(2) An application cannot be made under subsection (1) for a variation that would extend the period of effect of a formal authority in such a way that the period of effect of the authority will, after the variation is made, exceed 24 months (including any previous extensions under this Subdivision or Subdivision B).
(3) An application for the variation may be made:
(a) by means of a written document that is signed by the applicant (such an application is a formal variation application); or
(b) if the applicant has reason to believe that the delay caused by making a formal application for the variation may affect the success of the controlled operation to which the authority relates—orally in person, or by telephone or any other means of communication (such an application is an urgent variation application).
(4) More than one application for a variation under this section may be made in respect of the same authority. However, if an urgent variation of authority was granted as a result of an application under this section, the next application must be a formal variation application.
(5) An application for a variation (whether a formal variation application or an urgent variation application) must state:
(a) whether or not the controlled operation has been the subject of an earlier urgent variation application under this section and, if so:
(i) whether the urgent variation application was the last application under this section for a variation; and
(ii) whether or not the variation was granted; and
(b) the proposed period of the extension, which must be such as to comply with subsection (2) and must not exceed:
(i) in the case of a formal variation application—3 months; and
(ii) in the case of an urgent variation application—7 days.
(6) The nominated Tribunal member may require the applicant to provide such information concerning the proposed variation as is necessary for the nominated Tribunal member’s proper consideration of the application.
(7) As soon as practicable after making an urgent variation application that was not made in writing, the applicant must make a written record of the application and give a copy of it to the nominated Tribunal member to whom the application was made.
15GV Determination of application
(1) After considering an application for a variation of a formal authority, and any additional information provided under subsection 15GU(6), the nominated Tribunal member concerned:
(a) may vary the authority in accordance with the application, either unconditionally or subject to conditions; or
(b) may refuse the application.
(2) The nominated Tribunal member must not grant the variation unless the nominated Tribunal member is satisfied on reasonable grounds:
ZoeLaw is not a law firm. Picks are our opinion; we don't share your details.
(a) that either:
(i) a serious Commonwealth offence or a serious State offence that has a federal aspect has been, is being or is likely to be committed; or
(ii) an integrity testing authority is in effect in relation to an offence that it is suspected has been, is being or is likely to be committed by a staff member of a target agency (see the notes at the foot of this subsection); and
(b) that the nature and extent of the suspected criminal activity are such as to justify the variation; and
(c) that any unlawful conduct involved in conducting the controlled operation will be limited to the maximum extent consistent with conducting an effective controlled operation; and
(d) so far as the conduct involved in the controlled operation is not conducted online—that the operation will be conducted in a way that ensures that, to the maximum extent possible, any illicit goods involved in the controlled operation will be under the control of an Australian law enforcement officer at the end of the controlled operation; and
(e) that the proposed controlled conduct will be capable of being accounted for in a way that will enable the reporting requirements of Division 4 to be complied with; and
(f) that the controlled operation will not be conducted in such a way that a person is likely to be induced to commit a Commonwealth offence or an offence against a law of a State or Territory that the person would not otherwise have intended to commit; and
(g) that any conduct involved in the controlled operation will not:
(i) seriously endanger the health or safety of any person; or
(ii) cause the death of, or serious injury to, any person; or
(iii) involve the commission of a sexual offence against any person; or
(iv) result in significant loss of, or serious damage to, property (other than illicit goods); and
(h) that any role assigned to a civilian participant in the operation is not one that could be adequately performed by a law enforcement officer.
Note 1: Subparagraph (a)(ii) applies in relation to offences punishable on conviction by imprisonment for 12 months or more (see section 15JG).
Note 2: The target agencies mentioned in subparagraph (a)(ii) are the ACC, the Australian Federal Police and the Immigration and Border Protection Department (see section 15GC).
(2A) To avoid doubt:
(a) paragraph (2)(g) only requires the nominated Tribunal member to be satisfied as to the direct and reasonably foreseeable consequences of the unlawful conduct of participants in the controlled operation; and
(b) nothing in subparagraph (2)(g)(iii) is intended to prevent the nominated Tribunal member from varying a formal authority to conduct a controlled operation that will involve a participant:
(i) dealing with material depicting, material describing or material otherwise involving a sexual offence against any person; or
(ii) facilitating a person to deal with such material.
(2B) For the purposes of paragraph (2A)(a), a consequence is a direct consequence of unlawful conduct if the unlawful conduct causes or produces (and is not merely a minor influence on) the consequence without there being any intervening conduct or events.
