Application by Metropolitan Fire & Emergency Services Board [2014] FWC 7776 (3 November 2014)

(#P91_4293) See [2010] FWAA 7414 (Operational Staff Agreement); [2010] FWAA 7413 (ACFO Agreement)

(#P198_8599) See MFB Act, s.4

(#P201_9440) Exhibit MFB 7, para 13 - 19

(#P202_9738) Exhibit MFB 8, para 36; see also Exhibit UFU 3, para 24

(#P209_10985) MFB Outline of Submissions dated 15 May 2014, paras 4 - 5

(#P212_11696) Ibid, para 7

(#P213_11893) Exhibit MFB 55, paras 6.2 - 6.3; per NTEIU v Monash University [2013] FWCFB 5982 at [19]

(#P218_12403) MFB Outline of Submissions dated 15 May 2014, at para 17

(#P221_12611) Ibid, paras 19 - 27

(#P222_12718) Ibid, paras 28 - 32

(#P223_12864) [1995] HCA 71; (1995) 184 CLR 188

(#P230_13140) MFB Outline of Submissions dated 15 May 2014, para 19

(#P233_13286) Ibid, para 22

(#P236_13746) Ibid, para 25

(#P239_14118) Ibid, para 26

(#P244_14327) Ibid, para 29

(#P253_15067) Ibid, para 28; See also Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix B

(#P254_15239) MFB Outline of Submissions dated 15 May 2014, para 30; per UFU v CFA [2014] FCA [17], at [132]-[133]; Parks Victoria v The Australian Workers' Union [2013] FWCFB 950, at [369].

(#P269_17010) Ibid, para 32

(#P274_17744) Exhibit MFB 55, para 17.1

(#P285_19526) MFB Outline of Submissions dated 15 May 2014, para 33 - 36

(#P290_19835) (1999) 91 IR 184

(#P291_20066) MFB Outline of Submissions, dated 15 May 2014, para 39

(#P294_20577) FW Act, s.226(b)(i) and (ii)

(#P297_21085) MFB Outline of Submissions dated 15 May 2014, para 40

(#P298_21424) Ibid, para 41

(#P301_21599) Ibid, para 42

(#P302_21773) Ibid, para 43

(#P307_22340) Exhibit UFU 5, para 2

(#P312_22985) Ibid, para 20

(#P315_23198) Ibid, para 21

(#P330_25102) Ibid, paras 31 - 32

(#P333_25411) Ibid

(#P336_25782) Ibid, para 33

(#P337_25955) Ibid, para 34

(#P342_26387) Ibid, para 37

(#P347_27164) Ibid, para 39

(#P354_28035) Ibid, paras 40 - 42

(#P357_28238) Ibid, para 47

(#P358_28522) Ibid, para 48

(#P361_28983) (1999) 91 IR 184, at [44]

(#P364_29280) Exhibit UFU 5, para 46

(#P367_29562) [2010] FWA 6468[2010] FWA 6468; , (2010) 204 IR 243

(#P370_30211) Ibid, at [33]

(#P373_30564) Exhibit UFU 5, para 59; relying upon Re Tahmoor Coal Pty Ltd [2010] FWA 6468; (2010) 204 IR 243, at [58]

(#P374_30959) Ibid, paras 63 - 64

(#P375_31243) Ibid, para 67

(#P378_31906) Ibid, para 72

(#P379_32231) [2010] FWA 6468; (2010) 204 IR 243, at [55]

(#P382_32577) MFB Outline of Submissions dated 15 May 2014, para 76

(#P387_33218) Ibid, para 78

(#P390_33638) Ibid, para 83

(#P395_34412) Ibid, para 81 - 82

(#P400_34937) Ibid, para 84

(#P403_35206) Ibid, para 85

(#P406_36238) Ibid, para 86, citing Re Mount Thorley (1999) 91 IR 184 at 192 at [47]

(#P409_36681) Ibid, para 88 - 89

(#P410_37259) Ibid, paras 93 - 94

(#P413_37589) Ibid, para 100

(#P418_38119) Citing Australian Electoral Commission v Hickson (1997) 76 IR 399; per Branson and Marshall JJ at 416

