© 2026 Zoe. All rights reserved.
Zoe is a legal information platform. Always consult the Federal Register of Legislation for authoritative text.
[2015] FWC 641
Fair Work Commission
2015-01-28
Commissioner Roe
Original judgment source is linked above.
(#P28_2229) [2014] FWC 7678.
(#P37_4418) [2014] FWC 7678.
(#P55_5439) [2014] FWC 7678, at paras [15]-[20], [53]-[55] and [84]-[90] in particular.
(#P56_5558) [2014] FWCFB 6737.
(#P57_6590) [2014] FWCFB 6737, at para [54].
(#P71_8302) Submission of SSDS, 13 November 2014, at paras 22 and 25.
(#P98_19556) [2014] FWC 7678, at paras [26], [27], [37], [41] and [42].
(#P115_23538) PN331.
(#P116_23816) PN340.
(#P117_23969) PN431 to PN432.
(#P118_24549) [2014] FWC 7678, at para [29].
(#P123_25223) Exhibit Serco 8, at para 117 and following.
(#P128_27107) PN4480 to PN4481.
(#P137_29032) Exhibit UV 8.
(#P138_29330) PN3646 to PN3649, PN3684 to PN3693 and PN3703.
(#P139_29578) PN3709 to PN3710.
(#P144_31016) PN4052.
(#P149_32350) PN4677.
(#P157_35109) PN3515 to PN3519.
(#P184_45199) Exhibit Serco 8, Statement of Ms Phu, and PN189 and PN192.
(#P185_45626) PN93.
(#P186_45906) PN533 and PN544.
(#P189_46563) PN410.
(#P226_56797) PN4443.
(#P228_57335) Note: There is no direct evidence in respect to unsuccessful candidates for Blackhawk.
(#P229_57514) Note: Broadlex is probably an exception. There is no conclusive evidence in respect to Blackhawk. However, given that Blackhawk advised that there were 25 positions to fill and that only 15 SSDS employees were appointed it is likely that external applicants also got jobs.
(#P230_57903) Note: external candidates were probably not considered in the case of Broadlex. MSS, Compass and Spotless guaranteed internal candidates an interview but not external candidates.
(#P233_58252) See for example Statement of Mr Marriott, at para 161, and Mr Castles at PN4524.
(#P234_58493) PN282 and PN88.
(#P235_58672) PN297 and PN133.
(#P236_58918) PN499 and PN501.
(#P237_59057) PN509.
(#P238_59380) PN1521 to PN1525.
(#P248_60831) PN2271 to PN2277.
(#P249_61056) PN2276 and PN168 to PN170.
(#P254_61967) PN3506.
(#P269_64494) Exhibit Serco 9, Attachments NM103 and NM104.
(#P276_65544) Exhibit Serco 10, Attachment ML29, and Exhibit Serco 9, Attachment NM143.
(#P279_66288) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM103.
(#P280_66489) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM105.
(#P283_67789) PN2076 and PN2155.
(#P288_68589) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM86.
(#P295_69188) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM86.
(#P300_69589) PN2170.
(#P303_69742) PN2255.
(#P306_70221) [2014] FWC 7678, at paras [44] and [60]-[63] in particular.
(#P316_71736) PN2094.
(#P319_72573) PN2109.
(#P326_72902) PN2238 to PN2239.
(#P331_73647) Exhibit Serco 10, Attachment ML17.
(#P334_74385) PN2065 and PN2138.
(#P337_74575) PN2082.
(#P338_74878) PN2135 to PN2137.
(#P349_77867) PN1619 to PN1625.
(#P350_78170) PN1626.
(#P353_78836) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM62.
(#P354_78940) PN1645.
(#P357_79364) PN1630 to PN1631.
(#P358_79579) PN1675.
(#P359_79805) PN1713 and PN1749.
(#P362_80165) PN1635 to PN1639.
(#P363_80398) PN1642.
(#P366_80728) PN1666.
(#P369_81437) PN1720.
