Carroll v Karingal Inc [2016] FWC 3709

(#P57_2221) Exhibit R9 para 12

(#P58_2343) Exhibit R9 para 13

(#P61_2492) Exhibit R9 paras 15 & 18, R11

(#P62_2677) Exhibit R9 para 17 & 20

(#P67_2805) Exhibit R9 para 21-22

(#P68_3022) Exhibit R9 para 27

(#P69_3249) Exhibit R9 para 28

(#P72_3537) Exhibit R9 para 30, 32

(#P75_3730) Exhibit R9 para 42

(#P76_3873) Exhibit R9 para 42

(#P79_4056) Exhibit R9, para 44

(#P80_4223) Exhibit R9, para 45

(#P83_4378) Exhibit R9, attachment MW-14

(#P84_4539) Exhibit R9, attachment MW-14

(#P85_4743) Exhibit R9, attachment MW-14

(#P88_4883) Exhibit R9 para 53

(#P89_5040) Exhibit R9 para 53

(#P90_5244) Exhibit R9 para 53, Exhibit R1

(#P91_5457) Exhibit A1

(#P94_5607) Exhibit R9 para 56, attachment MW-15

(#P95_5776) Exhibit R9, attachment MW-15

(#P96_5980) Exhibit R9, attachment MW-15

(#P143_8238) Employer Response to Unfair Dismissal Application, filed 30 September 2015, p.3

(#P174_11155) Byrne v Australian Airlines Ltd (1995) 185 CLR 410, 465 (McHugh and Gummow JJ)

(#P177_11309) Sayer v Melsteel Pty Ltd [2011] FWAFB 7498, [14]

(#P182_11835) Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s. 387(a)

(#P183_12024) Selvachandran v Peteron Plastics Pty Ltd (1995) 62 IR 371, 373

(#P184_12184) Ibid

(#P187_12328) Walton v Mermaid Dry Cleaners Pty Ltd (1996) 142 ALR 681 at 685

(#P188_12606) Ibid

(#P193_12849) PN5659

(#P195_12973) Respondent's Closing Submissions, filed 8 April 2016, p.2

(#P198_13328) PN5428

(#P203_13838) King v Freshmore (Vic) Pty Ltd (unreported, AIRCFB, Ross VP, Williams SDP, Hingley C, 17 March 2000) Print S4213