(#P429_40765) Exhibit UFU 5, paras 102 - 107

(#P436_41463) Ibid, para 109 - 110

(#P439_41615) MFB Outline of Submissions dated 15 May 2014, para 45

(#P440_42015) Exhibit UFU 5, para 112

(#P447_42919) MFB Outline of Submissions dated 15 May 2014, paras 46 - 47

(#P458_43725) Exhibit UFU 5, paras 114 - 117

(#P461_43982) Exhibit MFB 55, para 18

(#P462_44443) Ibid, para 7.1

(#P465_44698) (2005) 139 IR 34

(#P466_44804) [2010] FWA 2434

(#P467_45003) Exhibit MFB 55, para 7.6

(#P468_45192) Ibid, para 7.5

(#P491_46584) Exhibit MFB 3, tab 6; AG790039 (1999) Print R5723

(#P492_46896) Ibid, cl. 6.2

(#P497_47386) Ibid, cl. 9.2.2

(#P500_47817) Ibid, cl. 9.2.5

(#P515_48986) Ibid, cl. 12.1

(#P530_50798) Ibid, cl 19.1

(#P543_51964) Ibid, cl. 23.1

(#P546_52364) Ibid, cl. 20

(#P551_52520) Exhibit MFB 3, tab 4; AG819934 (2002) Print PR925132

(#P552_52815) Ibid, cl. 6.2

(#P553_52975) Ibid, cl. 4.1

(#P556_53326) 1999 Agreement, cl. 11

(#P583_57265) 2002 Agreement, sch. 2, cl. 4.6.5

(#P598_58427) Exhibit MFB 3, tab 3; AG848710 (2006) PR971796

(#P599_58615) Ibid, cl 4.2

(#P600_58964) Ibid, cl. 6.1.3 and schedule 8; the reference to "the VFIEI Award" is apparently a reference to the Victorian Firefighting Industry Employees Interim Award 2000 (code AP801881)

(#P603_59722) Ibid, cll. 9.1 and 9.2.5

(#P604_59952) Ibid, cl. 12.9

(#P605_60296) Exhibit MFB 10, para 20

(#P610_60654) Exhibit MFB 3, tab 3, AG84710 (2006) PR971796, cll. 9.2.2 and 4.5.1

(#P611_60958) Ibid, sch. 2, cl 4.6.5 and 4.7.4

(#P618_61361) [2010] FWAA 7414, AE881005 (PR501990) Roe C

(#P619_61617) Ibid, cl 4.1

(#P620_61884) Ibid, cl 6.3

(#P625_62479) [2010] FWAA 7413

(#P630_62974) [2010] FWAA 7414, cl 13.1

(#P631_63315) Ibid, cl.15

(#P634_63568) Exhibit MFB 55, para 3; see also 2010 ACFO Agreement, cl.8

(#P637_64276) clause 19.4

(#P673_66189) Exhibits MFB 7 and 8

(#P675_66258) Exhibits MFB 10 and 11

(#P677_66334) Exhibits MFB 12 and 13

(#P679_66445) Exhibits MFB 14 and 15

(#P681_66528) Exhibit MFB 17

(#P683_66585) Exhibits MFB 18 and 19

(#P685_66711) Exhibits MFB 20 and 21

(#P687_66780) Exhibits MFB 22 and 23

(#P689_66838) Exhibits MFB 25 and 26

(#P691_66927) Exhibits MFB 27 and 28

(#P693_67011) Exhibits MFB 29 and 30

(#P695_67147) Exhibits MFB 31 and 32

(#P697_67198) Exhibits MFB 33 and 34

(#P699_67268) Exhibits MFB 35 and 36

(#P701_67397) Exhibits MFB 37, 38 and 39

(#P706_67740) Exhibit UFU 3

(#P708_67892) Exhibit UFU 6

(#P710_67971) Exhibit UFU 14

(#P712_68067) Exhibit UFU 16

(#P714_68133) Exhibit UFU 17

(#P716_68205) Exhibit UFU 19

(#P718_68294) Exhibit UFU 20

(#P720_68369) Exhibit UFU 21

(#P722_68427) Exhibit UFU 23

(#P724_68482) Exhibit UFU 25

(#P726_68544) Exhibit UFU 27

(#P728_68617) Exhibit UFU 28

(#P730_68694) Exhibit UFU 29

(#P732_68793) Exhibit UFU 30

(#P734_68846) Exhibit UFU 31

(#P736_68899) Exhibit UFU 32

(#P738_68955) Exhibit UFU 33

(#P740_69014) Exhibit UFU 34

(#P742_69074) Exhibit UFU 35

(#P744_69129) Exhibit UFU 36

(#P746_69189) Exhibit UFU 37

(#P748_69246) Exhibit UFU 38

(#P751_69561) Exhibit UFU 46

(#P752_69734) Exhibit UFU 48

(#P757_70135) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendices D to FF

