© 2026 Zoe. All rights reserved.
Zoe is a legal information platform. Always consult the Federal Register of Legislation for authoritative text.
[2013] FWC 1999
Fair Work Commission
2013-04-29
Mr P
Original judgment source is linked above.
(#P41_1613) Transcript PN 127 and 218 and Exhibit A3
(#P42_1754) Ibid PN 162 - 163
(#P43_2004) Ibid PN 164 - 165
(#P44_2220) Ibid PN 166 - 168
(#P47_2335) Ibid PN 621 - 655 and Exhibit A3
(#P52_2949) Ibid PN 228 - 234 and 859 - 860
(#P55_3473) Ibid PN 235 - 241
(#P56_3616) Ibid
(#P59_3796) Ibid PN 243 - 246
(#P64_4208) Ibid PN 182, 187 - 188, 247, 290, 333, 353, 355 - 358 and 617 - 619
(#P65_4342) Ibid PN 248, 334 - 337, 351 and 375
(#P66_4610) Ibid PN 342 - 345 and 350
(#P69_5205) Ibid PN 222 and 352
(#P72_5379) Ibid PN 354, 373 - 374 and 453 - 454
(#P73_5843) Ibid PN 455 - 459 and 598 - 600
(#P74_5977) Ibid PN 463
(#P77_6666) Ibid PN 464 - 468
(#P78_6813) Ibid PN 469
(#P81_7212) Ibid PN 362 - 365 and 372
(#P82_7322) Exhibit R1
(#P83_7506) Transcript PN 366 - 369 and 380
(#P86_7616) Ibid PN 346 - 348
(#P87_7902) Ibid PN 182, 250 - 257, 290 and 601
(#P90_8257) Ibid PN 476 - 477
(#P91_8501) Ibid PN 478
(#P92_8848) Ibid PN 479 - 485
(#P93_8999) Ibid PN 486 - 487
(#P96_9550) Ibid PN 488 - 494 and 888
(#P99_9862) Ibid PN 255 - 258
(#P100_9982) Ibid PN 289
(#P105_10302) Ibid PN 272 - 273 and 865 and Exhibit A2 at Attachment KW2
(#P106_10599) Ibid PN 275, 179 - 180 and 862 - 863
(#P109_11002) Ibid PN 281 - 282, 285, 327 and 329
(#P110_11124) Ibid PN 285 and 306 - 314
(#P111_11330) Ibid PN 332 and 495
(#P112_11481) Ibid PN 319 and 325
(#P113_11751) Ibid PN 326
(#P118_12524) Ibid PN 321
(#P123_12624) Ibid PN 322
(#P126_12836) Ibid PN 283 - 285
(#P127_13205) Ibid PN 286 - 287
(#P130_13432) Ibid PN 294
(#P131_13773) Ibid PN 294 - 296 and 304 - 305
(#P134_14236) Ibid PN 297 and 425 - 426
(#P137_14501) Ibid PN 258, 276 - 277, 280, 295, 306, 447 and 473
(#P138_14798) Ibid PN 259 - 261 and 550
(#P141_15127) Ibid PN 182, 427 - 431 and 884
(#P142_15268) Ibid PN 434 - 435
(#P143_15572) Ibid PN 442 - 444, 449 - 450 and 551
(#P144_15731) Ibid PN 451 and 474 - 475
(#P147_15939) Ibid PN 445 - 446 and 880
(#P148_16093) Ibid PN 452
(#P153_16758) Ibid PN 185, 214 - 215, 220, 496 - 498, 508 - 510, 515 - 518, 520 - 521, 542, 548 - 549, 558 and 612
(#P154_17021) Ibid PN 656 - 657
(#P157_17247) Ibid PN 559 - 565
(#P158_17456) Ibid PN 566 - 567
(#P161_17818) Ibid PN 185, 504 - 507 and 611
(#P164_18165) Ibid PN 216 - 217, 498, 501 - 503, 519, 524, 540, 609 and 892
(#P165_18677) Ibid PN 209 - 211
(#P166_18899) Ibid PN 212
(#P169_19050) Ibid PN 185 and 537
(#P170_19242) Ibid PN 186, 221 and 538
(#P173_19475) Ibid PN 190
(#P174_19656) Ibid PN 220
(#P177_20182) Ibid PN 203 - 205
(#P182_20474) Ibid PN 191 - 199, 223 - 224 and 662 - 668
(#P185_20689) Ibid PN 200 - 201
