© 2026 Zoe. All rights reserved.
Zoe is a legal information platform. Always consult the Federal Register of Legislation for authoritative text.
[2012] FWA 5322
Fair Work Australia
2012-06-26
Mr J
Original judgment source is linked above.
(#P54_1880) Exhibit A3
(#P57_2325) Transcript PN 207 - 209
(#P60_2459) Ibid PN 212 and Exhibit A3 at paragraph 2
(#P61_2993) Ibid PN 213 - 218 and ibid at paragraph 5
(#P64_3415) Ibid PN 219 - 222
(#P67_3803) Ibid PN 255 - 258
(#P68_3943) Ibid PN 259 - 265
(#P69_4411) Ibid PN 266 - 285 and PN 373 - 383
(#P72_4576) Exhibit A3 at paragraph 6
(#P73_4681) Transcript PN 330
(#P76_5013) Exhibit A3 at paragraphs 3 and 4
(#P79_5463) Ibid at paragraphs 7 - 10
(#P82_5978) Ibid at paragraphs 11 - 13
(#P85_6388) Ibid at paragraphs 14 - 19
(#P88_6684) Ibid at paragraphs 23 - 24
(#P91_6931) Ibid at paragraphs 25 - 26
(#P96_7022) Exhibit A4
(#P97_7162) Ibid at paragraph 2
(#P100_7691) Transcript PN 401 - 410
(#P103_8075) Ibid PN 411
(#P106_8338) Ibid PN 415 - 419
(#P109_8706) Exhibit A4 at paragraphs 3 - 4
(#P112_8885) Ibid at paragraph 6
(#P113_9027) Ibid at paragraph 7
(#P114_9175) Ibid at paragraph 8
(#P115_9307) Ibid at paragraph 9
(#P118_9534) Ibid at paragraphs 10 and 14
(#P123_9625) Exhibit A5
(#P124_9712) Ibid at paragraph 2 and Transcript PN 446
(#P125_9809) Ibid at paragraphs 2 and 5
(#P128_9931) Ibid at paragraph 13 and Transcript PN 430
(#P129_10145) Transcript PN 431 - 442
(#P132_10408) Ibid PN 447 - 448
(#P135_10579) Ibid PN 449
(#P138_10939) Exhibit A5 at paragraphs 3 - 4
(#P141_11072) Ibid at paragraph 6
(#P142_11378) Ibid at paragraphs 7 - 8
(#P145_11929) Ibid at paragraphs 9 - 11
(#P148_12130) Ibid at paragraph 12
(#P149_12449) Ibid at paragraphs 14 and 16
(#P154_12546) Exhibit A10
(#P155_13054) Ibid at paragraphs 2 - 9
(#P158_13252) Transcript PN 494
(#P161_13370) Exhibit A10 at paragraph 16
(#P162_13508) Transcript PN 504
(#P165_13682) Ibid PN 508
(#P168_14032) Exhibit A10 at paragraphs 11 - 13
(#P169_14322) Ibid at paragraphs 14 - 15
(#P172_14685) Ibid at paragraphs 18 - 23
(#P179_14780) Exhibit R9
(#P180_14904) Ibid at paragraph 3
(#P181_15088) Transcript PN 536
(#P184_15364) Ibid PN 541 - 544 and Exhibit R9 at paragraphs 12 and 14
(#P187_15932) Exhibit R9 at paragraphs 5 - 7
(#P190_16547) Ibid at paragraphs 8 - 11
(#P193_16702) Ibid at paragraphs 16 - 19
(#P198_16793) Exhibit R10
(#P199_17008) Ibid at paragraph 2 and 5
(#P202_17712) Ibid at Attachment KS-1 and Transcript PN 566 - 568
(#P205_17915) Transcript PN 577
(#P206_18213) Ibid PN 593 - 594
(#P209_18602) Ibid PN 598
(#P210_18793) Ibid PN 611 - 613
(#P211_18968) Ibid PN 599 - 609
(#P214_20075) Ibid PN 618 - 620 and 629 - 635
(#P217_20379) Ibid PN 621 - 623 and 626
(#P220_20735) Ibid PN 625 and 627 - 628
(#P223_21425) Ibid PN 637 - 654
(#P226_21793) Ibid PN 655 - 656
(#P229_22504) Ibid PN 803
(#P232_23295) Ibid PN 804 - 807 and 812
(#P235_23670) Ibid PN 657 - 668
(#P238_23901) Exhibit R10 at paragraph 38
(#P239_24320) Transcript PN 679 - 702
(#P242_25075) Ibid PN 714 - 722
(#P247_26506) Ibid PN 737 - 748
(#P250_26770) Ibid PN 750 - 754
(#P251_26901) Ibid PN 766
(#P252_27159) Ibid PN 843 - 844
(#P255_27670) Ibid PN 750 - 780 and Exhibit R10 at paragraph 18
(#P258_28073) Ibid PN 789 - 794
(#P259_28212) Ibid PN 796
