Bowen-James v Walton and Ors (NSW Court of Appeal, 5/8/91, unreported)
Bridges v Law Society of New South Wales [1983] 2 NSWLR 361 at 362
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
Source
Original judgment source is linked above.
Catchwords
Basser v Medical Board of Victoria [1981] VR 53Bowen-James v Walton and Ors (NSW Court of Appeal, 5/8/91, unreported)Bridges v Law Society of New South Wales [1983] 2 NSWLR 361 at 362Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336CES v Superclinics (Aust) Pty Ltd (1995) 38 NSWLR 47Davis (2 December 1994)Ex parte EvattRe New South Wales Bar Association (1969) 71 SR (NSW) 153WN (Pt 2)(NSW) 50Furey (23 December 2002)Gianoutsos v Glykis [2006] NSWCCA 137HCCC v Litchfield (1997) 41 NSWLR 630CASES CITED: Law Society of NSW v Foreman (1994) 34 NSWLR 408McBride v Walton (NSWCA 15 July 1994, BC 9402907)Medical Practitioners Board of Victoria v McGoldrick [1999] VSCA 215New South Wales Bar Association v Seymour (Court of Appeal, 14 April 1982, unreported)New South Wales Bar Association v Cummins (2002) 52 NSWLR 279Pillai v Messiter (No. 2) (1989) 16 NSWLR 197Prothonotary of the Supreme Court of New South Wales v McCaffery [2004] NSWCA 470
Prothonotary of the Supreme Court of New South Wales v Ritchard (Court of Appeal, 31 July 1987, unreported)
R v Suman Sood (04/11/1102)
R v Wald [1971]3 NSWDCR 25
Richter v Walton (NSW Court of Appeal, 15/9/93, unreported)
Rogers v Whitaker (1992) 175 CLR 279
Judgment (98 paragraphs)
[1]
See Schedule 4 Part 4 Clause 11 of the Health Care Complaints Act 1993 which provides that an amendment made to a health registration Act (including the Medical Practice Act) by the Health Registration Legislation Amendment Act 2004 does not apply to a complaint that was referred to a Committee or Tribunal under the health registration Act before the commencement of the amendment or to a complaint where an inquiry into it had commenced before the commencement of the amendment
[2]
Ex. E Tab 20 p. 1
[3]
Dr Healey Ex G Tab 3 T 13
[4]
Ex E Tab 21 p 3
[5]
Ex E Tab 17 p. 21
[6]
Dr Goldstone Ex E Tab 20 p.2.
[7]
Dr Healy Ex G Tab 3 T 145.12
[8]
Ex E Tab 7
[9]
Dr Healy in Ex G Tab 3 T145/14-55
[10]
Dr Gastaldin Ex G Tab 2 [13]; Dr Healy Ex E Tab 18 p 5-6 and in Ex G Tab 3 at T145/45.
[11]
Dr Healy exhibit AA [10]
[12]
Ex E Tab 14 p.2
[13]
Ex E Tab 18 p.4
[14]
See ambulance report Ex E Tab 14
[15]
Ibid.
[16]
Ibid.
[17]
Ex E Tab 17
[18]
Dr Healy Ex E Tab 18 p 5
[19]
Dr Healy in Ex G Tab 3at T149/20-25
[20]
See record at Ex E Tab 7
[21]
Ex E Tab 18
[22]
Dr Healy 23 October 1999 (Ex E Tab 18).
[23]
Dr Healy Ex E Tab 18 [5]
[24]
Dr Healy in Ex G Tab 3at T147/25-40
[25]
Dr Goldstone Ex E Tab 20 p 3
[26]
Ex E Tab 23
[27]
Ex E Tab 23 [10]
[28]
Quantik Ex E Tab 30 [1]
[29]
Zoretic Ex E Tab 28
[30]
Mafiti Ex E Tab 29
[31]
Ibid.
[32]
Allen Ex E Tab 27 [10]
[33]
Ex E Tab 26. Handwritten notes.
[34]
Zoretic Ex E Tab 28[14]
[35]
Ibid.