(#P190_20998) Ibid PN 169 - 176 and 674 - 676 and Exhibit A2 at paragraph 18
(#P191_21140) Ibid PN 177 - 178
(#P196_21346) Ibid PN 677 - 678 and 703
(#P197_21556) Ibid PN 568 - 573
(#P198_21780) Ibid PN 574 - 584
(#P199_21966) Ibid PN 585 - 588
(#P202_22326) Ibid PN 590 - 596
(#P203_22558) Ibid PN 613
(#P208_22971) Ibid PN 706
(#P209_23080) Ibid PN 710
(#P212_23363) Ibid PN 720 and Exhibit R2
(#P213_23551) Ibid PN 721 and Exhibit R3
(#P214_23748) Ibid PN 734 and Exhibit R4
(#P215_23875) Ibid PN 735
(#P218_24066) Ibid PN 744 - 748 and Exhibit R6
(#P219_24198) Ibid PN 756 - 757
(#P220_24440) Ibid PN 762 - 764 and Exhibit R7
(#P223_24695) Ibid PN 769 - 770 and Exhibit R8
(#P226_24942) Ibid PN 775
(#P227_25147) Ibid PN 776 - 777 and Exhibit R9
(#P228_25276) Exhibits R10 and R11
(#P231_25712) Transcript PN 798 - 814 and Exhibits R12 and R13
(#P232_25840) Ibid PN 819
(#P235_26055) Ibid PN 820 - 839
(#P236_26287) Ibid PN 822 - 832
(#P239_26947) Ibid PN 840 - 858
(#P244_27089) Exhibit A4
(#P247_27346) Transcript PN 912
(#P250_28035) Ibid PN 913, 1018 - 1019 and 1038
(#P251_28192) Ibid PN 1020
(#P254_28505) Ibid PN 1021 - 1025
(#P255_28767) Ibid PN 1026 - 1027
(#P258_29363) Ibid PN 915
(#P261_29846) Ibid PN 918 - 920
(#P264_30245) Ibid PN 922 and 937 and Exhibit A4 at paragraphs 15 - 16
(#P267_30997) Ibid PN 923
(#P268_31120) Ibid PN 924
(#P271_31582) Ibid PN 925
(#P274_32009) Ibid PN 929
(#P277_32505) Ibid PN 932 and Exhibit A4 at paragraph 6
(#P278_32694) Ibid PN 932
(#P279_32973) Ibid PN 935 - 936
(#P282_33155) Ibid PN 930 - 931
(#P285_33408) Ibid PN 943 and 945
(#P286_33699) Ibid PN 946 - 949
(#P289_34112) Ibid PN 950 - 955 and 999 - 1000
(#P290_34580) Ibid PN 1001 - 1003
(#P293_35398) Ibid PN 1005 - 1006 and 1014
(#P294_35584) Ibid PN 1041
(#P297_35861) Ibid PN 956 - 957
(#P300_36173) Ibid PN 961 - 966
(#P301_36513) Ibid PN 967, 973 - 976 and 997
(#P302_36687) Ibid PN 968 - 969
(#P303_36790) Ibid PN 970
(#P304_36920) Ibid PN 972 and 977
(#P307_37302) Ibid PN 940 - 942 and 978 and Exhibit A4 at paragraph 11
(#P308_37427) Ibid PN 979 - 980
(#P311_37765) Ibid PN 982 - 986
(#P312_38233) Ibid PN 987 - 988 and 1047
(#P315_38612) Ibid PN 989 - 996
(#P318_39211) Ibid PN 1028 - 1034 and Exhibit A4 at paragraph 17
(#P323_39372) Exhibit A5
(#P326_39718) Ibid at paragraph 10 and Transcript PN 1103 - 1106
(#P327_40026) Transcript PN 1107
(#P330_40211) Ibid PN 1108
(#P331_40410) Ibid PN 1109
(#P334_40678) Ibid PN 1124
(#P335_40967) Ibid PN 1128
(#P338_41120) Ibid PN 1133
(#P339_41629) Ibid PN 1136 - 1139
(#P342_42063) Ibid PN 1149 - 1159
(#P343_42257) Ibid PN 1160 - 1162
(#P346_42740) Ibid PN 1165 - 1170
(#P349_43083) Ibid PN 1172 - 1176
(#P350_43284) Ibid PN 1177 - 1178
(#P355_43420) Exhibit A6
(#P359_43910) Ibid at paragraph 7 and Transcript PN 1207 and 1245
(#P362_44104) Transcript PN 1243
(#P365_44399) Ibid PN 1209 - 1211 and 1229 and Exhibit with A6 at paragraph 10
