[2014] FWC 1437
General information, not legal advice.
Fair Work Commission
2014-03-03
Commissioner Wilson, Commissioner Cribb
Original judgment source is linked above.
(#P28_1074) Transcript, PN 998 - 1007
(#P35_1348) Application for Unfair Dismissal, Form F2, item 1; Employer Response, Form F3, item 1
(#P36_1676) Transcript, PN 1125
(#P47_3026) Applicant's Outline of Submissions, Exhibit A1 paras 6-7
(#P50_3170) Ibid, para 1
(#P51_3330) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, para 5
(#P56_3526) Ibid, para 6
(#P57_3700) Ibid
(#P60_3828) Ibid, para 7
(#P61_3940) Ibid, para 9
(#P64_4175) Ibid, Attachment JC-1, report of Dr Felman, 1 October 2011
(#P65_4349) Ibid, para 9
(#P68_4467) Ibid, para 10
(#P71_4579) Ibid, para 13
(#P72_4709) Ibid, para 6
(#P75_4864) Ibid, Attachments JC-3 (Felman, 21 September 2012), JC-4 (Turnbull, 10 October 2012)
(#P88_6736) Ibid, Attachment JC-3 (Felman, 21 September 2012), pp 5-6, JC 3; 6.0
(#P91_6922) Ibid, Attachment JC-4 (Turnbull, 10 October 2012), p3
(#P112_9757) Ibid, Attachment JC-4 (Turnbull, 10 October 2012), pp 2-3
(#P115_10068) Respondent's Outline of Submissions, Exhibit R1, para 18; Clarke, Attachment JC-6
(#P118_10485) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, Attachment JC-6
(#P121_10821) Applicant's Outline of Submissions, paras 17-24
(#P126_11071) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, para 15
(#P127_11185) Transcript, PN 1979 - 1985
(#P130_11618) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, para 17
(#P135_12224) Ibid, para 20
(#P138_12391) Transcript, PN 1404 - 1407, PN 1792
(#P141_12580) Transcript, PN 1250
(#P144_12684) Transcript, PN 1788; and in proceedings before Cribb C, Transcript PN 477
(#P147_12927) Transcript, PN 1115, 1121
(#P148_13200) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, Attachment JC-3 (Felman, 21 September 2012), paras 18-19
(#P149_13407) Transcript, PN 1385, 1535, 1758
(#P162_16072) [2013] FWC 5415
(#P165_16265) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, para 24
(#P170_16554) Ibid, para 25
(#P183_17331) Ibid, para 26
(#P186_17499) Transcript, PN 1999
(#P187_17689) Transcript, PN 1787
(#P190_18630) Transcript, PN 1788
(#P193_18786) Transcript, PN 2000-2002
(#P196_18948) Transcript, PN 1107
(#P197_19183) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, para 27; Transcript, PN 2002-2005
(#P198_19380) Ibid, para 29
(#P201_19680) Ibid, para 28
(#P204_19981) Transcript, PN 1748, 1988, 2008
(#P209_20194) Transcript, PN 1748
(#P210_20497) Transcript, PN 2015
(#P211_20683) Transcript, PN 2014
(#P224_22532) Transcript, PN 2016-2019
(#P231_22866) Transcript, PN 2021
(#P234_23061) Transcript, PN 1111
(#P237_23997) Transcript, PN 1408
(#P240_24225) Transcript, PN 2021
(#P247_25136) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, Attachment JC-6
(#P282_27378) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, Attachment JC-3 (Felman, 21 September 2012), p 4 and 6
(#P283_27558) Applicant's Outline of Submissions, para 16
(#P292_28838) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, Attachment JC-4 (Turnbull, 10 October 2012)
(#P301_29739) Respondent's Closing Submissions, paras 8-9
(#P304_30120) Qantas Airways Ltd v Christie (1998) 193 CLR 280, per Gaudron J at [34]
(#P305_30418) Ibid, per McHugh J, at [72]; Hail Creek Coal Pty Ltd v CFMEU (2004) 143 IR 354, at [124]
(#P308_30690) [2010] FWAFB 4022[2010] FWAFB 4022; , (2010) 195 IR 292 at [22]
(#P353_41463) [2010] FWAFB 4022, at [20]
(#P356_41682) Qantas Airways Ltd v Christie (1998) 193 CLR 280, see [7] and [26]
(#P359_42008) X v Commonwealth, (1999), 200 CLR 177, see [7], [13] and [72]
(#P362_42420) Hail Creek Coal Pty Ltd v CFMEU, see [6] and [122]
(#P365_42661) Applicant's Closing Statement and Response to Respondent's Outline of Submissions, 29 November 2013, para 48.
