/

/

Where to start with an Australian legal problem: plain-English guides, with the legislation and case law behind them.

Platform

Legislation
Cases
Guides
Find a lawyer
Absurdities
Ask Zoe
Graph
Recently analysed

Free tools

Bond claim checker
Barking dog and noise diary
Support at Home statement check
All tools

Lawyers: our picks

Lawyers in Sydney
Lawyers in Melbourne
Lawyers in Brisbane
Lawyers in Perth
Family lawyers
Employment lawyers
Criminal lawyers
Wills and estates lawyers
Find a lawyer

Company

Pricing
API
Privacy
Terms
Support
X
LinkedIn
Instagram

Jurisdictions

Commonwealth
New South Wales
Queensland
Victoria
Western Australia
South Australia
Tasmania
Australian Capital Territory
Northern Territory

© 2026 Zoe. All rights reserved.

Zoe gives general legal information, not legal advice. For the authoritative text, check the official register of the law's own jurisdiction, such as the Federal Register of Legislation for Commonwealth laws.

McLean v Transfield Services [2013] FWC 2573 | Case summary | Zoe

Legislation Cases Guides Find a lawyer Absurdities Ask Zoe Graph Pricing

Home/Cases/[2013] FWC 2573

CTHFWC

McLean v Transfield Services [2013] FWC 2573

[2013] FWC 2573

Fair Work Commission|2013-05-08|Before: Mr P

View original source

General information, not legal advice.

Ask Zoe about this case

Free, no account needed. General information, not legal advice.

At a glance

Source facts

Court

Fair Work Commission

Decision date

2013-05-08

Before

Mr P

Source

Original judgment source is linked above.

Related plain-English guides

Unfair dismissal at the Fair Work Commission (Form F2)Australia (Commonwealth)
Recover unpaid wages through Fair Work Ombudsman and small claimsAustralia (Commonwealth)
Unfair deactivation for gig and employee-like workersAustralia (Commonwealth)

Judgment (125 paragraphs)

[1]

(#P33_1519) Exhibit Transfield 1, Attachment C.

[2]

(#P98_8073) Exhibit CFMEU 3, Attachment A.

[3]

(#P123_10598) Transcript, at paras 366 and 643.

[4]

(#P146_11826) Selvachandran v Peterson Plastics Pty Ltd (1995) 62 IR 371.

[5]

(#P147_12002) Jobson v Gerrard Strapping Systems, Print P6151.

[6]

(#P148_12370) Briginshaw v Briginshaw and Another [1938] HCA 34; (1938) 60 CLR 336.

[7]

(#P157_14229) (1959) 101 CLR 298.

[8]

(#P170_17533) McLauchlan v Australia Meat Holdings Pty Ltd Print Q1625 at page 12 and King v Freshmore (Vic) Pty Ltd Print S4213 at para 28.

[9]

(#P175_18212) (2000) 98 IR 137.

[10]

(#P176_18440) Applicant's written submissions.

[11]

(#P181_19799) Fischer v Telstra Corporation Limited Print R2558 at para 33.

[12]

(#P232_26324) Section 382 of the Fair Work Act 2009.

[13]

(#P280_30981) [1999] FCA 1836; (1999) 169 ALR 89 at p.92 per Moore J.

[14]

(#P283_31075) Print S4213.

[15]

(#P288_31838) See Yew v ACI Glass Packaging Pty Limited (1996) 71 IR 201; Sherman v Peabody Coal Ltd (1998) 88 IR 408 and Australia Meat Holdings Pty Ltd v McLauchlan (1998) 84 IR 1.

[16]

(#P291_32170) Respondent's written submissions of 28 March 2013, at paras 31 and 33.

[17]

(#P292_32562) Exhibit Transfield 1, Attachment C.

[18]

(#P303_33694) Transcript, at para 370.

[19]

(#P304_33790) Transcript, at para 276.

[20]

(#P305_33940) Transcript, at para 383.

[21]

(#P306_34199) Transcript, at para 252.

[22]

(#P307_34271) Transcript, at paras 451and 452.

[23]

(#P308_34435) Exhibit CFMEU 4, at para 4.