(#P366_44800) Ibid PN 1212 - 1214 and 1273
(#P369_45172) Ibid PN 1274 - 1280 and 1315
(#P370_45441) Ibid PN 1281 - 1282
(#P373_45858) Ibid PN 1226 and 1283
(#P376_46250) Ibid PN 1219 - 1221 and Exhibit A6 at paragraph 9
(#P379_46487) Ibid PN 1222
(#P380_46842) Ibid PN 1224 - 1225
(#P383_46999) Ibid PN 1231
(#P386_47171) Ibid PN 1232 - 1233 and Exhibit A6 at paragraph 12
(#P387_47654) Ibid PN 1236 - 1237, 1267 - 1270 and 1272
(#P388_47785) Ibid PN 1271
(#P391_48525) Ibid PN 1238 - 1241, 1250 - 1251 and 1288 - 1298
(#P394_48746) Ibid PN 1242
(#P395_48953) Ibid PN 1244
(#P396_49303) Ibid PN 1247 - 1248
(#P399_49595) Ibid PN 1252 - 1253 and 1264
(#P400_49826) Ibid PN 1254 - 1255 and 1284 - 1287
(#P401_50030) Ibid PN 1257 and 1263
(#P402_50263) Ibid PN 1259 and 1316 and Exhibit A6 at paragraph 7
(#P405_51007) Ibid PN 1260 - 1262 and 1318 - 1320
(#P412_51147) Exhibit R16
(#P415_51344) Transcript PN 1352 and 1484
(#P418_51493) Exhibit R16 at paragraphs 37 - 48
(#P419_51709) Ibid at paragraph 43
(#P420_51818) Ibid at paragraph 46
(#P423_52229) Transcript PN 1348 - 1355
(#P426_52755) Ibid PN 1357 - 1359
(#P427_53129) Ibid PN 1360
(#P430_53589) Ibid PN 1361 and Exhibit R17 at paragraph 49
(#P431_53985) Ibid PN 1362 and Exhibit R16 at paragraph 50
(#P432_54118) Ibid PN 1363 - 1365
(#P435_55154) Ibid PN 1366 - 1380
(#P439_55824) Ibid PN 1386 - 1387 and PN 1555 - 1557 and Exhibit R16 at paragraph 8
(#P440_56340) Ibid PN 1388 - 1392
(#P443_56806) Ibid PN 1397 - 1402
(#P446_57057) Ibid PN 1403 - 1408
(#P447_57284) Ibid PN 1409
(#P450_57780) Ibid PN 1412 - 1415 and Exhibit R16 at paragraph 22
(#P453_58407) Ibid PN 1415 and ibid at paragraph 51
(#P454_58585) Ibid PN 1416 - 1417
(#P457_59153) Ibid PN 1418 - 1421 and 1490 - 1495
(#P460_59729) Ibid PN 1422 - 1424
(#P463_60205) Ibid PN 1427 - 1428
(#P464_60515) Ibid PN 1429
(#P467_60797) Ibid PN 1438 - 1439 and Exhibit R16 at paragraph 53
(#P468_61098) Ibid PN 1440 and 1485 - 1487
(#P469_61466) Ibid PN 1440
(#P472_61969) Ibid PN 1442 - 1444
(#P475_62155) Ibid PN 1445 - 1460 and PN 1558 and Exhibit R16 at paragraph 47
(#P476_62317) Ibid PN 1463 and ibid at paragraph 49
(#P479_62922) Ibid PN 1465 - 1471 and ibid
(#P482_63470) Ibid PN 1472
(#P483_63696) Ibid PN 1473
(#P484_63762) Ibid PN 1475
(#P487_64203) Ibid PN 1475
(#P488_64461) Ibid PN 1478
(#P489_64768) Ibid PN 1479
(#P492_65138) Ibid PN 1480 and 1553 - 1554
(#P493_65247) Ibid PN 1559
(#P494_65830) Ibid PN 1560
(#P497_66107) Ibid PN 1481 - 1482
(#P498_66410) Ibid PN 1483
(#P501_66971) Ibid PN 1496 - 1505 and 1579 and 1586 and Exhibit R16 at paragraphs 54 - 60
(#P502_67181) Exhibit R16 at paragraph 59
(#P505_67809) Transcript PN 1540 - 1548
(#P508_68068) Ibid PN 1549 - 1552 and Exhibit R16 at paragraph 62
(#P511_68220) Exhibit R16 at paragraphs 28 - 36
(#P516_68406) Exhibit R17