(#P260_28346) Ibid
(#P261_28825) Ibid PN 797 and Exhibit R10 at paragraph 31
(#P264_29344) Exhibit R10 at paragraph 20
(#P267_30056) Ibid at paragraphs 25 - 28 and 32
(#P270_30886) Ibid at paragraphs 35 - 37 and 39
(#P275_30972) Exhibit R12
(#P276_31281) Ibid at paragraphs 2 and 16 and Transcript PN 886 - 890
(#P279_31609) Transcript PN 894 - 899
(#P280_31848) Ibid PN 900 - 904 and Exhibit R12 at paragraph 42
(#P281_32194) Ibid PN 905 - 912
(#P284_32755) Ibid PN 913 - 918 and 924
(#P287_33137) Ibid PN 925 and Exhibit R12 at paragraph 13
(#P288_33575) Ibid PN 926 - 931
(#P291_34488) Ibid PN 992 - 1001 and 1004
(#P292_34751) Ibid PN 1002 and 1065
(#P293_34894) Ibid PN 1066 - 1067
(#P296_35471) Ibid PN 932 - 943
(#P297_35896) Ibid PN 945 - 962
(#P300_36763) Ibid PN 963 - 970
(#P303_37203) Exhibit R12 at paragraphs 17 - 18
(#P304_37551) Ibid at paragraphs 19 - 20
(#P305_37723) Ibid at paragraph 25
(#P306_37915) Ibid at paragraph 26
(#P309_38463) Transcript PN 963, 971 - 974 and 1068 - 1072
(#P310_38765) Ibid PN 987 - 991
(#P311_39035) Ibid PN 1070 - 1076
(#P314_39970) Ibid PN 975 - 985
(#P315_40164) Ibid PN 1090 - 1097
(#P318_40480) Exhibit R12 at paragraph 23
(#P319_40789) Transcript PN 1005 - 1009
(#P320_41134) Ibid PN 1125
(#P323_41273) Ibid PN 1031
(#P324_41810) Ibid PN 1012 - 1026, 1032 and 1056 - 1061
(#P327_42299) Ibid PN 1034 - 1050
(#P328_42558) Ibid PN 1051 and 1063
(#P331_42627) Exhibits R5 and R6
(#P332_42894) Transcript PN 1078 - 1080
(#P341_43324) Ibid PN 13 and 1209
(#P342_43466) Ibid PN 13
(#P343_43751) Ibid PN 14 and 1210
(#P344_43914) Ibid PN 1210 and Exhibit A11 at paragraphs 3 - 4
(#P345_44051) 2003 IR 215, Transcript PN 1211 - 1214 and Exhibit A11 at paragraph 5
(#P348_44579) Ibid PN 16 and Exhibits A1 and A2 at paragraph 9
(#P349_44953) Ibid PN 1215, Exhibit A1 at paragraph 10 and Exhibit A11 at paragraph 6
(#P352_45315) Ibid PN 168
(#P353_45516) Ibid PN 169
(#P356_45856) Ibid PN 1216 and Exhibit A11 at paragraph 7
(#P357_46595) Ibid PN 1217 - 1219 and ibid at paragraph 8
(#P360_47300) Ibid PN 1220 and ibid at paragraph 9
(#P363_48013) Ibid PN 1221 - 1223
(#P366_48245) PR977445, 27 June 2007, Exhibit A11 at paragraph 10 and Transcript PN 1228 - 1229
(#P369_49100) Transcript PN 1230 - 1232 and Exhibit A11 at paragraphs 11 - 12
(#P374_49681) [2010] FWAFB 3488, Exhibit A 11 at paragraph 16 and Transcript PN 1236 - 1237
(#P375_50096) Exhibit A11 at paragraphs 13 - 14 and Ibid PN 1237
(#P378_50874) Ibid at paragraph 17 and ibid PN 1238
(#P381_51271) Ibid at paragraph 18 and ibid PN 1239
(#P382_51432) Ibid PN 1240
(#P383_51576) Ibid PN 27 - 28
(#P386_52093) Ibid PN 29 and Exhibits A1 and A2 at paragraph 17
(#P387_52615) Ibid PN 28 - 29
(#P390_52968) [2010] FWA 8426
(#P391_53342) Transcript PN 1241 - 1243 and Exhibit A11 at paragraphs 20 and 22
(#P394_54112) Ibid PN1244 - 1246 and ibid at paragraphs 23 - 25
(#P397_54734) Ibid 1247 - 1249 and ibid at paragraph 26
(#P400_54901) Ibid PN 1250
(#P403_55194) Ibid PN 31
(#P404_55979) Ibid PN 32 - 33
(#P409_56233) Ibid PN 35 and 1252 and Exhibit A11 at paragraph 29
(#P410_56613) Ibid PN 35 - 36
(#P413_56883) Ibid PN 1253 and Exhibit A11 at paragraph 30
(#P414_57375) Ibid PN 1253 - 1256
(#P417_58223) Ibid PN 1257 - 1260
(#P420_58977) Exhibits R5 and R6
