austlii:qld/QBCCMCmr/2025/353
General information, not legal advice.
QBCCMCmr
2025-10-16
Original judgment source is linked above.
Perry Sands [2025] QBCCMCmr 353
The Body Corporate for Perry Sands (respondent)
Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld) (Act), sections 227(1)(b) and 229(3)(a)
PROPERTY DAMAGE - JURISDICTION - whether a claim for damage to property and other losses should be heard in a court or tribunal of competent jurisdiction.
Act, ss 281, 270(1)(b); Standard Module, s 180.
1. The application is dismissed pursuant to section 250 of the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997(Qld) and referred to the Magistrates Court as having competent jurisdiction to hear upon and decide the matter. > > OR, in the alternative should the application proceed before the Commissioner: > > 2. Damages in the sum of $34,633.93. > > 3. A direction for works to be performed sufficiently and appropriately addressing the underground water and drainage issues; > > 4. The Respondent pay the Applicant's costs; and > > 5. Such further or other direction as appropriate.
a) Make-safe electrical works: $1,540.00 including GST > > b) Plumbing disconnect and reconnect around rectification works: $841.50 including GST > > c) Replace kitchen cabinetry and benchtops: $20,952.43 including GST > > d) Remove and replace doors, hinges and frames, install weather seals: $2,595.00 including GST > > e) Paint and repair cracking to walls: $2,420.00 including GST > > f) Install pump to remove ground water below the Property: $3,405.00 including GST > > g) Twelve (12) nights at $240 per night: $2,880.00 including GST
3.2. Jurisdiction and powers in claims for damage to property
4.2. Maintenance obligations that may be relevant in this dispute
[1] For evidence: That pipes may have needed repair, see paragraph 5 of Annexure C and paragraph 5b of the statement from Shane Briggs; That a heavy rainfall event occurred, see paragraph 7 of Annexure C; That the existing stormwater system has inadequate capacity to cope with surface water, see paragraph 20 of the statement from Shane Briggs, citing the Structural Waterproof Consulting report; That there was inadequate drainage to deal with a permanent underground natural water source, see paragraph 20 of the statement from Shane Briggs, citing the Structural Waterproof Consulting report; That there was building movement, see paragraph 24 of the statement from Shane Briggs, citing the Exigo report; That there was a lack of maintenance, see paragraph 25 of the statement from Shane Briggs, citing correspondence from Strata Community.
[3] DJL v Central Authority [2000] HCA 17 at [25] as cited in Enderley Gardens [2024] QBCCMCmr 60 at [70].
[7] See, for example, Act, s 152, Standard Module, s 180.
[8] For a more detailed discussion on when an adjudicator has the power to make orders around economic loss, see Victoria Square [2024] QBCCMCmr 387.
[9] There may be exceptions, such as where a private yard exists on the plan. See 9.1 & 9.6.4 of the Registrar of Titles Directions for the Preparation of Plans.
[10] Land Title Act 1994 (Qld), s 49C(4).
[13] Provides when utility infrastructure is, and is not, common property.
[14] Where damage to property arises out of a breach of legislation or CMS.
[15] Outlines particular exceptions to the body corporate's maintenance obligations.
[16] When an item is an improvement to common property made by a lot owner.
[17] Where conditions under an exclusive use by-law change maintenance obligations.
[18] Where there has been an improvement made by an owner of a lot to an area subject of an exclusive use by-law.
[19] MAGOG (NO. 15) Pty Ltd v The Body Corporate for the Moroccan [2010] QDC 70 at [83] citing Seiwa Pty Ltd v Owners Strata Plan 35042 [2006] NSWSC 1157 at [4].
[21] Victoria Square [2024] QBCCMCmr 387 at [67], who also cited Vickery v The Owners - Strata Plan No 80412 [2020] NSWCA 284.
[23] Two quotes may be necessary in certain circumstances, pursuant to sections 173 and 174 of the Standard Module.
[26] Body Corporate for Palm Springs Residences CTS 29467 v J Patterson Holdings Pty Ltd [2008] QDC 300 at [98].
[27] Woodrange Pty Ltd v Le Grand Broadwater Body Corporate [2004] QDC 215; cited in Body Corporate for Palm Springs Residences CTS 29467 v J Patterson Holdings Pty Ltd [2008] QDC 300 at [91].