(#P519_69115) Ibid at paragraph 45and Transcript PN 1674 - 1677
(#P522_69382) Ibid PN 1679
(#P523_70041) Ibid PN 1680 and Exhibit R17 at paragraphs 12 - 17
(#P524_70216) Exhibit R17 at paragraph 43
(#P527_70765) Transcript PN 1600 - 1601 and 1604
(#P528_70976) Ibid PN 1602 - 1603 and 1605 and 1608 and 1622 - 1623 and 1625 - 1627
(#P529_71254) Ibid PN 1624
(#P530_71411) Ibid PN 1636 - 1638
(#P533_71969) Ibid PN 1646 - 1650
(#P534_72196) Exhibit R17 at paragraph 36
(#P537_72381) Transcript PN 1606
(#P538_72498) Ibid PN 1607
(#P539_72878) Ibid PN 1607 - 1608
(#P542_73697) Ibid PN 1740 - 1745
(#P545_74386) Ibid PN 1628 - 1635
(#P548_74949) Ibid PN 1762 - 1763 and Exhibit R17 at paragraphs 21-22
(#P549_75355) Ibid PN 1778 - 1783 and 1845 - 1846
(#P550_75523) Ibid PN 1847
(#P553_76007) Ibid PN 1784 and Exhibit R17 at paragraph 49
(#P554_76236) Exhibit R17 at paragraph 49
(#P557_76631) Transcript PN 1785
(#P560_77254) Ibid PN 1786 - 1789 and Exhibit R17 at paragraph 35
(#P563_77667) Ibid PN 1609
(#P564_78237) Ibid PN 1610 and Exhibit R17 at paragraphs 25 - 34
(#P567_78692) Ibid PN 1615 - 1620
(#P570_79213) Ibid PN 1639 - 1641 and Exhibit R17 at paragraph 5
(#P571_79478) Ibid PN 1642 - 1645
(#P574_80121) Ibid PN 1651 - 1654
(#P577_80796) Ibid PN 1691 - 1693 and 1732 - 1733 and 1835 - 1837 and Exhibit R17 at paragraph 43
(#P580_81145) Ibid PN 1696 - 1703 and 1706 and 1720 and 1726
(#P581_81392) Ibid PN 1720 and Exhibit R17 at paragraph 48
(#P582_81906) Ibid PN 1728 - 1731
(#P583_82286) Ibid PN 1828 - 1842
(#P586_82798) Ibid PN 1694 - 1704 and Exhibit R17 at paragraph 47
(#P589_82967) Ibid PN 1708 - 1711
(#P592_83222) Ibid PN 1790 - 1793
(#P593_83553) Ibid PN 1795 - 1796
(#P594_83887) Ibid PN 1798 - 1805
(#P597_84082) Ibid PN 1806 - 1807
(#P598_84441) Ibid PN 1813 - 1819
(#P599_84521) Exhibit R17 at paragraphs 51 - 53
(#P602_84828) Transcript PN 1822 - 1831
(#P603_84985) Ibid PN 1833 - 1834 and Exhibit R17 at paragraphs 54 - 55
(#P610_85735) Ibid PN 1926 - 1931
(#P613_86394) Ibid PN 1937
(#P616_86964) Ibid PN 1938 - 1941 and 2046
(#P619_87549) Ibid PN 1942 - 1943 and 2020
(#P622_87992) Ibid PN 1944 - 1945 and 1954 - 1955
(#P623_88122) Ibid PN 1946 - 1947
(#P624_88512) Ibid PN 1957 - 1960 and 2009 - 2011
(#P625_88687) Ibid PN 1961
(#P626_88824) Ibid PN 2012
(#P629_89233) Ibid PN 1944 - 1950 and 2024 - 2037
(#P632_89503) Ibid PN 1962 - 1963
(#P635_89851) Ibid PN 1967 - 1970
(#P636_89983) Ibid PN 2057 - 2058
(#P637_90519) Ibid PN 1973 - 1974
(#P640_91246) Ibid PN 1975 - 1980
(#P641_91487) Ibid PN 2013
(#P644_91840) Ibid PN 1998 - 2000
(#P645_92098) Ibid PN 2002 - 2005
(#P648_92279) Ibid PN 2014 and 2045
(#P651_92855) Ibid PN 2015
(#P654_93274) Ibid PN 2047
(#P657_94014) Ibid PN 2040 - 2044
(#P658_94428) Ibid PN 2048 and 2050
(#P661_94635) Ibid PN 2016 - 2019
(#P666_94771) Exhibit R18
(#P669_95372) Transcript PN 2105 - 2106