(#P421_59230) Transcript PN 1260 - 1267 and Exhibit A11 at paragraphs 33 - 36
(#P424_59601) Ibid PN 1268 - 1271
(#P425_60072) Ibid PN 1272
(#P430_60295) Ibid PN 37 and Exhibit A11 at paragraph 39
(#P431_60533) Ibid PN 1278 and ibid at paragraphs 44 - 45
(#P432_60811) (2011) FCAFC 54
(#P433_60920) Transcript PN 1278 - 1279
(#P436_61114) Ibid PN 37
(#P437_61410) Exhibit A11 at paragraphs 40 - 42
(#P438_61842) Ibid at paragraphs 46 - 47
(#P443_62410) Ibid at paragraphs 53 - 55 and Transcript PN 38 - 39 and 1280
(#P446_62994) Ibid at paragraph 54 and ibid PN 1281
(#P449_63165) Ibid at paragraph 56
(#P450_63445) Transcript PN 1282
(#P453_63605) Ibid PN 1282 - 1289
(#P456_63917) Ibid PN 39 - 41 and 1280 and Exhibit A11 at paragraph 57
(#P461_64352) Ibid PN 155 and 1303 and Exhibit R13 at paragraph 1.2
(#P462_64669) Ibid PN 1303
(#P465_64898) Ibid PN 1304 - 1305
(#P468_65122) (2003) IR 215
(#P469_65365) Transcript PN 1310 - 1312
(#P474_65513) Ibid PN 1313
(#P477_66025) Ibid PN 1313, Exhibit R13 at paragraphs 1.8 and 2.2 -2.7 and Exhibit R7 at paragraph 5.2
(#P478_66162) [2010] FWAFB 3488
(#P479_66389) Transcript PN 1313 - 1329
(#P484_66838) Ibid PN 67
(#P487_67116) Ibid PN 67 - 69 and 74
(#P490_67695) Ibid PN 70 - 71
(#P493_67987) Ibid PN 71
(#P494_68329) Ibid PN 72 - 73
(#P499_68840) Ibid PN 1330
(#P500_69038) Ibid PN 153 - 154 and Exhibit R13 at paragraphs 3.1-3.2
(#P503_69157) Ibid PN 1332
(#P504_69249) (2009) 188 IR 297 and Transcript PN 1333 - 1341
(#P505_69566) Ibid PN 1347 - 1349 and Exhibit R7 at paragraph 6.17
(#P508_69873) (1984) 8 IR 34 and (1984) 9 IR 115, Exhibit R7 at paragraphs 6.2-6.3 and Transcript PN 153 and 1371 - 1372
(#P509_70476) Transcript PN 154 and 1375
(#P510_70800) Ibid PN 1376 - 1380
(#P515_71275) Ibid PN 77 and 1385 and Exhibit R13 at paragraph 2.2
(#P516_71389) Exhibit R1
(#P517_71543) Transcript PN 83
(#P518_71657) Ibid PN 1385
(#P521_71896) Ibid PN 74
(#P522_72650) Ibid PN 75 - 76
(#P525_73205) Ibid PN 1384
(#P526_73298) Exhibit R3
(#P527_73465) Ibid and Transcript PN 84
(#P530_74470) Transcript PN 88 - 90
(#P533_74648) Ibid PN 1386
(#P534_74939) Ibid PN 1387
(#P537_75364) Ibid PN 49 and Exhibit R7 at paragraph 7.1
(#P538_75707) Ibid PN 53, Exhibit R1 and Exhibit R13 at paragraph 4.3
(#P539_75915) Ibid PN 54 and Exhibit R13 at paragraph 4.4
(#P540_76236) Ibid PN 1389 - 1391 and ibid at paragraph 4.7
(#P543_76429) Ibid PN 1393
(#P544_76567) Exhibit R5
(#P545_76666) Exhibit R6
(#P546_76845) Transcript PN 117
(#P547_77079) [2010] FWAFB 7578 and ibid PN 1393 - 1397
(#P554_77731) [2010] FWA 6280
(#P555_77888) Exhibit R7 at paragraph 10.9
(#P558_78075) Ibid at paragraph 11.2
(#P561_78185) Ibid at paragraphs 11.3 and 11.5
(#P564_78385) Ibid at paragraphs 11.4
(#P567_78621) Ibid at paragraphs 11.7 - 11.10
(#P570_79000) Ibid at paragraph 11.11-11.12
(#P571_79158) Ibid at paragraph 11.13
(#P574_79804) Ibid at paragraph 11.14
(#P577_79993) Ibid at paragraph 11.15
(#P603_81424) Explanatory Memorandum in relation to the Fair Work Bill 2008
(#P645_87915) [2010] FWA 8426
(#P669_90688) Ibid
Printed by authority of the Commonwealth Government Printer
Crema and others
Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd [2012] FWA 5322
(2009) 188 IR 297
(1984) 8 IR 34
(1984) 9 IR 115