(3) A variation is not a legislative instrument.
15GW Manner of varying formal authority
(1) A formal authority may be varied by a nominated Tribunal member only:
(a) in the case of a formal variation application (other than a formal variation application referred to in subparagraph (b)(ii))—by means of a written document, signed by the nominated Tribunal member (such a variation is a formal variation of authority); or
(b) in the case of:
(i) an urgent variation application; or
(ii) a formal variation application, if the nominated Tribunal member is satisfied that the delay caused by granting a formal variation of authority may affect the success of the controlled operation;
orally in person, or by telephone or any other means of communication (such a variation is an urgent variation of authority).
(2) The nominated Tribunal member must, as soon as practicable, prepare and give a written document that complies with section 15GX to the applicant.
15GX Form of variation of formal authority
(1) A variation of a formal authority by a nominated Tribunal member (whether formal or urgent) must:
(a) identify the controlled operation to which the authority relates; and
(b) state the name and position of the person varying the authority; and
(c) state the name of the applicant; and
(d) state whether the application for the variation was a formal variation application or an urgent variation application; and
(e) state the date and time when the variation of authority is or was granted; and
(f) state the period of the extension.
(2) The period of the extension:
(a) must not exceed the period that would result in the period of effect of the authority exceeding 24 months (including any previous extensions under this Subdivision or Subdivision B); and
(b) must not exceed:
(i) in the case of a formal variation of authority—3 months; and
(ii) in the case of an urgent variation of authority—7 days.
Subdivision D—Other matters
15GY Cancellation of authorities
(1) An appropriate authorising officer may, by order in writing given to the principal law enforcement officer for a controlled operation, cancel the authority to conduct the controlled operation at any time and for any reason.
(2) Without limiting subsection (1), an appropriate authorising officer may cancel an authority at any time at the request of the principal law enforcement officer for the controlled operation concerned.
(3) Cancellation of an authority takes effect at the time the order is made or at the later time specified in the order.
15GZ Effect of authorities
(1) Subject to subsection (2), an authority:
(a) authorises each law enforcement participant in the controlled operation to which the authority relates who is identified in the authority to engage in the controlled conduct specified in the authority in respect of that participant; and
(b) authorises each civilian participant (if any) in the controlled operation to which the authority relates who is identified in the authority to engage in the particular controlled conduct (if any) specified in the authority in respect of that participant.
(2) A person identified in an authority as being authorised to engage in controlled conduct for the purposes of the controlled operation is authorised to do so for the period of effect of the authority, unless:
(a) the authority specifies a shorter period during which the person is so authorised; or
(b) the authority is varied to provide that the person is no longer so authorised; or
(c) the authority is cancelled before the end of that period.
(3) The authority to engage in controlled conduct given to a participant cannot be delegated to any other person.
15H Defect in authority
An application for an authority or variation of an authority, and any authority or variation of an authority granted on the basis of such an application, is not invalidated by any defect, other than a defect that affects the application, authority or variation in a material particular.
Division 3—Protection from criminal responsibility and related provisions
Subdivision A—Controlled operations under this Part
15HA Protection from criminal responsibility for controlled conduct during controlled operations
(1) This section applies if:
(a) a participant in a controlled operation engages in conduct in the course of, and for the purposes of, the controlled operation; and
(b) engaging in that conduct is a Commonwealth offence or an offence against a law of a State or Territory.
(2) Despite any other law of the Commonwealth, a State or a Territory, the participant is not criminally responsible for the offence, if:
(a) the participant engages in the conduct in accordance with the authority to conduct the controlled operation; and
(b) the participant is identified in the authority as a person authorised to engage in controlled conduct for the purposes of the controlled operation; and
(c) the conduct does not involve the participant intentionally inducing a person to commit a Commonwealth offence or an offence under a law of a State or Territory that the person would not otherwise have intended to commit; and
(d) the conduct does not involve the participant engaging in any conduct that is likely to:
(i) cause the death of, or serious injury to, any person; or
(ii) involve the commission of a sexual offence against any person; and
(e) if the participant is a civilian participant in the operation—he or she acts in accordance with the instructions of a law enforcement officer.
(3) To avoid doubt, nothing in subparagraph (2)(d)(ii) is intended to prevent the participant being protected from criminal responsibility if the conduct involves the participant:
(a) dealing with material depicting, material describing or material otherwise involving a sexual offence against any person; or
(b) facilitating a person to deal with such material.