(#P380_83080) PN1712 to PN1714 and PN1749 to PN1754.
(#P385_83619) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM60.
(#P386_83705) See Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM73.
(#P389_84641) Exhibit Serco 10, Attachments ML6 to M13.
(#P394_85499) Exhibit Serco 11, at para 124.
(#P397_85640) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachments TM42, TM43 and TM64.
(#P398_86206) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM42.
(#P403_86781) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM43.
(#P406_86908) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM52.
(#P407_87164) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM64.
(#P410_87402) PN852 to PN853.
(#P411_87903) See [2014] FWC 7678, particularly at paras [60] to [63].
(#P414_88695) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM44.
(#P419_90141) PN1625 to PN1626.
(#P422_90966) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM51.
(#P425_91453) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM58.
(#P436_95397) PN4570.
(#P437_95853) Exhibit Serco 11, at para 142(c).
(#P446_97310) PN2429 to PN2430.
(#P447_97541) PN2428.
(#P448_97717) PN2489.
(#P449_97870) PN2577.
(#P454_98986) PN2518 to PN2522.
(#P455_99179) PN4546.
(#P458_99368) PN2495.
(#P459_99518) Exhibit Serco 13, Attachments PC12, PC14 and PC17.
(#P467_102145) Letter of 2 December 2014 from Mr McDonnell produced in response to order requested by SSDS.
(#P470_102479) Exhibit Serco 13, at para 23.
(#P477_103804) PN4432.
(#P488_106064) PN1858.
(#P489_106200) PN1861.
(#P490_106334) PN2019 to PN2020.
(#P491_106599) PN1864 to PN1867.
(#P494_106863) PN1940.
(#P495_108134) PN1915 to PN1917 and PN1931.
(#P498_108365) PN1906 to PN1908.
(#P499_108956) PN1824 to PN1825.
(#P500_109266) PN1950 to PN1951.
(#P503_109801) PN1964 to PN1965.
(#P521_113779) PN1488 and Exhibit NUW 3, Statement of Ms Donnini, at para 15.
(#P524_114217) Exhibit NUW 3, Statement of Ms Donnini, at para 11.
(#P525_114470) PN1482.
(#P532_115034) Exhibit Serco 10, Attachment ML45, and confirmed by document in response to order to produce provided 2 December 2014 by Dean Tranda Blackhawk Logistics.
(#P533_115349) PN683.
(#P534_115596) PN688.
(#P537_116334) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM75.
(#P540_116684) PN710.
(#P545_117712) Exhibit Serco 10, Attachment ML45.
(#P562_119870) PN1381.
(#P563_120172) PN1381.
(#P568_120837) Exhibit NUW 2, Statement of Mr McKinnon, at para 2(j).
(#P573_121712) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM123.
(#P576_122004) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM123, email of 3 September 2014, and Exhibit Serco 13, Attachment PC23.
(#P583_123633) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM112.
(#P590_125113) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM126.
(#P593_125296) PN930.
(#P594_125517) PN1371.
(#P595_125735) PN1369.
(#P598_126210) PN1369.
(#P599_126371) PN1379.
(#P602_126597) PN1352 and PN1358.
(#P603_127126) Exhibit Serco 11, Attachment TM112.
(#P604_127368) PN1447.
(#P605_127548) PN1450.
(#P608_127764) PN1454.
(#P613_128718) PN1365.
(#P621_129147) PN1358 to PN1360.
(#P630_130185) PN1389 to PN1391.
(#P634_130359) PN1396.
(#P639_131761) PN4695, PN4699, PN5063, PN3795 and PN3799.
(#P655_135316) [2014] FWC 7678, at paras [44] and [60]-[63].
(#P680_141432) [2014] FWC 7678, at paras [84]-[87].
(#P683_141880) SSDS Supplementary Submissions of 4 December 2014, Attachment 1.
(#P692_145878) PN4681 to PN4690.
Printed by authority of the Commonwealth Government Printer