austlii:cth/FedCFamC2G/2025/686
General information, not legal advice.
FedCFamC2G
2025-05-14
Original judgment source is linked above.
FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)
UPON the admissions the Respondent is taken to have made, consequent upon default by the Respondent pursuant to rule 13.04(2) of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth) (Rules)
(i) $77.24 in respect of the minimum rate of pay to which the Applicant was entitled under the Award;
(ii) $51.09 in respect of penalty rates to which the Applicant was entitled under the Award;
(iii) $770.56 in respect of overtime rates to which the Applicant was entitled under the Award;
(iv) $185.74 in respect of superannuation to which the Applicant was entitled under the Award;
(v) $148.00 in respect of accrued untaken annual leave to which the Applicant was entitled under the Act.
(a) $4,541.49 in compensation for economic loss; and
(b) $2,000.00 in general damages.
(a) By 4.00pm on 10 June 2025, the Applicant is to file and serve any further evidence and an outline of written submissions (with a maximum of 10 pages).
(b) By 4.00pm on 8 July 2025, the Respondent is to file and serve any evidence and an outline of written submissions (with a maximum of 10 pages).
(c) By 4.00pm on 29 July 2025, the Applicant is to file and serve any further evidence and an outline of written submissions (with a maximum of 5 pages) in reply.
(d) The question of what (if any) pecuniary penalties are appropriate to order be determined on the papers.
(e) There be liberty to apply in respect of the program at this order 7.
(a) section 44 of the Act by contravening section 90(2) of the Act in relation to payment of accrued and untaken annual leave;
(b) section 44 of the Act by contravening section 125 of the Act in relation to the Fair Work Information Statement;
(c) section 45 of the Act by contravening clause 18.1 of the Restaurant Industry Award 2020 (Award) in relation to minimum rates of pay;
(d) section 45 of the Act by contravening clauses 24.1 and 24.2 of the Award in relation to penalty rates;
(e) section 45 of the Act by contravening clauses 23.1 and 23.4 of the Award in relation to overtime rates;
(f) section 45 of the Act by contravening clause 22.2 of the Award in relation to superannuation;
(g) section 45 of the Act by contravening clause 3.3 of the Award in relation to availability of copies of the Award and National Employment Standards;
(h) section 323 of the Act by failing to pay the Applicant her wages in full;
(i) section 340 of the Act by taking adverse action against the Applicant for the reason, or reasons that included the reason, that:
(i) the Applicant had and/or had exercised and/or proposed to exercise and/or to prevent the exercise of the Applicant's workplace right(s); and/or
(ii) that a third party had exercised and/or proposed to exercise workplace right(s) for the Applicant's benefit, or for the benefit of a class of persons to which the Applicant belongs;
(j) section 536(2) by providing payslips that did not include the information prescribed by the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) (Regulations); and
(k) section 536(3) by providing payslips which were false or misleading.
Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court's records.
Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).
(a) Eili Chahine (formerly named as Second Respondent to these proceedings); and
(b) Win Nguyen.
(a) The Applicant was engaged to work for the Respondent on a permanent, full-time basis;
(b) The Applicant was engaged to work subject to a weekly roster of around 5 days per week and 8 hours per day or shift; and
(c) The Applicant's rate of pay would be $25.00 per hour for all hours worked.
(a) An entitlement to progressively accrue and accumulate paid annual leave at 4 weeks per year of service, from year to year and according to the ordinary hours of work: s.87 of the Act;
(b) An entitlement to be paid accrued but untaken annual leave upon the cessation of the employment: s.90(2) of the Act; and
(c) An entitlement to be given the Fair Work Information Statement before, or as soon as practicable after, the employee starts employment: s.125 of the Act.