15HB Indemnification of participants against civil liability
(1) The Commonwealth must indemnify a participant in a controlled operation against any civil liability (including reasonable costs) the participant incurs because of conduct the participant engages in if:
(a) the participant engages in the conduct in the course of, and for the purposes of, the controlled operation in accordance with the authority to conduct the controlled operation; and
(b) the participant is identified in the authority as a person authorised to engage in controlled conduct for the purposes of the controlled operation; and
(c) the conduct does not involve the participant intentionally inducing a person to commit a Commonwealth offence or an offence under a law of a State or Territory that the person would not otherwise have intended to commit; and
(d) the conduct does not involve the participant engaging in any conduct that is likely to:
(i) cause the death of, or serious injury to, any person; or
(ii) involve the commission of a sexual offence against any person; and
(e) if the participant is a civilian participant in the operation—he or she acts in accordance with the instructions of a law enforcement officer; and
(f) the requirements (if any) specified in the regulations have been met.
(2) To avoid doubt, nothing in subparagraph (1)(d)(ii) is intended to prevent the participant being indemnified against civil liability if the conduct involves the participant:
(a) dealing with material depicting, material describing or material otherwise involving a sexual offence against any person; or
(b) facilitating a person to deal with such material.
15HC Effect of sections 15HA and 15HB on other laws relating to criminal investigation
Sections 15HA and 15HB do not apply to a person’s conduct that is, or could have been, authorised under Commonwealth law or a law of a State or Territory relating to the following:
(a) arrest or detention of individuals;
(b) searches of individuals;
(c) entry onto, or searches or inspection of, premises;
(d) searches, inspections or seizures of other property;
(e) forensic procedure;
(f) electronic surveillance devices or telecommunications interception;
(g) identification procedures;
(h) the acquisition or use of assumed identities;
(i) any other matter concerning powers of criminal investigation.
15HD Effect of being unaware of variation or cancellation of authority
(1) If an authority to conduct a controlled operation is varied in a way that limits its scope, this Part continues to apply to a participant in the controlled operation as if the authority had not been varied in that way, for so long as the participant:
(a) is unaware of the variation; and
(b) is not reckless about the existence of the variation.
(2) If an authority to conduct a controlled operation is cancelled, this Part continues to apply to a person who was a participant in the controlled operation immediately before the cancellation as if the authority had not been cancelled in that way, for so long as the person:
(a) is unaware of the cancellation; and
(b) is not reckless about the existence of the cancellation.
(3) For the purposes of this section, a person is reckless about the existence of the variation or cancellation of an authority if:
(a) the person is aware of a substantial risk that the variation or cancellation has happened; and
(b) having regard to the circumstances known to the person, it is unjustifiable to take the risk that the authority has not been varied or cancelled.
(4) In this section, a reference to an authority that is cancelled includes, in the case of an integrity testing controlled operation authority, a reference to an authority that has stopped being in effect because the integrity testing authority concerned has stopped being in effect.
Note: See paragraph 15GN(3)(c).
15HE Protection from criminal responsibility for certain ancillary conduct
(1) This section applies if:
(a) a person engages in conduct (the ancillary conduct) that relates to controlled conduct (the related controlled conduct) engaged in by another person; and
(b) engaging in the ancillary conduct is an ancillary offence in relation to the offence constituted by the related controlled conduct.
(2) Despite any other law of the Commonwealth, a State or a Territory, the person who engaged in the ancillary conduct is not criminally responsible for the ancillary offence if, at the time the person engaged in the ancillary conduct, he or she believed the related controlled conduct was being engaged in, or would be engaged in, by a participant in a controlled operation authorised under this Part.
(3) In this section:
ancillary offence, in relation to an offence constituted by related controlled conduct, means a Commonwealth offence or an offence under a law of a State or Territory:
(a) of conspiring to commit the offence constituted by the related controlled conduct; or
(b) of aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring, inciting or being in any way knowingly concerned in, the commission of the offence constituted by the related controlled conduct.
15HF Compensation for property loss or serious damage
(1) If a person suffers loss of or serious damage to property, or personal injury, in the course of, or as a direct result of a controlled operation authorised under this Part, the Commonwealth is liable to pay to the person compensation as agreed between the Commonwealth and the person or, in default of agreement, as determined by action against the Commonwealth in a court of competent jurisdiction.
(2) Subsection (1) does not apply if:
(a) the person suffered the loss, damage or injury in the course of, or as a direct result of, engaging in any criminal activity (other than criminal activity that is controlled conduct); or
(b) the person was a law enforcement participant at the time of suffering the loss, damage or injury.