Appeal by Jetstar Services Pty Ltd [2013] FWCFB 7030 | Case summary

Fair Work Commission (Full Bench)|2013-10-03

(#P45_1288) Section 394 of the .

(#P46_1588) Edited reasons for the decision were published by the Commissioner on 10 May 2013; see [2013] FWC 2959.

(#P47_1873) [2013] FWC 4794.

(#P48_2102) PR539125.

(#P51_2423) PR539291. Reasons were provided in [2013] FWC 5254.

(#P56_2654) Section 604(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009.

(#P57_2866) Part 3-2 of the _Fair Work Act 2009 - _Unfair dismissal.

(#P58_3017) Section 400(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009.

(#P59_3262) Section 400(2) of the Fair Work Act 2009.

(#P60_3439) (1936) 55 CLR 488.

(#P72_4714) [2013] FWC 2959, at para 12.

(#P75_4980) [2013] FWC 2959, at para13.

(#P78_5079) [2013] FWC 2959, at para 14.

(#P81_5265) [2013] FWC 2959, at para 15.

(#P84_5649) See Appeal Transcript, at para 607.

(#P87_5949) [2013] FWC 2959, at para 16-33.

(#P90_6073) [2013] FWC 2959, at para 16.

(#P93_6257) [2013] FWC 2959, at para 23.

(#P98_6644) [2011] FWAFB 1166, at para 24.

(#P105_7706) [2013] FWC 2959.

(#P112_8255) [2013] FWC 2959, at para 32.

(#P115_8458) [2012] FWAFB 7423.

(#P116_8605) PR931440.

(#P129_10721) [2013] FWC 2959, at paras 4-6.

(#P132_10939) See, for example, Transcript before Ryan C, at paras 1442-1444, 1455-1460.

(#P135_11067) Exhibit R6, Attachment GP1 in U2013/5656; Appeal Book p.634 and Transcript before Ryan C at paras 1789-1790.

(#P136_11214) Exhibit R4, Attachment MC3, at p.12 in U2013/5656.

(#P137_11310) Transcript before Ryan C, at paras 2063, 2067 and 2085.

(#P140_11454) Transcript before Ryan C, at para 949.

(#P143_11597) Exhibit R1, at para 29 in U2013/5656; Exhibit R4, Attachment MC3, at p.14 in U2013/5656; Exhibit, R6 Attachment GP1 in U2013/5656; Appeal Book p.626 and Transcript before Ryan C at para 1772.

(#P148_12017) Exhibit A3, at para 8 in U2013/5656.

(#P153_12510) [2013] FWC 2959, at para 32.

(#P154_12668) Transcript before Ryan C, at paras 1504-1514.

(#P155_12769) Transcript before Ryan C, at paras 1510.

(#P156_13464) [2013] FWC 2959 at paras 17-21.

(#P165_14242) [2013] FWC 2959 at para 21.

(#P166_14381) [2013] FWC 2959 at para 17.

(#P169_14469) Transcript before Ryan C, at paras 1406-1555.

(#P170_14970) Transcript before Ryan C, at paras 1496, 1539 and 1550.

(#P171_15107) Transcript before Ryan C, at para 1198.

(#P172_15235) Transcript before Ryan C, at paras 1198 and 1216.

(#P173_15297) Exhibit R1, at para 14 in U2013/5656 and Transcript before Ryan C, at para 1488.

(#P176_15718) Transcript before Ryan C, at paras, 1489-1490, 1497, 1509 and 1514.

(#P177_15871) Exhibit R6, Attachment GP1 in U2013/5656 and Appeal Book p.628.

(#P178_16090) Exhibit R1, at para 14 in U2013/5656 and Transcript before Ryan C, at paras 1203-1204, 1216, 1313, 1497, 1509 and 1514.

(#P183_16478) [2013] FWC 2959 at para 25.

(#P186_16586) [2013] FWC 2959 at para 26.

(#P189_16731) [2013] FWC 2959 at para 27.

(#P192_16868) [2013] FWC 2959 at para 27.

(#P195_16996) [2013] FWC 2959 at para 27.

(#P198_17265) [2013] FWC 2959 at para 28.

(#P201_18054) Briginshaw v Briginshaw [1938] HCA 34; (1938) 60 CLR 336.

(#P204_18835) Transcript before Ryan C, at paras 1141-1144.