(#P766_71901) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix O; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 424 - 427

(#P769_72249) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix S; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 439 - 448

(#P772_72563) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix M; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 411 - 417

(#P773_72694) [2013] FWC 4758

(#P776_72805) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix V; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 466 - 474

(#P777_72974) Ibid, para 1

(#P780_73328) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendices BB and EE; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 534 - 545

(#P783_73590) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix J; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 392 - 397

(#P784_73871) Exhibit MFB 29, para 25

(#P785_74047) Ibid, para 46

(#P790_74291) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix D; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 366 - 371

(#P791_74418) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix DD; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 555 - 559

(#P798_74974) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix I; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 388 - 391

(#P799_75148) Exhibit MFB 27, para 175

(#P802_75403) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix FF; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 561 - 583

(#P805_75725) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix U; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 462 - 465

(#P806_75885) Exhibit UFU 75, para 462 - 465

(#P809_75987) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix AA; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 531 - 533

(#P810_76204) Exhibit MFB 25, para 103

(#P811_76266) Exhibit UFU 75, para 531

(#P812_76448) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix AA, para 1

(#P817_76687) Exhibit UFU 75, paras 532 - 533

(#P820_76782) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix K; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 398 - 402

(#P821_77178) Exhibit MFB 27, para 74

(#P822_77399) Exhibit MFB 8, para 98

(#P823_77747) Exhibit UFU 75, para 399

(#P826_77838) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix R; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 434 - 438

(#P827_78370) Exhibit MFB 27, para 110

(#P828_78570) Ibid, para 130

(#P831_78892) Exhibit UFU 75, para 438

(#P834_79036) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix E; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 372 - 378

(#P835_79440) Ibid, para 6

(#P838_79508) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix G; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 381 - 384

(#P839_80060) Exhibit MFB 25, para 74

(#P842_80375) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix CC; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 546 - 554

(#P843_80680) C2013/3358, 20 March 2013

(#P844_81093) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix CC; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 546 - 554

(#P849_82056) Exhibit UFU 75, para 553 - 554

(#P852_82201) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix F; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 379 - 380

(#P855_82769) Exhibit UFU 75, para 379

(#P858_82876) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix Q; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 434 - 438

(#P859_83220) Exhibit MFB 25, para 203

(#P860_83538) Ibid, para 235 - 238

(#P863_83879) Exhibit UFU 75, para 437

(#P866_83976) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix P; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 428 - 433

(#P867_84327) Exhibit MFB 25, at para 92

(#P870_84556) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix T; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 449 - 461

(#P871_84838) Exhibit MFB 31, paras 56 - 58

(#P872_85195) Exhibit 75, para 451

(#P875_85355) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix Y; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 507 - 526

(#P880_86594) Exhibit MFB 14, para 173 - 174

(#P883_87040) Ibid, para 177

(#P886_87443) Ibid, para 180

(#P889_87611) Exhibit UFU 75, para 509

(#P890_87890) Ibid, para 512

(#P895_89159) Ibid, paras 522 - 523

(#P898_89294) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix H; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 385 - 387

(#P899_89457) Exhibits MFB 27, para 74; MFB 8, para 98

(#P900_89652) Exhibit MFB 22, paras 29 - 30

(#P903_89797) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix Z; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 527 - 530

(#P908_90814) Ibid, para 1

(#P913_91010) Exhibit UFU 75, para 528

(#P920_91852) Victorian Government (Melbourne, December 2012) accessible at www.dpc.vic.gov.au

(#P923_92585) Ibid, contained within Exhibit MFB 18, p 70

(#P928_93310) Ibid, p 82

(#P935_93639) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix L; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 403 - 410