[36]
Ex E Tab 32
[37]
Ex E Tab 28 [7]
[38]
ibid
[39]
Dr Goldstone Ex G Tab 5 p 1
[40]
Ex E Tab 31p 2
[41]
Ex E Tab 26 p.6
[42]
Sood Ex E Tab 25[9]
[43]
Sood Ex E Tab 25 [14]
[44]
Ex E Tab 28
[45]
Ex G Tab 7 p.2
[46]
Ex E Tab 39
[47]
Dr Goldstone's evidence in this matter at T95/11-17
[48]
Ex G Tab 37 Letter from Ms Sood to HCCC 12 March 2003
[49]
Ex G Tab 7
[50]
Ex F Tab 15
[51]
Ex L T 728-23
[52]
Ex P
[53]
Dr Brodie Ex F Tab 16 p. 7
[54]
E.g. ND was given Misoprostal and told it would make the uterus softer.
[55]
Dr Peat said this was the most likely drug: Ex L T 1064.21
[56]
The Tribunal has made a number of references to Dr Allen in these reasons. He did not give evidence before the Tribunal so our sources of information about his role in matters is documentary only.
[57]
TLT 593.5-10
[58]
Ex L T964: Dr Brodie.
[59]
Ex LT965/11
[60]
Dr Brodie Ex F Tab 16 p7
[61]
Dr Brodie Ex F Tab 16 pp 5-6
[62]
Ex G Tab 12 5.2
[63]
Ex L T1060/55-1061/5
[64]
Dr Brodie Ex F Tab 16 p 6 and Ex L T964/15-22
[65]
Dr Brodie Ex L T991
[66]
See Dr Kuah's evidence to the s 66 enquiry. Ex H Tab 5 p 9
[67]
Ex L T1065/49
[68]
Ex L T1067/28-32
[69]
Ex L T1066/1 and Ex F [25]
[70]
Ex F Tab 16 p. 11
[71]
Dr Gastaldin Ex F Tab 11[6]
[72]
Dr Peat Ex F Tab 17 p 1-2
[73]
Dr Gastaldin Ex F Tab 11[6]
[74]
Dr Peat Ex F Tab 17 p 2. C.f. Dr Gastaldin Ex F Tab 11[6]
[75]
MIMS 1-1
[76]
Dr Brodie Ex F Tab 16 p 6
[77]
Dr Peat Ex F Tab 17 p 2
[78]
Ex F Tab 1 para [17]
[79]
Dr Goldstone T79/25,56
[80]
Dr Healy Ex AA [14]
[81]
Butterworths Medical Dictionary (2nd Edition)
[82]
Ex F Tab 29 p.4
[83]
Pillai [[18]]
[84]
Ex G Tab 9
[85]
She wrote two scripts, not one, and then failed to read the label on the injection when she administered it. The Committee found this suggested a lack of concentration which could have resulted in "disastrous consequences" for the patient.
[86]
Report of Professional Standards Committee 28 July 1997 p 29
[87]
Report of Professional Standards Committee 28 July 1997 p 29-30
[88]
Report of Professional Standards Committee 28 July 1997 p 30
[89]
Report of Professional Standards Committee 28 July 1997 p 26
[90]
Report of Professional Standards Committee 28 July 1997 p 28
[91]
Report of the Professional Standards Committee 28 July 1997 p 28
[92]
Report of Professional Standards Committee 28 July 1997 p 30.8
[93]
Report of Professional Standards Committee 28 July 1997 p 30
[94]
Report of Professional Standards Committee 28 July 1997 p 31.3
[95]
Ex N
[96]
T 207
[97]
Ex 'AK'
[98]
Adopted by the Court in Health Care Complaints Commission v Litchfield (1997) 41 NSWLR 630 at 638
DISCLAIMER - Every effort has been made to comply with suppression orders or statutory provisions prohibiting publication that may apply to this judgment or decision. The onus remains on any person using material in the judgment or decision to ensure that the intended use of that material does not breach any such order or provision. Further enquiries may be directed to the Registry of the Court or Tribunal in which it was generated.
Parties
Applicant/Plaintiff:
Allinson
Respondent/Defendant:
General Council of Medical Education and Registration