© 2026 Zoe. All rights reserved.
Zoe is a legal information platform. Always consult the Federal Register of Legislation for authoritative text.
[2014] FWC 8898
Fair Work Commission
2014-12-19
Commissioner Cribb
Original judgment source is linked above.
(#P22_759) Exhibit A7 at paragraph 73
(#P29_1116) Exhibit R4 at paragraphs 8 and 11
(#P86_4100) Exhibit A7 at paragraphs 13 - 16 And Exhibit A3 at paragraph 10
(#P89_4280) Exhibit R4 at paragraph 9
(#P90_4752) Transcript PN 1238 - 1239
(#P97_5242) Exhibit R4 at paragraph 9 and Exhibit A7 at paragraph 11
(#P108_6117) Transcript PN 41 - 80
(#P109_6287) Ibid at PN 35 and Exhibit A3 at Attachment LRB7
(#P110_6480) Ibid PN 117-118
(#P111_6523) Ibid PN 115
(#P112_6674) Exhibit A3 and Exhibit A4
(#P115_6913) Transcript PN 1240
(#P120_7260) Ibid PN 1240
(#P127_7678) Ibid PN 153 - 170
(#P130_7838) Ibid PN 171 - 175 and Exhibit A1 at paragraph 7
(#P133_8003) Ibid PN 177 - 185 and ibid at paragraph 3
(#P136_8195) Ibid at paragraph 8
(#P139_8373) Ibid at paragraph 9 and Transcript PN 197 and 204
(#P142_8622) Ibid PN 198 - 203 and 225 - 227
(#P145_8762) Ibid PN 204 - 205
(#P150_9075) Ibid PN 209 - 214 and 216
(#P153_9343) Ibid PN 218 - 225 and 259 - 261
(#P154_9445) Ibid PN 228
(#P157_9560) Ibid PN 229 - 231 and 237
(#P160_9797) Ibid PN 240 - 242
(#P163_10013) Ibid PN 242 - 250 and Exhibit A1 at paragraph 10
(#P166_10264) Ibid PN 251 - 254 and 257 and ibid at paragraph 11
(#P169_10393) Ibid PN 255 - 256, 258 and 280
(#P172_10574) Ibid PN 262 - 276 and 278 - 282
(#P175_10837) Ibid PN 283 - 287
(#P178_11177) Ibid PN 291 - 293 and 296 - 298 and Exhibit A1 at paragraph 13
(#P181_11406) Ibid PN 294 - 295 and 302 - 309
(#P184_11540) Ibid PN 310 - 311
(#P189_11746) Ibid PN 355 - 361 and Exhibit A2 at paragraph 3
(#P192_11870) Ibid PN 362 - 367
(#P193_11972) Ibid PN 371 and 383
(#P194_12056) Ibid PN 373 - 375 and Exhibit A2 at paragraph 6
(#P197_12263) Ibid PN 377 - 380 and ibid at paragraph 7
(#P200_12491) Ibid PN 382 and 385 - 387
(#P203_12650) Ibid PN 395 - 400 and Exhibit A2 at paragraph 8
(#P206_12987) Ibid PN 401 - 402, 406 and 417 and ibid a paragraph 9
(#P207_13093) Ibid PN 407 - 410
(#P210_13207) Ibid PN 403 - 405 and 420
(#P213_13371) Ibid PN 410 and 412 - 413
(#P218_13618) Ibid PN 488 - 489 and 500 - 501 and Exhibit A3 at paragraph 10
(#P221_13858) Ibid PN 507 - 511 and 667
(#P224_14222) Ibid PN 594, 595, 609, 614 - 615, 617 - 618 and 673 - 675
(#P225_14398) Ibid PN 603 - 604
(#P228_14584) Ibid PN 611 - 613
(#P231_14670) Ibid PN 616 and 672 and Exhibit A3 at paragraph 14
(#P234_14932) Ibid PN 651 - 652 and Exhibit A3 at paragraph 13
(#P237_15192) Ibid PN 665 - 666
(#P240_15549) Ibid PN 669 - 671 and 676 - 678
(#P243_15617) Exhibit A5
(#P246_15682) Ibid at paragraph 3
(#P249_15848) Ibid at paragraph 6 and 7
(#P252_16043) Ibid at paragraphs 8 and 9
(#P255_16237) Ibid at paragraph 10
(#P258_16399) Ibid at paragraph 12
(#P263_16539) Exhibit A7 at paragraph 26 and Transcript PN 1240
(#P264_16733) Ibid at paragraphs 27 - 30
(#P267_16835) Ibid at paragraph 39 and Transcript PN 1240
(#P268_16973) Ibid at paragraphs 36 - 37 and ibid PN 1240
(#P271_17712) Ibid PN 1241
(#P274_18082) Ibid PN 1242
(#P275_18494) Ibid PN 1243
(#P278_18724) Ibid PN 1244
(#P281_19141) Ibid PN 1245 - 1246
(#P284_19425) Ibid PN 1247 - 1250
(#P287_19816) [2011] FWAFB 7642
(#P288_19904) Exhibit A8 at paragraph 8(b)