(#P938_93772) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix N; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 418 - 423

(#P941_93917) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix W; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 475 - 495

(#P944_94054) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix X; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 496 - 506

(#P955_95159) Exhibit MFB 14, para 43

(#P956_95465) Exhibit MFB 15, para 11

(#P959_95618) Exhibit UFU 75, para 497

(#P998_99602) Exhibit MFB 14, paras 35 - 36

(#P1021_101564) Exhibit MFB 7, paras 24 - 28

(#P1026_102354) Exhibit MFB 55, para 17.1

(#P1027_102963) MFB Outline of Submissions dated 15 May 2014, para 29

(#P1030_103435) Exhibit UFU 75, para 49 - 50

(#P1031_103659) Ibid, para 51

(#P1032_103870) Ibid, para 57

(#P1033_104104) Ibid, para 69

(#P1036_104427) [1998] FCA 551; (1999) 83 FCR 346, at p 354

(#P1041_104951) Exhibit MFB 55, para 4.7

(#P1044_105130) [1947] HCA 26; (1947) 74 CLR 31

(#P1055_106381) [1995] HCA 71; (1995) 184 CLR 188, at [42]

(#P1062_108306) Re Australian Education Union; Ex parte Victoria [1995] HCA 71; (1995) 184 CLR 188, at 232, per Mason CJ, Brennan, Deane, Toohey, Gaudron, McHugh JJ

(#P1065_108559) Parks Victoria v The Australian Workers' Union and others [2013] FWCFB 950

(#P1072_109743) Ibid, at [294] - [295]

(#P1087_111776) United Firefighters Union of Australia v Country Fire Authority [2014] FCA 17, at [103] - [106]

(#P1090_111964) The decision concerns the Country Fire Authority/United Firefighters' Union of Australia Operational Staff Enterprise Agreement 2010, approved by the FWC on 21 October 2010

(#P1093_112888) [2014] FCA 17, at [133]

(#P1109_113279) Ibid, at [10]

(#P1118_115434) [2010] FWA 6468; (2010) 204 IR 243, at [30]

(#P1121_115998) (2005) 139 IR 34, at [23]

(#P1144_117790) Exhibit UFU 75, para 42

(#P1147_117901) Exhibit MFB 55, para 7.5

(#P1148_118050) (1999) Print S0542

(#P1149_118125) [2010] FWA 6468; (2010) 204 IR 243

(#P1164_118657) Exhibit 55, para 7.6

(#P1165_118795) (1999) Print S0542, at [41]

(#P1166_118895) Ibid, at [41], see elements (b), (d), (e) and (f)

(#P1169_119112) [2010] FWA 2434

(#P1170_119625) Ibid, at [13]

(#P1173_120163) Ibid, at [14]

(#P1176_120233) [2013] FWC 5385

(#P1177_120442) Ibid, at [35]

(#P1180_121461) 139 IR 34, at [23]

(#P1183_121888) [2010] FWA 6468; (2010) 204 IR 243, at [46]

(#P1188_123042) [2010] FWA 3483, at [21]; see also Re Mt Thorley Operations (1999) 91 IR 184, at [42]; ERA v LHMU [2010] FWA 2434, at [18], [27]; SDV Australia Pty Ltd [2013] FWC 5385, at [37] - [42]

(#P1191_123313) PR977415 and PR976734

(#P1192_123347) PR982556

(#P1193_123392) Print Q6511 (December 1999)

(#P1204_125090) [2010] FWA 3483, at [26] - [27]

(#P1241_128592) [2010] FWA 3483, at [30] - [34]

(#P1280_131755) [2010] FWA 2434

(#P1291_133680) Ibid, at [24] - [27]

(#P1294_133751) [2010] FWA 6468; (2010) 204 IR 243

(#P1301_135483) Ibid, at [49] - [51]

(#P1304_135621) [2013] FWC 5385, at [36] - [42]

(#P1305_135689) [2010] FWA 3483, at [30] - [32]

(#P1308_136719) Ibid, at [21]

(#P1313_137067) [2010] FWA 3434, at [6]

(#P1316_137602) Ibid, see [8] - [10], [12]