(a) An entitlement to a minimum ordinary hourly rate of pay of $24.08: cl.18.1;
(b) An entitlement to a penalty rate of 100% of the minimum ordinary hourly rate of pay, plus $3.93 per hour or part of an hour, for ordinary hours worked between midnight and 6.00am on a weekday: cl.24.1 and 24.2;
(c) An entitlement to overtime rates as follows for all time worked on a weekday in excess of 38 hours per week:
(i) 150% of the minimum ordinary hourly rate of pay for the first 2 hours of overtime;
(ii) 200% of the minimum ordinary hourly rate of pay thereafter,
(d) An entitlement to annual leave loading of 17.5% on all amounts payable in respect of paid annual leave, including the payment of untaken annual leave upon the end of employment: cl.25.3;
(e) An entitlement to superannuation contributions from the Respondent at the rate of 11% of the Applicant's ordinary time earnings, this amount being the minimum required to avoid the Respondent being required to pay the superannuation guarantee charge: cl. 22.2; and
(f) An entitlement to have copies of the NES and the Award made available on a notice board conveniently located at or near the workplace or through accessible electronic means: cl.3.3.
Other entitlements under the Fair Work Act
(a) Pay the Applicant in full in relation to the performance of work: s.323;
(b) Give a pay slip to the Applicant within one working day of paying an amount to them in relation to the performance of work: s.536(1);
(c) Give a pay slip to the Applicant that included any information prescribed by the Regulations including the rate of pay for the employee's ordinary hours and the number of hours worked by an employee at that rate of pay: s.536(2)(b) and reg.3.46(3); and
(d) Not give a pay slip the employer knew was false and misleading: s.536(3).
(a) A total of 55 hours, across 5 shifts; and
(b) On each shift, 1.5 hours between the hours of midnight to 6.00am on weekdays,
(particulars at Annexure A to these reasons).
(a) A total of 30 hours, across 3 shifts; and
(b) On each of the 3 shifts, 0.5 hours per shift between the hours of midnight to 6.00am on weekdays,
(particulars at Annexure A to these reasons).
In summary - contraventions of civil remedy provisions
(a) Declarations pursuant to s.545(1) of the Act that the Respondent contravened each of the aforementioned civil remedy provisions;
(b) An order pursuant to s.545(1) of the Act that the Respondent pay compensation to the Applicant in respect of the loss and damage caused particularised in the application for default judgment as follows:
(i) $77.24 in respect of the minimum rate of pay under the Award;
(ii) $51.09 in respect of penalty rates under the Award;
(iii) $770.56 in respect of overtime rates under the Award;
(iv) $185.74 in respect of superannuation under the Award;
(v) $148.00 in respect of accrued untaken annual leave under the Act,
(c) An order pursuant to s.545(1) of the Act arising out of the adverse action taken against the Applicant for prohibited reason(s), particularised in the application for default judgement as:
(i) $4,541.49 in economic loss suffered between 12 July 2023 and 14 August 2023 (a period of four weeks and three working days), calculated at 40 hours of work per week and the minimum rates of pay under the Award; and
(ii) $2,000.00 in general damages.
(d) An order pursuant to s.546(1) of the Act and within 60 days the Respondent pay pecuniary penalties fixed in the amount of $20,000.00 for the declared contraventions of civil remedy provisions under the Act.
(e) An order pursuant to s.547(2) of the Act that the Respondent pay interest to the Applicant owed on the amounts ordered for compensation, economic and non-economic loss, to be calculated at the applicable pre-judgement interest rate prescribed by the Federal Court of Australia.
(f) Such further or other order the Court deems appropriate.
(a) required that the Respondent file and serve a notice of address for service by 27 October 2023; and
(b) included a notation in terms that Counsel for the Applicant had advised the Court that they had been in contact with a Mr Zaferan Asir, the sole director of the Respondent, and Mr Asir was aware of the proceeding.
(a) required that the Respondent file and serve a defence by 30 January 2024;
(b) ordered that, in the event of non-compliance with the requirement that the Respondent file and serve a defence by 30 January 2024, any application for default judgement and material in support be filed by 13 February 2024 and be referred to a Judge for determination;
(c) ordered that the application proceed by way of statement of claim, and be heard and determined together with 2 related matters in MLG1593/2023 and MLG1596/2023, so that evidence in one matter be received as evidence in the other.
I certify that the preceding sixty-one (61) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment of Judge Mansini.
Daoud
3 Lads Laverton Food Hub [2025] FedCFamC2G 686