[2015] FWC 2526
General information, not legal advice.
Fair Work Commission
2015-07-09
Deputy President Gostencnik, President Gostencnik
Original judgment source is linked above.
(#P30_1568) [2014] FWCD 1004, and
(#P31_2185) Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Industrial Union of Employees, Queensland [2014] FWCFB 7154 and Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2014] FWCFB 7194
(#P34_2602) Ibid at [55] and [42]
(#P59_7000) See for example The Maritime Union of Australia [2014] FWCFB 1973; Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia v Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2014] FWCFB 4397; Re Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2014] FWCFB 6497; Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate [2014] FWCFB 7194; and Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Industrial Union of Employees, Queensland [2014] FWCFB 7154
(#P60_7695) [2015] FCAFC 56
(#P69_12963) Ibid at [13]-[17]
(#P72_13562) Ibid at [42]
(#P75_13868) Ibid at [43]
(#P78_14203) [2015] FWC 1522
(#P95_16761) Ibid at [32]
(#P98_17158) [2015] FCAFC 56 at [25] and [43]
(#P109_18334) Applicants' outline of submissions in reply (13 February 2015) at [12] - [14]
(#P172_24813) Transcript PN33 - PN60 (17 February 2015)
(#P191_30395) [2015] FCAFC 56 at [18]- [25]
(#P194_30898) See for example Nestle Australia Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1987) 16 FCR 167 at 184; Elias v Commissioner of Taxation [2002] FCA 845; (2002) 123 FCR 499 at [62]; Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v New Oakleigh Coal Pty Ltd and another [2012] FWAFB 5107 at [15]
(#P199_32426) [2014] FWCFB 5947
(#P210_37725) Ibid at [23]-[27]
(#P221_39933) Exhibit 2 at [2]
(#P222_40253) Declaration by proposed permit holder (Timothy Jarvis) dated 17 January 2014 at (a) and attachment thereto
(#P223_40503) Ibid
(#P224_40772) Ibid at (m)
(#P229_42399) Declarations by member of committee of management (Gregory Simcoe) dated 8 November 2010 attached to Application for an Entry Permit (Timothy Jarvis) filed 8 November 2010
(#P232_42994) Declaration by proposed permit holder (Timothy Jarvis) dated 17 January 2014 at (b)
(#P233_43265) Ibid at (c)
(#P276_44659) Ibid at (n)
(#P277_45101) Ibid at (o)
(#P278_45284) Ibid at (p)
(#P287_46685) [2012] FMCA 189
(#P289_46837) [2012] FCA 1144
(#P291_46925) BRG1008/2011
(#P293_47062) [2013] FCA 846
(#P327_52887) [2012] FMCA 189 at [6] - [12]
(#P330_53046) Ibid at [22]
(#P331_53207) Ibid
(#P332_53437) Ibid at [23]
(#P333_53658) Ibid
(#P406_59137) [2012] FCA 1144 at [15] - [23]
(#P409_59395) Ibid at [36]
(#P410_59671) Ibid at [37]
(#P411_59800) Ibid at [38]
(#P412_59943) Ibid at [39]
(#P413_60143) Ibid at [40]
(#P414_60401) Ibid at [41]
(#P415_60535) Ibid at [42]
(#P418_60946) Specific Submissions of the Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate (RE2014/531)dated 14 April 2014 at [6]
(#P419_61333) Ibid at [7]
(#P424_62212) [2012] FCA 1273
(#P427_63092) [2012] FCA 1144 at [48]
(#P428_63318) Ibid at [49]
(#P431_63870) CFMEU correspondence to FWC dated 28 April 2014 at [14]
(#P434_65602) Ibid at [15]
(#P483_71296) Agreed Statement of Facts filed in BRG1008/2011 at [3] - [10]
(#P532_75603) [2013] FCA 846 at [25] - [29]
(#P535_75911) Ibid at [34]
(#P536_76178) Ibid
(#P537_76434) Ibid
(#P540_76814) Ibid at [35]
(#P549_78547) Applicant's Outline of Submissions in Reply dated 13 February 2015 at [17]
(#P550_78789) Transcript PN149 - PN152 (17 February 2015)