(#P670_95490) Ibid PN 2111
(#P673_95960) Ibid PN 2107 - 2110
(#P674_96314) Ibid PN 2112
(#P677_96534) Ibid PN 2113 - 2117
(#P678_96869) Ibid PN 2117 - 2118
(#P681_97221) Ibid PN 2119 - 2121 and Exhibit R18 at paragraph 22
(#P684_97616) Ibid PN 2122 - 2125 and ibid at paragraphs 26 - 30
(#P687_98231) Ibid PN 2126 and 2139 - 2140
(#P688_98575) Ibid PN 2128 - 2130
(#P691_98707) Ibid PN 2132 - 2133
(#P692_99058) Ibid PN 2134 - 2135 and 2138
(#P699_99342) Final Submissions of the Applicant dated 14 January 2013 at paragraph 6
(#P704_99710) Ibid at paragraph 7
(#P705_99855) Ibid
(#P708_100306) Ibid at paragraph 8
(#P713_100652) Ibid at paragraph 9
(#P716_100807) Ibid at paragraph 10
(#P719_100920) Ibid
(#P722_101154) Ibid
(#P725_101436) Ibid at paragraph 11
(#P726_101805) Ibid
(#P729_102506) Ibid and Exhibit R1 at paragraph 23
(#P734_103208) Ibid at paragraph 12
(#P739_103647) Ibid at paragraph 13 and Exhibit R1 at paragraph 23
(#P744_104195) Ibid at paragraph 15
(#P747_104484) Ibid
(#P748_104782) Ibid at paragraph 16
(#P751_104943) Ibid at paragraph 17
(#P752_105205) Ibid at paragraph 18
(#P755_105465) Ibid at paragraphs 18 - 19
(#P758_105880) Ibid at paragraph 20
(#P759_106076) Ibid at paragraph 21 and Exhibit R1 at paragraph 18
(#P762_106381) Ibid at paragraph 21
(#P763_106915) Ibid at paragraph 22
(#P766_107317) Ibid at paragraph 24
(#P767_107475) Ibid at paragraph 25
(#P770_107889) Ibid
(#P775_108205) Ibid at paragraph 28
(#P784_108892) Ibid at paragraph 27
(#P789_109457) Ibid at paragraph 29 and Exhibit R1 at paragraph 21
(#P790_109691) Ibid at paragraph 30
(#P793_110226) Ibid at paragraphs 30 - 31 and Exhibit R1 at paragraph 20
(#P794_110432) Ibid at paragraph 31
(#P799_111095) Ibid at paragraph 33 and Exhibit A1 at paragraph 16
(#P802_111467) Ibid at paragraph 34
(#P805_111887) Ibid at paragraph 35
(#P810_112596) Ibid at paragraph 36
(#P813_113214) Ibid
(#P818_113663) Ibid at paragraph 40
(#P821_114246) Ibid
(#P850_115849) Ibid and Exhibit R1 at paragraph 28
(#P853_116353) Ibid
(#P854_116529) Ibid
(#P859_116729) Ibid and Exhibit R1 at paragraph 28
(#P862_116984) Ibid
(#P871_117517) Ibid
(#P876_117728) Ibid
(#P881_117928) Ibid
(#P886_118058) Ibid
(#P891_118256) Ibid
(#P896_118731) Ibid
(#P901_119157) Ibid
(#P904_119307) Ibid
(#P905_119671) Ibid
(#P910_119890) Final Submissions of the Respondent dated 5 February 2013 at paragraphs 99 - 100
(#P913_120109) Ibid at paragraph 2
(#P914_120284) Ibid at paragraph 2(e)
(#P921_120962) Ibid at paragraph 5
(#P922_121120) Ibid at paragraph 6 - 9
(#P925_121289) Ibid at paragraph 11
(#P928_121772) Ibid at paragraphs 12 - 13
(#P931_122237) Ibid at paragraph 14 and Exhibit R15 at paragraphs 28 - 30
(#P934_122942) Ibid at paragraph 16 and ibid at paragraphs 31 - 35
(#P939_123248) Ibid at paragraph 8
(#P946_123602) Ibid at paragraphs 19 - 23 and Exhibit R15 at paragraph 3
