© 2026 Zoe. All rights reserved.
Zoe is a legal information platform. Always consult the official source for authoritative text.
[2002] QCA 176
Court of Appeal (Qld)
2002-05-24
Helman J, Murdo P, Pherson JA, Williams JA
Original judgment source is linked above.
JAE-WON KIM and DONG HEE KIM Plaintiff (Not a party)
MICHAEL WILLIAM HURST Second Defendant (First Respondent)
LTD (ACN 009 027 221) Third Party (Second Respondent)
JAE-WON KIM and DONG HEE KIM Plaintiff (Not a party)
MICHAEL WILLIAM HURST Second Defendant (Respondent)
WILLIAMS JA: In this matter the Court comprised the President and Justices McPherson and Helman. The order in Appeal Number 7772 of 2001 is as follows:
(1) Appeal against the apportionment of damages between the appellant Cole and respondent Hurst dismissed with costs;
(2) Appeal allowed by setting aside judgment with costs in favour of the defendant Hurst and substituting judgment for the plaintiff Cole in the sum of $25,000 with interest and costs on the Magistrates Court scale.
In Appeal 8074, appeal allowed with costs; the judgment set aside with costs; in lieu thereof there be judgment dismissing with costs the third party proceedings against the appellant brought by the respondent second defendant.
I publish the separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, Justice Helman dissenting in part.
# Kim & Anor
Cole & Ors \[2002\] QCA 176