(#P204_14194) Edwards v Giudice [1999] FCA 1836; (1999) 94 FCR 561, 565

(#P209_14544) PN757

(#P210_14689) PN763

(#P211_14776) PN758

(#P216_15103) PN803

(#P217_15202) PN804

(#P222_15410) PN781

(#P223_15515) PN781

(#P224_15595) PN781-784

(#P235_16197) Exhibit R5, para 29, attachment AE-14

(#P236_16441) Ibid, para 29, attachment AE-15

(#P237_16914) Ibid, para 30

(#P240_17064) PN326

(#P241_17170) PN327

(#P242_17261) PN330

(#P243_17554) PN329-330

(#P244_17674) PN332

(#P249_17863) Exhibit R5, para 8

(#P250_17994) Ibid, para 8

(#P251_18273) Ibid, para 9

(#P252_18554) Ibid, para 9

(#P253_18692) Ibid, para 9

(#P256_18836) Ibid, para 17

(#P257_19124) Ibid, para 17, attachment AE-6

(#P258_19312) Ibid, para 17

(#P261_19478) PN5433

(#P262_19781) PN5434

(#P263_19972) PN5435

(#P264_20205) PN227-228

(#P267_20323) PN254-257

(#P268_20474) PN270 & 273

(#P271_20621) PN5437

(#P272_20736) Ibid

(#P273_20910) Ibid

(#P274_21093) PN5441

(#P279_21250) Exhibit R5, para 10

(#P280_21421) Ibid, para 11

(#P281_21714) Ibid, para 11

(#P282_21870) Ibid, para 12

(#P285_21998) Ibid, para 20

(#P286_22140) Ibid, para 20

(#P287_22360) Ibid, para 21

(#P290_22562) PN243

(#P291_22871) PN244

(#P298_23079) Exhibit R4, para 14

(#P299_23359) Ibid

(#P300_23507) Exhibit R4, para 15

(#P301_23951) Exhibit R4, SH-2

(#P302_24192) Ibid

(#P305_24474) Exhibit R4, para 16

(#P306_24751) Ibid

(#P307_24941) Ibid

(#P310_25234) PN435-437

(#P315_25402) Exhibit R4, para 20

(#P316_25763) Ibid

(#P319_25934) Ibid, para 21

(#P320_26228) Ibid

(#P321_26370) Ibid

(#P324_26543) Ibid, para 26

(#P325_26744) Ibid

(#P326_26869) Ibid

(#P329_27010) PN447

(#P330_27205) PN449

(#P331_27336) PN450

(#P332_27526) PN453

(#P337_27841) Exhibit R6, para 9

(#P338_28025) Exhibit R6, para 10

(#P339_28261) Exhibit R6, para 11

(#P340_28405) Exhibit R6, para 11

(#P341_28608) Exhibit R6, para 13

(#P342_28851) Exhibit R6, para 13

(#P345_29004) Exhibit R6, para 17

(#P346_29244) Exhibit R6, para 18

(#P347_29457) Exhibit R6, para 18

(#P348_29636) Exhibit R6, para 18

(#P349_29851) Exhibit R6, para 18

(#P352_29996) Exhibit R6, para 19

(#P353_30144) Exhibit R6, para 20

(#P354_30399) Exhibit R6, para 20

(#P355_30510) Exhibit R6, para 20

(#P358_30647) PN612

(#P359_30805) PN615

(#P360_31095) PN616-619

(#P361_31357) PN623

(#P362_31584) PN623

(#P365_31820) Exhibit R17, paras 3-4

(#P366_32059) Exhibit R17, paras 5-6

(#P367_32396) Exhibit R17, para 6

(#P368_32558) Exhibit R17, para 7

(#P369_32754) Exhibit R17, para 8

(#P370_32888) Exhibit R17, para 8

(#P373_33016) Exhibit R17, para 12

(#P374_33222) Exhibit R17, para 12

(#P375_33346) Exhibit R17, para 12

(#P376_33568) Exhibit R17, para 19

(#P379_33775) PN5679

(#P380_34177) PN5684

(#P383_34537) PN5692

(#P390_35681) Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s. 387(b)

(#P391_35876) Crozier v Palazzo Corporation Pty Ltd (2000) 98 IR 137, 151; Gooch v Proware Pty Ltd T/A TSM (The Service Manager) [2012] FWA 10626

(#P392_36091) Previsic v Australian Quarantine Inspection Services (unreported, AIRC, Holmes C, 6 October 1998) Print Q3730,

(#P395_36340) PN5729-5728

(#P396_36466) Exhibit R9, para 53

(#P397_36730) Exhibit R9, para 53

(#P400_36851) Exhibit R11, EH-23

(#P405_37226) Exhibit R11, EH-23

(#P408_37384) Exhibit R 11, EH-23

(#P409_37600) Exhibit R 11, EH-23

(#P412_37808) PN5535

(#P413_37915) Ibid

(#P414_38238) PN5538

(#P415_38347) Ibid

(#P422_38786) Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s. 387(c)

(#P423_38988) Crozier v Palazzo Corporation Pty Ltd (2000) 98 IR 137, 151

(#P424_39185) Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology v Asher (2010) 194 IR 1, 14 citing Gibson v Bosmac Pty Ltd (1995) 60 IR 1, 7 (Wilcox CJ)

(#P425_39548) Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology v Asher (2010) 194 IR 1, 14-15 citing Gibson v Bosmac Pty Ltd (1995) 60 IR 1, 7 (Wilcox CJ)

(#P428_39836) PN5759

(#P429_40063) Respondent's closing submissions, para 30 & PN5729

(#P432_40285) PN5549

(#P433_40475) PN5552

(#P436_40657) Exhibit R9, para 45

(#P437_40808) Exhibit R9, para 45

(#P438_41075) Exhibit R9, para 46

(#P439_41241) Exhibit R9, para 48

(#P440_41442) Exhibit R9, para 49

(#P443_41821) Exhibit R9, para 52

(#P446_42129) Exhibit R1

(#P447_42368) Exhibit R9, attachment MW-14

(#P452_43025) Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s.387(d)

(#P455_43486) Explanatory Memorandum, Fair Work Bill 2008 (Cth) [1542]

(#P458_43657) Exhibit R9 para 53

(#P463_44035) Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s.387(e)

(#P464_44190) Annetta v Ansett Australia Ltd (2000) 98 IR 233, 237

(#P465_44552) Johnston v Woodpile Investments T/A Hog's Breath Caf� - Mindarie [2012] FWA 2, [58]

(#P468_44775) PN5905

(#P469_44899) PN5560

(#P474_45356) Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s.387(f)

(#P475_45725) Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s.387(g)

(#P478_45884) PN5905

(#P483_46119) Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s.387(h)

(#P486_46378) PN5905

(#P489_46652) PN5560

Printed by authority of the Commonwealth Government Printer