(#P949_123891) Ibid at paragraph 24
(#P950_124253) Ibid
(#P951_124416) Ibid at paragraph 26
(#P956_124829) Ibid at paragraphs 26 - 27 and Exhibit R15 at paragraph 21
(#P959_125251) Ibid at paragraphs 28 - 29
(#P960_125445) Ibid at paragraph 30
(#P963_125712) Ibid at paragraphs 31 - 32
(#P964_125945) Exhibit R15 at paragraph 21
(#P967_126093) Ibid at paragraph 3 and Final Submissions of the Respondent dated 5 February 2013 at paragraph 33
(#P972_126774) Final Submissions of the Respondent dated 5 February 2013 at paragraph 35 - 36
(#P975_127187) Ibid at paragraphs 38 - 39
(#P978_127350) Ibid at paragraph 40
(#P979_127484) Ibid
(#P984_127993) Ibid at paragraphs 41 - 42
(#P987_128253) Ibid at paragraph 43
(#P990_128438) Ibid at paragraph 44
(#P998_128922) Ibid at paragraphs 44 - 45 and 49
(#P1001_129217) Ibid at paragraphs 46 - 48
(#P1004_129616) Ibid at paragraphs 51 - 52
(#P1005_129832) Ibid at paragraph 53
(#P1008_130116) Ibid at paragraph 54
(#P1011_130638) Ibid at paragraphs 55 - 58
(#P1018_131132) Ibid at paragraph 59 - 60
(#P1021_131468) Ibid at paragraph 62
(#P1024_131819) Ibid at paragraph 63 - 65
(#P1025_132221) Ibid at paragraph 65
(#P1028_132411) Ibid at paragraph 69
(#P1033_132836) Ibid at paragraph 70 and Exhibit R15 at paragraph 15
(#P1034_133089) Ibid at paragraph 71
(#P1035_133209) Ibid at paragraph 74 and Exhibit R15 at paragraph 16
(#P1040_133561) Ibid at paragraphs 75 - 76
(#P1045_133848) Ibid at paragraph 76
(#P1048_134292) Ibid at paragraph 77
(#P1051_134510) Ibid
(#P1054_134754) Ibid at paragraph 78
(#P1055_135104) Ibid at paragraphs 78 - 79
(#P1058_135499) Ibid at paragraphs 80 - 81
(#P1061_135695) Ibid at paragraph 81
(#P1068_135945) Ibid at paragraph 82
(#P1069_136129) Ibid at paragraph 83
(#P1070_136363) Ibid at paragraph 84 and Exhibit R15 at paragraphs 36 - 38
(#P1075_136773) Ibid at paragraph 85 and ibid at paragraph 25
(#P1078_137163) Ibid at paragraph 87 and ibid at paragraph 26
(#P1081_137411) Ibid at paragraph 88 and ibid at paragraph 24
(#P1086_137760) Ibid at paragraph 89
(#P1091_138082) Exhibit R15 at paragraphs 48 - 49
(#P1094_138630) Ibid at 50 - 54 and Final Submissions of the Respondent dated 5 February 2013 at paragraphs 90 - 91
(#P1097_138970) Final Submissions of the Respondent dated 5 February 2013 at paragraph 92
(#P1098_139162) Ibid at paragraph 93
(#P1101_139303) Exhibit R15 at paragraph 55 - 58
(#P1104_139440) Final Submissions of the Respondent dated 5 February 2013 at paragraph 94
(#P1109_139925) Ibid at paragraph 95 - 96
(#P1112_140282) Ibid at paragraph 97
(#P1113_140551) Ibid at paragraph 98
(#P1120_141389) Ibid at paragraph 102 and Exhibit R15 at paragraph 39
(#P1123_141564) Ibid at paragraph 103
(#P1126_141832) Ibid
(#P1128_141899) Ibid
(#P1130_142080) Ibid and Exhibit R15 at paragraph 60