[24]

(#P311_34554) Transcript, at para 370.

[25]

(#P314_34825) Transcript, at para 373.

[26]

(#P315_34957) Transcript, at para 374.

[27]

(#P318_35158) Exhibit CFMEU 3, at para 22.

[28]

(#P319_35348) Transcript, at paras 1012 and 1139.

[29]

(#P320_35645) Transcript, at paras 768, 1009 and 1137.

[30]

(#P323_35966) Transcript, at para 1217.

[31]

(#P324_36017) Transcript, at para 1221.

[32]

(#P325_36152) Transcript, at paras 1222-1223.

[33]

(#P326_36242) Transcript, at para 1238.

[34]

(#P329_36336) Exhibit CFMEU 4 at para 3.

[35]

(#P330_36621) Transcript, at para 417.

[36]

(#P331_36748) Transcript, at para 989.

[37]

(#P334_36900) Transcript, at para 656.

[38]

(#P335_37023) Transcript at paras 680-683.

[39]

(#P336_37160) Exhibit CFMEU 4, at para 5.

[40]

(#P337_37328) Exhibit CFMEU 4, at para 5.

[41]

(#P338_37469) Transcript, at para 654-655.

[42]

(#P341_37530) Exhibit Transfield 3.

[43]

(#P342_37839) Transcript, at para 580.

[44]

(#P343_38506) Exhibit Transfield 3.

[45]

(#P346_38746) Transcript, at para 588.

[46]

(#P347_38874) Transcript, at para 702.

[47]

(#P348_39058) Transcript, at para 707.

[48]

(#P349_39250) Transcript, at para 708.

[49]

(#P350_39344) Transcript, at para 710.

[50]

(#P353_39477) Transcript, at para 709.

[51]

(#P354_39607) Transcript, at paras 662 and 683.

[52]

(#P357_39760) Transcript, at para 677.

[53]

(#P362_39992) Exhibit CFMEU 3, at para 48.

[54]

(#P363_40131) Exhibit CFMEU 3, at para 49.

[55]

(#P366_40229) Exhibits CFMEU 2 and Transfield 5.

[56]

(#P367_40371) Transcript, at para 869.

[57]

(#P372_41206) Transcript, at para 1135.

[58]

(#P373_41363) Respondent's written submissions of 28 March 2013, at para 22.

[59]

(#P376_41473) Exhibit Transfield 4 at paras 20-27.

[60]

(#P377_41889) Transcript, at paras 37-40.

[61]

(#P380_42036) Transcript, at paras 988 and 992

[62]

(#P383_42190) Exhibit CFMEU 4, at para 7.

[63]

(#P386_42342) Transcript, at para 1251-1255.

[64]

(#P413_45557) Transcript, at para 370.

[65]

(#P414_45816) Exhibit Transfield 5.

[66]

(#P417_46737) Transcript, at para 373.

[67]

(#P420_47081) As reflected in the Respondent's written submissions and the evidence of Mr Ibrahim in Transcript, at para 1081.

[68]

(#P425_48002) Exhibit Transfield 4, at para 25.

[69]

(#P426_48333) Transcript, at paras 1222-1223.

[70]

(#P427_48421) Transcript, at para 1238.

[71]

(#P430_48623) Exhibit Transfield 4, at para 27.

[72]

(#P431_48823) Exhibit Transfield 3.

[73]

(#P432_48876) Transcript, at para 707.

[74]

(#P433_49106) Transcript, at para 677.

[75]

(#P434_49594) Exhibit Transfield 3.

[76]

(#P447_51346) Exhibit Transfield 1, Attachment C.

[77]

(#P452_52256) Exhibit Transfield 4, at para 23.

[78]

(#P455_52373) Exhibit Transfield 4, at para 29.

[79]

(#P456_52538) Exhibit Transfield 4, at para 28.

[80]

(#P459_52838) Exhibit Transfield 6, at para 8.

[81]

(#P462_53475) Exhibit Transfield 4, at paras 28-29.

[82]

(#P467_53980) Exhibit CFMEU 4, at para 17.