(#P370_43867) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, Attachment JC-4 (Turnbull, 10 October 2012), pp2-3
(#P373_44243) Applicant's Closing Statement and Response to Respondent's Outline of Submissions, 29 November 2013, para 14
(#P374_44540) Ibid
(#P379_45019) Applicant's Closing Statements and Response to Respondent's Outline of Submissions, 29 November 2011, para 14
(#P382_46178) Ibid, para 20-22
(#P383_46359) Transcript, PN 1214
(#P384_46533) Respondent's Outline of Submissions, para 20 - 22; see Accident Compensation Act 1985 (Vic), s.242A
(#P387_46884) [2013] FWC 5415, at [9]; see also Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, Attachment JC-3 (Felman, 21 September 2012), pp 1 - 2
(#P390_47747) Miller v University of New South Wales [2003] FCAFC 180, see [64] - [69]
(#P399_49536) Boag v Button, at [22]
(#P402_49719) Qantas v Christie, at [72]
(#P403_50017) Ibid, at [86]
(#P408_50637) Applicant's Closing Statements and Response to Respondent's Outline of Submissions, 29 November 2011, para 26
(#P411_51041) Jones v Dunkel and Another [1959] HCA 8; (1959) 101 CLR 298
(#P412_51336) Maria-Anna Owens v Allied Express Transport Pty Ltd, [2011] FWA 1058, at [14]
(#P413_51559) Maritime Union of Australia, The v Patrick Stevedores Holdings Pty Limited, [2014] FWFCB 657, at [67]
(#P418_52523) Selvachandran v Peteron Plastics Pty Ltd, (1995) 62 IR 371 at 373
(#P433_53686) Transcript, PN 1370 - 1375, 1543
(#P438_54198) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, Attachment JC-3 (Felman, 21 September 2012), p 6
(#P441_54483) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, Attachment JC-4 (Turnbull, 10 October 2012), p 3
(#P448_55433) Respondent's Closing Submissions, 16 December 2013, paras 11 - 12
(#P451_55530) [2011] FWA 7728
(#P452_55732) Ibid, at [25]
(#P453_55873) [2012] FWAFB 1404, at [18]
(#P472_58200) Transcript, PN 1385, 1535, 1758
(#P473_58347) Transcript, PN 1761, 1788, 2059
(#P474_58504) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, para 26
(#P475_58690) Transcript, PN 1110, 1247
(#P480_59430) Transcript, PN 1406 - 1407, 1792
(#P487_60328) Applicant's Outline of Submissions, paras 18 - 24; Closing Submissions para 29
(#P488_60785) Statement of Joanne Clarke, Exhibit R2, paras 29-30; Transcript, PN 2018-2019
(#P491_61332) Victorian Association for the Teaching of English Inc v Debra de Laps, [2014] FWCFB 613, at [52]
Printed by authority of the Commonwealth Government Printer
Rowe
V/Line Pty Ltd [2014] FWC 1437
(1999) 200 CLR 177
(1998) 193 CLR 280
(2004) 143 IR 354
(2010) 195 IR 292
(1959) 101 CLR 298
(1995) 62 IR 371