(#P205_18926) Transcript before Ryan C, at para 1142.

(#P206_19086) Exhibit R6, Attachment GP1 in U2013/5656 and Appeal Book p.635.

(#P209_19696) [2013] FWC 2959 at para 16.

(#P210_19788) Exhibit R4, Attachment MC2 in U2013/5656.

(#P211_19870) Transcript, at para 143.

(#P212_20011) Exhibit R1, at para 28 in U2013/5656 and Transcript before Ryan C, at paras 1121 and 1148.

(#P213_20266) Transcript before Ryan C, at para 2174.

(#P214_20432) Exhibit R6, Attachment GP1 in U2013/5656 and Appeal Book p.635.

(#P215_20585) Exhibit A3 in U2013/5656.

(#P216_20745) Exhibit A3, at para 8 in U2013/5656.

(#P217_21026) Transcript before Ryan C, at paras 732 and 868-872.

(#P218_21259) Transcript before Ryan C, at para 868.

(#P219_21332) Transcript, before Ryan C at para 870.

(#P226_22398) [2013] FWC 2959, at para 5.

(#P229_22540) Exhibit R4, Attachment MC3 in U2013/5656.

(#P230_22812) Exhibit R4, Attachment MC3, at p. 8 in U2013/5656.

(#P231_23219) Exhibit R4, Attachment MC3, at p. 8 in U2013/5656.

(#P232_23491) Exhibit R4, Attachment MC3, at p. 10 in U2013/5656.

(#P233_23711) Exhibit R4, Attachment MC3, at p. 11 in U2013/5656.

(#P234_23872) Exhibit R4, Attachment MC3, at p. 12 in U2013/5656.

(#P237_24445) Exhibit R6, Attachment GP1 at 635 in U2013/5656.

(#P242_24891) Transcript before Ryan C at paras 2686, 2718 and 2821.

(#P243_24986) Exhibit R4, Attachment MC3 in U2013/5656.

(#P244_25311) Exhibit R6, Attachment GP1 in U2013/5656 and Appeal Book p.628, at para 7.

(#P247_25615) [2013] FWC 2959, at para 16.

(#P248_25670) [2013] FWC 2959, at para 16.

(#P267_28431) Exhibit R1, in this Appeal at para 15.

(#P268_28668) Exhibit R6, Attachment GP1 in U2013/5656 and Appeal Book p.628 (the Police Statement which was provided to the investigators - Exhibit R4, Attachment MC3, at page 7 in U2013/5656).

(#P271_28889) Exhibit R1, in this Appeal at para 16.

(#P272_29049) Exhibit R6, Attachment GP1 in U2013/5656 and Appeal Book p. 628 (the Police Statement which was provided to the investigators - Exhibit R4, Attachment MC3, at page 7 in U2013/5656).

(#P277_30165) Transcript before Ryan C, at para 1609.

(#P278_30294) Transcript before Ryan C, at para 1608.

(#P295_32004) Transcript before Ryan C, at paras 3416-3418.

(#P296_32120) Section 382 of the Fair Work Act 2009.

(#P299_32335) Section 390(1)(b) of the Fair Work Act 2009.

(#P312_32866) Transcript before Ryan C, at paras 3420-3422.

(#P339_34997) Transcript in this Appeal, at para 607.

(#P342_35193) Transcript in this Appeal, at para 607.

(#P343_35459) Print S6238.

(#P344_35581) [1995] IRCA 346; (1995) 62 IR 385 at 393.

(#P345_35653) I.138/1993 at p. 9.

(#P346_35697) Print N4832.

(#P347_35751) (1998) 83 IR 102 at 109-110.

(#P356_36319) Print S6238, at para 25.

(#P361_36608) Transcript in this Appeal, at paras 626-635.

(#P378_38080) Transcript in this Appeal, at para 618.

(#P384_38817) [2008] AIRCFB 15, at para 23 [Majority decision of SDP Acton and SDP Cartwright].

(#P401_41342) Transcript in this Appeal, at para 665.

Printed by authority of the Commonwealth Government Printer

Appeal by Jetstar Services Pty Ltd [2013] FWCFB 7030 (3 October 2013)

At a glance

Court

Decision date

Source

Judgment (101 paragraphs)

Legislation Cited (1)

Cases Cited (4)