(#P1319_138013) [2010] FWA 3483, see [2], [8], [11]

(#P1322_138401) [2013] FWC 5385, see [1], [3], 48] - [49]

(#P1325_139017) [2010] FWA 6468; (2010) 204 IR 243, at [55]

(#P1330_140284) Ibid, at [46]

(#P1341_143783) Operational Staff Agreement, cl.4.1

(#P1344_144247) [2010] FWA 3434, at [6]

(#P1351_145551) Ibid, at [29] - [ 31]

(#P1354_145831) [2010] FWA 6468; (2010) 204 IR 243, at [54]; following ERA v LHMU [2010] FWA 2434, at [29]

(#P1355_146088) Ibid

(#P1362_147307) cf ERA v LHMU [2010] FWA 2434, at [14]

(#P1363_147613) [2010] FWA 6468; (2010) 204 IR 243, at [55]

(#P1386_150540) See, for example, Exhibit UFU 14, para 131; Exhibit UFU 35, para 7

(#P1389_150671) Exhibit UFU 16, para 138

(#P1392_150834) Exhibit UFU 29, para 26

(#P1395_150925) Exhibit UFU 31, para 36; Exhibit UFU 43, para 21; Exhibit UFU 74, statement of Rebecca Locke, para 3

(#P1398_151190) Exhibit UFU 31, para 43; Exhibit UFU 6, para 79; Exhibit UFU 36, para 33

(#P1401_151410) Exhibit UFU 74, statement of Michael Pratt, para 8

(#P1404_151821) Exhibit UFU 3, para 41

(#P1407_151960) Exhibit UFU 57, para 14; Exhibit UFU 68, para 8; Exhibit UFU 74, statement of John Topic, para 9; Exhibit UFU 74, statement of Rebecca Locke, para 3

(#P1410_152335) Exhibit UFU 34, para 12

(#P1413_152830) Ibid, para 13

(#P1416_153159) Exhibit UFU 28, para 24

(#P1419_153254) Ibid, para 25

(#P1422_153418) Exhibit UFU 27, para 3

(#P1425_153514) Exhibit UFU 74, statement of Ian Porter, para 3; Exhibit UFU 27, para 3

(#P1428_153665) Exhibit UFU 33, para 31, Exhibit UFU 74, statement of John Topic, para 11

(#P1433_154350) Exhibit MFB 55, para 20.2

(#P1436_154643) Exhibit UFU 46

(#P1437_154894) Exhibit UFU 23, para 10

(#P1438_155060) Ibid, para 6

(#P1443_155226) Ibid, para 11

(#P1470_157702) Exhibit UFU 46, p 10, item (g)

(#P1477_159660) Ibid, p 9

(#P1480_159896) Ibid

(#P1487_160882) Ibid, p 10

(#P1490_161108) Exhibit MFB 51

(#P1491_161271) MFB 55, para 20.5(c)

(#P1492_161707) Exhibit MFB 51

(#P1495_161981) (1959) 101 CLR 298

(#P1498_162300) The UFU Victorian Branch Secretary

(#P1527_167214) Exhibit UFU 8, p 2

(#P1540_167763) Exhibit MFB 7, para 24

(#P1543_168334) Exhibit UFU 8, p 5

(#P1544_168463) Ibid, p 12

(#P1583_172559) Exhibit MFB 7, paras 10 - 19

(#P1590_173216) See for example, Exhibit MFB 37, paras 49 - 53

(#P1597_173671) Exhibit UFU 5, para 60

(#P1600_173878) Exhibit UFU 23, para 10

(#P1603_174802) Transcript, PN 9653

(#P1620_178391) Extract from Transcript, PN 7517 - 7538

(#P1650_181067) Exhibit MFB 55, para 32.3

(#P1655_181457) Exhibit MFB 55, para 21.1

(#P1674_182447) MA000111

(#P1675_182645) Exhibit UFU 5, para 71; also Exhibit UFU 75, para 52

(#P1676_183016) Exhibit MFB 55, para 9.9; see also Exhibit MFB 2, tab 7, Metropolitan Fire and Emergency Services Board, Commanders Interim Award 2002, AP839447

(#P1677_183382) See for example Exhibits MFB 5, cl.25; 29; MFB 55, para 32.7;

(#P1680_183935) Exhibit UFU 5, para 32

(#P1681_184246) Ibid, para 31

(#P1686_184830) Exhibit MFB 55, paras 9.2 - 9.3

(#P1693_186021) Exhibit UFU 75, para 97 - 98; in relation to Commanders, the UFU notes Commanders who held the position of the now defunct rank of Inspector are covered by the MFB Commanders Interim Award 2002 in which a modernisation application is reserved.