[83]

(#P472_54196) Exhibit CFMEU 4, at para 6.

[84]

(#P475_54408) Exhibit CFMEU 4, at para 7.

[85]

(#P478_54671) Exhibit CFMEU 4, at para 8.

[86]

(#P481_54930) Exhibit CFMEU 4, at para 9.

[87]

(#P484_55095) Exhibit CFMEU 4, at para 11.

[88]

(#P487_55306) Exhibit CFMEU 4, at para 5.

[89]

(#P490_55494) Exhibit Transfield 3.

[90]

(#P493_55659) Exhibit Transfield 4, at para 36.

[91]

(#P496_55862) Exhibit Transfield 1, Attachment C.

[92]

(#P499_56122) Exhibit CFMEU 7, at para 3.

[93]

(#P500_56257) Exhibit CFMEU 7, at para 5.

[94]

(#P503_56535) Exhibit CFMEU 7, at para 9 and Exhibit CFMEU 6, at para 5.

[95]

(#P508_57337) Exhibit Transfield 4, at para 28-29.

[96]

(#P509_57798) Exhibit CFMEU 4, at para 7.

[97]

(#P520_58998) Respondent's written submissions of 28 March 2013, at para 24.

[98]

(#P521_59106) Respondent's written submissions of 28 March 2013, at para 25.

[99]

(#P530_61440) Transcript, at para 868

[100]

(#P557_64006) Section 390 of the Fair Work Act 2009.

[101]

(#P570_64977) Section 390(3) of the Fair Work Act 2009.

[102]

(#P635_69061) (1998) 88 IR 21.

[103]

(#P636_69211) Applicant's written submissions of 28 March 2013, at para 53.

[104]

(#P639_69903) Respondent's written submissions of 28 March 2013, at para 34.

[105]

(#P648_71056) Respondent's written submission of 28 March 2013, at para 38.

[106]

(#P653_71765) Exhibit CFMEU 3, at paras 18 and 19.

[107]

(#P656_72315) Transcript, at para 505.

[108]

(#P667_73414) Transcript, at paras 324-326 and 348.

[109]

(#P668_73712) Exhibits CFMEU 3, at para 14 and CFMEU 4, at para 14.

[110]

(#P673_74156) Exhibit CFMEU 5.

[111]

(#P676_74299) Transcript, at paras 343-346.

[112]

(#P699_76651) Transcript, at para 532.

[113]

(#P702_76806) Transcript, at para 74.

[114]

(#P705_77348) Exhibit Transfield 1, at para 2.

[115]

(#P706_77494) Transcript, at para 532.

[116]

(#P709_77782) Exhibit Transfield 2.

[117]

(#P714_78826) Transcript, at para 505.

[118]

(#P719_79066) Exhibits CFMEU 3, at paras 11-12.

[119]

(#P722_79613) Exhibit CFMEU 3, at paras 18-20.

[120]

(#P725_79829) Exhibit CFMEU 4, at para13.

[121]

(#P728_80152) Transcript, at para 532.

[122]

(#P733_81349) Respondent's written submissions of 28 March 2013, at para 54 and Attachment A of Applicant written submissions.

[123]

(#P734_81536) Exhibit CFMEU 4, at attachments CMc-1 and CMc-2.

[124]

(#P737_81976) Final written submissions, at paras 37-38.

[125]

(#P742_82989) AE888976 PR515912.

Printed by authority of the Commonwealth Government Printer

Parties

Applicant/Plaintiff:

McLean

Respondent/Defendant:

Transfield Services [2013] FWC 2573

Legislation Cited (3)

Work Act 2009

Health and Safety Regulations 2007

Relations Act 1996

Cases Cited (9)

(1995) 62 IR 371

(1938) 60 CLR 336

(1959) 101 CLR 298

(2000) 98 IR 137

(1999) 169 ALR 89

(1996) 71 IR 201

(1998) 84 IR 1

(1998) 88 IR 408

(1998) 88 IR 21

Find a lawyer

Employment lawyers across Australia: our picks by city

ZoeLaw is not a law firm. Picks are our opinion; we don't share your details.