(#P291_20333) Ibid at paragraph 8(3) and 9
(#P296_20561) Transcript PN 767 - 769
(#P299_20874) Exhibit R3 at paragraph 47 - 48
(#P300_20955) Ibid at paragraph 49
(#P301_21059) Exhibit R4 at paragraph 13 and 15
(#P302_21365) Ibid at paragraph 15
(#P307_21744) Exhibit A8 at paragraphs 7 - 8 and Transcript PN 82 - 91
(#P312_22551) Exhibit A3 at Attachment LRB 6
(#P317_23213) [2011] FWAFB 7642 at [21]
(#P318_23466) Ibid at [23]
(#P335_26439) Exhibit R4 at paragraph 10
(#P338_26646) Exhibit A7 at paragraphs 58 - 59 and Exhibit A3 at paragraphs 20 - 33
(#P351_27410) Exhibit A4 at paragraphs 22 and 32 and Transcript PN 485 - 488
(#P352_27544) Ibid PN 554
(#P355_27652) Ibid PN 556 and Exhibit A4 at paragraphs 17 and 33
(#P356_27950) Ibid PN 557 - 569, 620 - 622, 629 and 636
(#P359_28101) Ibid PN 630 - 632 and Exhibit A4 at paragraph 17
(#P362_28272) Ibid PN 568 and 695
(#P365_28692) Ibid PN 700 - 702
(#P368_28843) Ibid PN 577 - 578 and 696
(#P369_29050) Ibid PN 622 and Exhibit A4 at paragraph 17
(#P372_29231) Ibid PN 644
(#P375_29377) Ibid PN 591 - 592
(#P378_29516) Ibid PN 628
(#P381_29754) Ibid PN 648 - 649 and Exhibit A4 at paragraphs 12 - 13, 20 and 24
(#P384_29967) Exhibit A3 at paragraphs 39 - 41
(#P387_30203) Ibid at paragraphs 33 - 34
(#P390_30496) Exhibit A4 at paragraphs 11, 13 and 21
(#P393_30643) Ibid at paragraph 23
(#P396_30898) Transcript PN 20 and 1237
(#P397_31027) [2012] FCAFC 53
(#P398_31077) Transcript PN 20 and 1231
(#P401_31429) [2012] FWAFB 22066
(#P402_31505) [2012] FWAFB 8461
(#P403_31752) Exhibit A7 at paragraph 73
(#P404_32102) Ibid at paragraphs 73 - 74 and Exhibit A3 at paragraphs 33 - 34
(#P405_32278) Ibid at paragraph 75 and Exhibit A8 at paragraph 13
(#P408_33180) Ibid at paragraphs 76 - 79
(#P411_33702) Ibid at paragraphs 82 - 83
(#P412_33892) Ibid at paragraph 83 and Exhibit A3 at paragraph 38 - 41
(#P415_34518) Ibid at paragraph 88 and Exhibit A8 at paragraphs 14 - 15
(#P418_35071) Exhibit A8 at paragraphs 13 - 14 and Exhibit A4 at paragraph 14
(#P421_35678) Exhibit A8 at paragraph 16
(#P424_35988) Ibid at paragraph 17, Exhibit A4 at paragraph 22 and Transcript PN 1271 - 1272
(#P425_36672) Transcript PN 1271 - 1272
(#P428_36987) Exhibit A8 at paragraph 18 and Exhibit A4 at paragraphs 12 - 13, 16, 20 and 24
(#P429_37403) Transcript PN 1272
(#P432_37937) Ibid PN 1273 - 1275
(#P433_38217) Ibid PN 1278
(#P436_38657) Ibid PN 1276, Exhibit A8 at paragraph 19 and Exhibit A4 at paragraph 85
(#P437_39288) [2014] FWC 6601
(#P438_39406) Transcript PN 1254 - 1263
(#P441_40117) Ibid PN 1266 - 1267
(#P442_40388) Ibid PN 1270
(#P445_40686) Ibid PN 1266 and 1270, Exhibit A8 at paragraph 21 and Exhibit A4 at paragraph 87
(#P448_40854) [2014] FWC 6321
(#P449_40914) Exhibit A8 at paragraph 20
(#P450_41140) Transcript PN 1286 - 1287
(#P459_41523) Exhibit R2 at paragraph 18
(#P462_41862) Ibid at paragraphs 14 - 15
(#P465_42084) Ibid at paragraphs 22 - 26
(#P468_42537) Transcript PN 771 - 772
(#P469_42620) Ibid PN 892
(#P472_43132) Exhibit R2 at paragraph 40
(#P475_43627) Transcript PN 773 - 774 and 836 - 837
(#P478_43805) Ibid PN 838
(#P481_43975) Ibid PN 893 and Exhibit R2 at paragraph 42
(#P482_44143) Ibid PN 912
(#P483_44280) Ibid PN 913 - 914
(#P486_44547) Ibid PN 839
(#P487_44698) Ibid PN 840
(#P490_45105) Ibid PN 775
(#P495_45340) Ibid PN 780
(#P498_45507) Ibid PN 782 - 784
(#P501_45658) Ibid PN 785
