PN1838

(#P610_81363) Transcript, PN4475-4477

(#P613_81835) Transcript, PN4408

(#P614_82081) Exhibit R6, paragraph 10

(#P619_82364) Exhibits A8 & R20 - part of Respondent's outline of submissions

(#P624_83155) Transcript, PN674 & 675

(#P627_83626) Transcript, PN1667-1668

(#P636_84153) Transcript, PN123

(#P639_85028) Transcript, PN 129 & 130

(#P668_91303) Transcript, PN1252

(#P669_91635) Exhibit A10 - Applicants' written closing submissions, paragraph 13

(#P670_92253) Exhibit R4, paragraph 63

(#P685_94939) Transcript - PN1415, PN1482

(#P695_96252) Exhibit A1 - Attachment MRR-1, clause 2.4.2

(#P733_104220) Transcript - Ms Zeitz, PN2705

(#P738_104880) Transcript - Ms Zeitz, PN2707

(#P747_106406) Transcript, PN7151

(#P750_106816) Exhibit R4 - Attachment TWH-31

(#P753_107660) Transcript, PN7187

(#P760_108471) Transcript, PN 7217

(#P791_113994) R20, paragraph 26

(#P885_125488) Exhibit R4 - Attachment TWH-24

(#P890_126446) Fair Work Act 2009, s.789FD(1) and (2)

(#P921_132924) Exhibit R4 - Attachment THW-19, page 3

(#P930_134084) Exhibit R4 - Attachment TWH-25

(#P935_135768) Exhibit R4 - Attachments THW-29 & TWH-32

(#P940_136569) Exhibit R4, paragraph 66

(#P975_140490) Howard v Pilkington (Australia) Ltd [2008] VSC 491 at [49] citing Rankin v Marine Power International Pty Ltd [2001] VSC 150.

At a glance

Court

Decision date

Before

Source

Judgment (210 paragraphs)

Parties

Legislation Cited (2)

Cases Cited (7)