© 2026 Zoe. All rights reserved.
Zoe is a legal information platform. Always consult the Federal Register of Legislation for authoritative text.
[2015] FWC 3924
Fair Work Commission
2015-06-11
Commissioner Lewin
Original judgment source is linked above.
(#P99_9318) O'Meara v Stanley Works Pty Ltd [2006] AIRC 496, [23]
(#P104_9768) Kylie Bruce v Fingal Glen Pty Ltd (in liq) [2013] FWCFB 5279, [18] - [19]
(#P107_10099) Kylie Bruce v Fingal Glen Pty Ltd (in liq) [2013] FWCFB 5279, [29]
(#P124_12505) Exhibit MO1, Statement of Matthew O'Shannassy, [5]
(#P127_12825) Exhbit RM1, Statement of Robert McConville, [7]-[10]
(#P142_14481) Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 28 January 2015) PN1016 - PN1026. While there is an issue concerning whether the box was closed I accept the evidence of Mr Ioane that the box was sufficiently open to reveal the apparent presence of the contents as Toll uniform work clothing.
(#P147_15614) Exhibit MO 1, Statement of Matthew O'Shannessy, [3]
(#P152_15839) Exhibit SA1
(#P159_16426) Exhibit MO1, Statement of Matthew O'Shannassy, [5]; Exhibit RM1, Statement of Robert McConville, [3]
(#P166_18789) Exhibit DS1, Statement of Damian James Sloan, [5]
(#P169_18956) Exhibit DS1, Statement of Damian James Sloan, [7]
(#P180_20242) Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 12 March 2015) PN2991 - PN2995
(#P181_20943) Exhibit PB1, Outline of Evidence - Peter Banbury, [6]; Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 6 February 2015) PN359 - PN361
(#P182_21510) Exhibit MO1, Statement of Matthew O'Shannessy, [19]
(#P187_22575) Exhibit RM1, Statement of Robert McConville, [10]
(#P196_24819) See Fingal Glen, Paragraph [15] above
(#P219_27693) Exhibit DS1, Statement of Damien James Sloan, [5]
(#P232_30868) Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 27 January 2015) PN693 - PN696; Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 28 January 2015) PN1632, PN1640
(#P237_32611) Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 6 February 2015) PN347 - PN349
(#P238_33002) Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 6 February 2015) PN396 - PN371
(#P239_33301) Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 6 February 2015) PN342, PN610 - PN611, PN672
(#P242_33804) Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 6 February 2015) PN367 - PN370
(#P269_36912) Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 6 February 2015) PN359 - PN361
(#P272_37446) Exhibit PB1, [7]
(#P273_37501) Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 6 February 2015) PN426
(#P278_38889) Exhibit DS1, Statement of Damian James Sloan, [5]
(#P281_39143) Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 28 January 2015) PN2303 - 2307
(#P286_40132) Exhibit PB1, Outline of Evidence - Peter Banbury, [11]
(#P291_41662) Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 6 February 2015) PN1238 - PN1248
(#P294_42831) Exhibit SA1, Witness Statement of Mr Amiatu
(#P366_48685) Respondent's Outline of Submissions filed 23 December 2015
(#P369_48905) Selvachandran v Peteron Plastics Pty Ltd (1995) 62 IR 371, 373
(#P370_49066) Ibid, 373
(#P371_49238) Miller v University of New South Wales [2003] FCAFC 180; (2003) 132 FCR 147, [13]; Walton v Mermaid Dry Cleaners Pty Ltd (1996) 142 ALR 681, 685.
(#P372_49531) Boris Jurisic v ABB Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FWCFB 5835, [73]; citing Selvachandran v Peteron Plastics Pty Ltd (1995) 62 IR 371, 373; Nettlefold v Kym Smoker Pty Ltd [1996] IRCA 282; (1996) 69 IR 370
(#P379_50359) Exhibit R1
(#P410_53960) Respondent's Additional Submissions filed 27 March 2015, [6] - [7]
(#P413_54440) Exhibit DS 1, Statement of Damian James Sloan, [5]
(#P422_56364) The Macquarie Concise Dictionary (The Macquarie Library Pty Ltd, 2nd ed, 1988), 268
(#P423_56542) Ibid, 460
(#P426_57390) Respondent's Additional Submissions filed 27 March 2015; Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 28 January 2015) PN1137 - PN1145
(#P477_65234) Byrne v Australian Airlines Ltd (1995) 185 CLR 410, 465 (McHugh and Gummow JJ)
(#P482_66778) B, C and D v Australian Postal Corporation T/A Australia Post [2013] FWCFB 6191, [41]
(#P491_68369) Exhibit MO1, MO2, M03
(#P510_70944) Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 12 March 2015) PN2762 - PN2782
(#P513_71624) Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 12 March 2015) PN2522 - PN2523
(#P528_73404) Respondent's Outline of Submissions filed 23 December 2015
(#P531_73732) Perkins v Grace Worldwide (Aust) Pty Ltd (1997) 72 IR 186
(#P534_74284) Ibid, 191
(#P537_74437) Harrington v Coates Hire Operations Pty Limited [2015] FWC 2598, [130]
(#P546_77452) B, C and D v Australian Postal Corporation T/A Australia Post [2013] FWC 9293, [18] - [20]
(#P551_78038) Transcript of Proceedings, Sione Amiatu v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Frank Ioane v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd; Marcello Mastroianni v Toll Ipec Pty Ltd (Fair Work Commission, Commissioner Lewin, 12 March 2015) PN3232
Printed by authority of the Commonwealth Government Printer
Amiatu
Toll Ipec Pty Ltd [2015] FWC 3924
(1992) 67 ALJR 170
(1996) 69 IR 370
(1997) 72 IR 186
(1938) 60 CLR 336
(1995) 185 CLR 410
(1998) 84 IR 1
(1998) 81 IR 410
(1998) 82 IR 102
(1995) 62 IR 371
(2003) 132 FCR 147
(1996) 142 ALR 681