(#P1187_145446) Exhibit A2 at Attachment KW1 and Exhibit R15 at paragraph 2
(#P1190_145674) Final Submissions of the Respondent dated 5 February 2013
(#P1191_145913) Final Submissions of the Applicant dated 14 January 2013 at paragraph 12
(#P1192_146093) Final Submissions of the Applicant dated 14 January 2013
(#P1201_146819) Exhibit A2 at Attachment KW2
(#P1204_147035) Ibid
(#P1220_147566) Ibid
(#P1223_147786) Final Submissions of the Respondent dated 5 February 2013 at paragraphs 8 - 9
(#P1226_148072) Final Submissions of the Applicant dated 14 January 2013 at paragraph 14
(#P1227_148364) Transcript PN 319 - 321 and 325
(#P1228_148606) Ibid PN 321 and 326
(#P1237_149475) Exhibit R16 at Attachment ADW4
(#P1240_150141) Exhibit A2 at Attachment KW2
(#P1247_152633) Transcript PN 333 - 338, 343 - 345, 350, 355, 357 - 358, 372 - 373 and 375 and Exhibit A2 at paragraph 7
(#P1250_152884) Final Submissions of the Respondent dated 5 February 2013 at paragraph 31
(#P1251_153036) Ibid PN 26, Exhibit R17 at paragraph 47 and Transcript PN 1799
(#P1258_153274) Transcript PN 254 and 257
(#P1259_153522) Ibid PN 961 and Exhibit A4 at paragraph 10
(#P1264_153847) Ibid PN 967, 969, 973 - 976 and 978 and Exhibit A4 at paragraph 10
(#P1267_154266) Ibid PN 477
(#P1268_154499) Ibid PN 478
(#P1277_155038) Final Submissions of the Applicant dated 14 January 2013
(#P1278_155325) Transcript PN 354 and373 - 374 and Exhibit A2 at paragraph 13
(#P1281_155545) Transcript PN 1799
(#P1282_155742) Ibid PN 1455
(#P1287_156454) Exhibit R1
(#P1302_158682) Exhibit A2 at Attachment KW2
(#P1311_160072) Exhibit R14
(#P1314_160230) Exhibit A2 at paragraph 14
(#P1352_163768) Final Submissions of the Respondent dated 5 February 2013 at paragraphs 51 - 54
(#P1401_171058) Transcript PN 932
(#P1428_174840) Ibid PN 1440
(#P1435_176025) Final submissions of the respondent dated 5 February 2013 at paragraph 61
(#P1436_176265) Exhibit R16 at paragraph 43, Exhibit R17 at paragraph 45(c) and Transcript PN 1424
(#P1437_176470) Transcript PN 1424
(#P1442_176626) Exhibit A2 at Attachment KW1
(#P1443_176869) Exhibit R13
(#P1450_177220) Final submissions of the applicant dated 14 January 2013 at paragraph 40
(#P1451_177463) Ibid
(#P1454_177710) Ibid
(#P1457_177832) Final submissions of the respondent dated 5 February 2013 at paragraph 94
(#P1458_178458) Ibid at paragraphs 91 and 93
(#P1461_178789) Exhibit A2 at Attachment KW3
(#P1462_179051) Exhibit R13
(#P1463_179143) Exhibit R1
(#P1468_179554) Exhibit A2 at Attachment KW3
(#P1471_179927) Ibid
(#P1501_181810) Final submissions of the respondent dated 5 February 2013 at paragraph 97
(#P1504_182422) Transcript PN 2015
(#P1507_182677) Ibid PN 2047
(#P1514_183509) Ibid PN 2015
(#P1515_183642) Ibid PN 2015
(#P1518_183817) PR536078
Printed by authority of the Commonwealth Government Printer
Walsh
Ambulance Victoria [2013] FWC 1999