(#P1696_186891) Exhibit MFB 55, para 41.1

(#P1699_187365) Exhibit MFB 55, para 9.7

(#P1732_189556) Amended by the MFB to 18 months - see Exhibit 55, para 41.1

(#P1735_190211) [2010] FWA 6468; (2010) 204 IR 243, at [13]

(#P1738_190753) [2010] FWA 3483, at [35]

(#P1755_194131) 1999 Agreement, cl. 11

(#P1756_194283) Ibid, cl.9.3.4

(#P1759_194787) 2002 Agreement, cl.9.1

(#P1770_196300) FW Act, s.205(1)

(#P1773_196382) [2010] FCAFC 150; (2010) 204 IR 142, per Keane CJ and Marshall J

(#P1780_198763) Ibid, at [14]

(#P1783_200247) See also [32] and [37]

(#P1786_200432) [1987] HCA 28; (1987) 163 CLR 117

(#P1791_201454) Ibid, at p.135, per Mason CJ, Wilson, Brennan, Deane, Dawson, Toohey, Gaudron JJ

(#P1794_201929) Transcript, PN 11289

(#P1803_203925) 2010 Operational Staff Agreement, cl.15 and cl.13.3.2

(#P1804_204070) Ibid, cl.88

(#P1805_204360) Ibid, cl.19.1

(#P1808_204768) Exhibit MFB 5, cl.10.1(a) and 15.2

(#P1809_205147) Ibid

(#P1812_205259) Ibid, cl.15.4(h)

(#P1813_205658) Exhibit UFU 75, paras 291 - 293

(#P1834_206893) Fire Fighting Industry Award 2010 (MA000111), cll. 8.1, 9.1 and 9.4

(#P1835_207152) Exhibit MFB 55, para 33.5

(#P1846_208863) Exhibit MFB 5, Sch.1

(#P1918_212337) MFB Outline of Submissions dated 15 May 2014, para 46 - 47

(#P1925_212820) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix M; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 411 - 417

(#P1926_212915) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix V; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 466 - 474

(#P1927_213044) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix S; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 439 - 448

(#P1928_213156) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendices BB and EE; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 534 - 545

(#P1929_213268) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix G; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 381 - 384

(#P1930_213363) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix P; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 428 - 433

(#P1931_213471) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix AA; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 531 - 533

(#P1934_214132) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix Z; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 527 - 530

(#P1935_214261) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendices BB and EE; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 534 - 545

(#P1940_214777) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix E; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 372 - 378

(#P1943_214898) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix H; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 385 - 387

(#P1946_214989) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix I; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 388 - 391

(#P1949_215213) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix K; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 398 - 402

(#P1952_215295) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix Q; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 434 - 438

(#P1955_215404) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix R; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 434 - 438

(#P1958_215544) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix T; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 449 - 461

(#P1961_215655) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix U; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 462 - 465

(#P1964_215812) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix W; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 475 - 495

(#P1967_216043) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix X; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 496 - 506

(#P1970_216178) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix Y; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 507 - 526

(#P1973_216278) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix CC; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 546 - 554

(#P1976_216385) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix FF; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 561 - 583

(#P1981_216632) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix O; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 424 - 427

(#P1982_216770) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix D; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 366 - 371

(#P1983_216881) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix DD; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 555 - 559

(#P1986_217243) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix F; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 379 - 380

(#P1987_217356) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix L; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 403 - 410

(#P1988_217463) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix N; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 418 - 423

(#P1989_217707) Exhibit MFB 5, Sch 1, cl.2.2

(#P1992_217833) Exhibit UFU 75, paras 101, 128

(#P1993_218028) Ibid, paras 292 - 293

(#P1994_218374) Modern Award, cl.9.1

(#P1995_218492) Exhibit MFB 55, para 33.5

(#P2014_221170) See Exhibits MFB 55, Appendix E; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 372 - 378