(#P504_45948) Ibid PN 833 and 841
(#P507_46305) Ibid PN 842 - 844
(#P510_46426) Ibid PN 845 - 847
(#P513_46819) Exhibit R2 at paragraphs 33 and 41
(#P516_47082) Ibid at paragraphs 34 - 35
(#P517_47239) Ibid at paragraph 36
(#P520_47445) Ibid at paragraph 41 and Transcript PN 853 - 854
(#P523_47668) Ibid PN 855 - 872
(#P524_47842) Ibid PN 873 and 883
(#P527_48076) Ibid PN 884 - 886
(#P530_48428) Ibid PN 887 - 889
(#P533_49032) Exhibit R2 at paragraphs 29 - 31 and 37 - 38
(#P538_49547) Transcript PN 986 and 1160
(#P541_49798) Exhibit R3 at paragraph 11
(#P544_50034) Ibid at paragraphs 23 - 24 and Transcript PN 987
(#P545_50376) Ibid PN 1176 - 1178
(#P548_50591) Exhibit R3 at paragraph 11
(#P551_51081) Transcript PN 1161 - 1165
(#P554_51484) Ibid PN 1172 - 1175
(#P557_51846) Ibid PN 1168 - 1171
(#P562_52069) Exhibit R4 at paragraph 16
(#P565_52178) Ibid at paragraph 17 and Exhibit R5 at paragraph 5
(#P568_52479) Ibid at paragraph 19 and Transcript PN 1302
(#P573_52828) Ibid at paragraph 20
(#P576_53112) Ibid at paragraph 21
(#P579_53448) Exhibit R5 at paragraphs 2 - 4 and Transcript PN 1299 - 1301
(#P582_53580) Ibid at paragraph 5
(#P585_53743) Ibid
(#P608_57237) [2012] FWAFB 8461 at [33]
(#P613_57577) [2014] FWC 6601 at [19]
(#P638_60987) Transcript PN 681
(#P641_61087) Ibid PN 687 - 688
(#P644_61406) Exhibit A4 at paragraphs 16 and 18
(#P647_61817) Ibid at paragraphs 19 and 25
(#P650_62156) Ibid at paragraph 26
(#P653_62303) Ibid at paragraphs 27 - 31
(#P656_62769) Ibid at paragraph 34
(#P659_63137) Ibid at paragraph 35
(#P662_63405) Ibid at paragraph 36
(#P665_63522) Ibid at paragraph 37
(#P672_64091) Transcript PN 917 - 919 and Exhibit R2 at paragraph 39(a)
(#P675_64475) Ibid PN 920 - 921
(#P678_64784) Ibid PN 923 - 926 and 958
(#P679_64933) Exhibit R2 at paragraph 39(b)
(#P682_65112) Transcript PN 927
(#P683_65280) Exhibit R2 at paragraph 39(c)
(#P688_65613) Exhibit R3 at paragraph 28 and Transcript PN 1031 - 1033
(#P691_65904) Ibid at paragraphs 29 - 30 and ibid PN 1034 - 1036
(#P694_66125) Ibid PN 1040 - 1059
(#P695_66364) Ibid PN 1060
(#P698_66587) Ibid PN 1061 - 1065
(#P701_66957) Exhibit R3 at paragraph 30
(#P702_67071) Transcript PN 1060
(#P705_67353) Exhibit R3 at paragraphs 32 - 34
(#P708_67476) Transcript PN 1069 -and 1073 - 1074
(#P709_67626) Ibid PN 1083
(#P712_68059) Ibid PN 1084 - 1085
(#P715_68489) Ibid PN 1091
(#P718_68809) Ibid PN 1096 and Exhibit R3 at paragraph 21
(#P719_68930) Ibid PN 1096
(#P722_69284) Ibid PN 1096, 1097 and 1128
(#P723_69405) Ibid PN 1093 - 1095
(#P726_69683) Ibid PN 1099 and 1125 - 1127
(#P729_69831) Ibid PN 1136 and Exhibit R3 at paragraph 21(b)
(#P730_70037) Ibid PN 1139
(#P733_70231) Ibid PN 1137 and Exhibit R3 at paragraph 21(b)
(#P736_70503) Ibid PN 1135 and 1138 - 1139
(#P739_70935) Ibid PN 1139
(#P742_71282) Ibid PN 1143 - 1146
(#P745_71741) Ibid PN 1151, 1154 - 1159, 1181 and 1191
(#P748_71884) Ibid PN 1190 - 1193
(#P751_72124) Ibid PN 1196 and Exhibit R3 at paragraphs 23 - 24 and 32 - 34
(#P754_72354) Exhibit R4 at paragraph 24
(#P757_72631) Ibid at paragraph 24(a)
(#P760_72797) Ibid at paragraph 24(b)
(#P763_72939) Ibid at paragraph 24(c)
(#P766_73199) Ibid at paragraph 24(d)
(#P769_73320) Ibid at paragraph 24(e)
(#P782_75794) [2013] FWC 4267
(#P785_76213) Ibid at [13]
(#P792_76819) PR559115
Printed by authority of the Commonwealth Government Printer