(#P553_80176) Applicants' submissions pursuant to the statement and directions of Deputy President Gostencnik dated 19 May 2015 dated 2 June 2015 at [8]-[9]
(#P556_81074) See Lend Lease at [37]
(#P557_81144) Ibid at [40]
(#P560_82426) Declaration by proposed permit holder (Timothy Jarvis) dated 17 January 2014 at j) and k)
(#P561_82697) Declaration of member of the committee of management (David Hanna) dated 17 January 2014 at b) and c)
(#P574_87231) Applicants' submissions pursuant to the statement and directions of Deputy President Gostencnik dated 19 May 2015 dated 2 June 2015 at [12]
(#P577_87827) Ibid at [13]
(#P580_88217) Ibid at [14]
(#P583_88616) Submissions of Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate dated 16 June 2015 at [23]
(#P584_89030)
(#P585_89294)
(#P596_92808) Transcript PN 114 (17 February 2015)
(#P597_92917) Submissions of the Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate dated 5 December 2014 at [12] - [21]; Transcript PN 272 - PN 293 (17 February 2015)
(#P600_93844) Exhibit 1 at [2]
(#P603_94043) Declaration by proposed permit holder (Andrew TeMoho) dated 3 March 2014 at (a) and Declaration by member of committee of management (Michael Ravbar) dated 3 March 2014 at (a)
(#P604_94786) See Declaration by proposed permit holder (Andrew TeMoho) dated 21 January 2014
(#P605_95033) TeMoho statement at [19]
(#P606_95115) Affidavit of Michelle Clare affirmed on 17 April 2015
(#P607_95327) Declaration by proposed permit holder (Andrew TeMoho)dated 3 March 2014
(#P608_95440) Affidavit of Michelle Clare affirmed on 17 April 2015 at [4]-[12]
(#P611_95610) Ibid at [2]-[3]
(#P612_95731) Ibid at [5] and [9]
(#P615_97193) TeMoho Statement at [15] - [16]
(#P616_97420) Ibid at [17] - [18]
(#P619_97888) Declaration by proposed permit holder (Andrew TeMoho) dated 21 January 2014 at (b) and Declaration by member of committee of management (Michael Ravbar) dated 21 January 2014 at (a)
(#P620_98256) Declaration by proposed permit holder (Andrew TeMoho) dated 3 March 2014 at (c) and Declaration by member of committee of management (Michael Ravbar) dated 3 March 2014 at (c)
(#P690_99887) Ibid at (e) where second appearing in each case
(#P691_100350) Ibid at (f) in each case
(#P692_100545) Ibid at (g) in each case
(#P699_101070) [2012] FMCA 189
(#P701_101110) [2013] FCA 846
(#P716_102005) [2012] FMCA 189 at [22]
(#P717_102177) Ibid
(#P718_102406) Ibid at [23]
(#P719_102641) Ibid
(#P732_103581) [2013] FCA 846 at [34]
(#P733_103858) Ibid
(#P734_104114) Ibid
(#P737_104485) Ibid at [35]
(#P750_106648) Statutory Declaration of Andrew TeMoho dated 26 February 2014 at [9]
(#P753_107055) Letter from CFMEU to the Commission dated 18 March 2014 at [27]
(#P754_107392) TeMoho statement at [6] - [9]
(#P757_108094) TeMoho statement at [11] - [14]
(#P760_108674) Statutory Declaration of Andrew TeMoho dated 26 February 2014 at [9]
(#P761_109053) Ibid at [11]
(#P764_109317) TeMoho statement
(#P767_109543) Ibid at [29]
(#P782_110702) Ibid at [19] - [22]
(#P795_111767) Statutory Declaration of Andrew TeMoho dated 26 February 2014 at [5], [9] and [11]
(#P800_112660) Submissions of the Director of the Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate dated 5 December 2014 at at [56] - [57]
(#P813_116992) Transcript PN 40 (17 February 2015)
Printed by authority of the Commonwealth Government Printer
(1987) 18 FCR 51
(1990) 27 FCR 427
(2012) 203 FCR 389
(1979) 143 CLR 499
(1987) 16 FCR 167
(2002) 123 FCR 499
(1990) 170 CLR 321
(2012) 201 FCR 297