(#P2017_221980) Exhibit MFB 25, para 155

(#P2022_222329) Ibid, para 159

(#P2029_223381) An Assistant Chief Fire Officer

(#P2032_223939) Exhibit UFU 14, paras 118 - 120

(#P2035_224202) Transcript, PN 6627 - 6631

(#P2036_224334) Transcript, PN 7262

(#P2039_225425) Transcript, PN 6667

(#P2042_225895) Exhibit MFB 26, para 13; Transcript, PN 3121

(#P2049_227509) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix R; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 434 - 438

(#P2050_228434) Exhibit MFB 27, para 110

(#P2051_228576) Transcript, PN 1213

(#P2060_231189) Exhibit UFU 14, paras 102 - 105

(#P2069_231757) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix K; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 398 - 402

(#P2070_232214) Exhibit MFB 27, para 40

(#P2071_232400) Exhibit UFU 21, paras 28 - 29

(#P2072_232475) Exhibit MFB 27, para 74

(#P2075_232879) Exhibit MFB 28, para 35

(#P2080_233937) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix K, para 3

(#P2091_235477) Exhibit MFB 22, paras 27 - 30

(#P2094_235835) Transcript, PN 7068 - 7069

(#P2101_236812) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix Y; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 507 - 526

(#P2102_237251) Exhibit MFB 14, para 174

(#P2103_237712) Ibid, para 177

(#P2104_237823) Exhibit UFU 21, p.48

(#P2107_238472) Exhibit MFB 14, para 180; pp.370-378; see also C2014/2674

(#P2110_238765) Exhibit UFU 21, para 55

(#P2111_238983) Ibid, paras 34 - 44

(#P2114_239309) Ibid, para 51

(#P2125_240250) Ibid, para 48

(#P2128_240950) Exhibit MFB 15, paras 20 - 24

(#P2133_241383) Exhibit MFB 7, para 60

(#P2140_242198) Ibid, paras 66 - 67

(#P2145_243616) Transcript, PN 1680

(#P2230_248926) Exhibit UFU 21, para 52

(#P2233_249418) Exhibit MFB 7, paras 83 - 84

(#P2247_250316) Ibid, pp.139-140, Attachment PR-15

(#P2250_250475) Transcript, PN 401 - 403, incorrectly transcribed

(#P2251_250653) Macquarie Dictionary, (5th ed, 2009), p.545

(#P2254_251152) Exhibit MFB 7, para 73, and Attachment PR-11

(#P2255_252054) Operational Staff Agreement, cl.13.3.1 and 13.3.3

(#P2280_255773) See FW Act, Pt 2-5, Div 3 and Div 4

(#P2289_257047) [2014] FCAFC 84

(#P2308_264127) [2010] FWA 6468; (2010) 204 IR 243, at [54] - [55]

(#P2327_266678) [2010] FWA 6468; (2010) 204 IR 243, at [70]

(#P2332_267529) Ibid, at [59]

(#P2341_269088) Ibid, at [65] - [70]

(#P2344_269624) Exhibit MFB 18, para 6

(#P2367_270987) Exhibit MFB 19, para 11

(#P2372_271510) Exhibit MFB 8, paras 61 - 63

(#P2385_272765) Exhibit MFB 19, para 16-17

(#P2390_273125) Exhibit UFU 75, para 177

(#P2407_278398) See FW Act, Pt 2-5, Div 3 and Div 4

(#P2420_279919) Exhibit MFB 55, para 20.8

(#P2467_287263) Transcript, PN 10533 - 10536

(#P2470_288164) Referred to in Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix T and Exhibit UFU 75, para 449 - 465

(#P2471_288542) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix F; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 379 - 380

(#P2472_288666) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix L; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 403 - 410

(#P2473_288782) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix D; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 366 - 371

(#P2474_288908) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix DD; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 555 - 559

(#P2475_289023) Exhibit MFB 55, Appendix P; Exhibit UFU 75, paras 428 - 433

(#P2476_289306) Transcript, PN 1570 - 1575

Printed by authority of the Commonwealth Government Printer