QLDIn ForceAct
Human Rights Act 2019
sec.53Declaration of incompatibility
Start here
Get a plain-English read of sec.53
Turn the raw legal text into a practical explanation grounded in Human Rights Act 2019.
### sec.53 Declaration of incompatibility
This section applies if—
in a proceeding in the Supreme Court a question of law arises that relates to the application of this Act or a question arises in relation to the interpretation of a statutory provision in accordance with this Act; or
a question is referred to the Supreme Court under section 49 ; or
an appeal before the Court of Appeal relates to a question mentioned in paragraph (a) .
The Supreme Court may, in a proceeding, make a declaration (a declaration of incompatibility ) to the effect that the court is of the opinion that a statutory provision can not be interpreted in a way compatible with human rights.
However, the Supreme Court can not make a declaration of incompatibility about a statutory provision if an override declaration is in force in relation to the provision.
If the Supreme Court is considering making a declaration of incompatibility, the court must give notice of that fact in the approved form to the Attorney-General and the commission.
The Supreme Court must not make a declaration of incompatibility unless the court is satisfied—
a notice has been given to the Attorney-General and the commission under subsection (4) ; and
a reasonable opportunity has been given to the Attorney-General and the commission to intervene in the proceeding or to make submissions about the proposed declaration.
For the Supreme Court of Queensland Act 1991 , section 62 , a declaration of incompatibility is taken to be an order of the court in the Trial Division.
(sec.53-ssec.1) This section applies if— in a proceeding in the Supreme Court a question of law arises that relates to the application of this Act or a question arises in relation to the interpretation of a statutory provision in accordance with this Act; or a question is referred to the Supreme Court under section 49 ; or an appeal before the Court of Appeal relates to a question mentioned in paragraph (a) .
(sec.53-ssec.2) The Supreme Court may, in a proceeding, make a declaration (a declaration of incompatibility ) to the effect that the court is of the opinion that a statutory provision can not be interpreted in a way compatible with human rights.
(sec.53-ssec.3) However, the Supreme Court can not make a declaration of incompatibility about a statutory provision if an override declaration is in force in relation to the provision.
(sec.53-ssec.4) If the Supreme Court is considering making a declaration of incompatibility, the court must give notice of that fact in the approved form to the Attorney-General and the commission.
(sec.53-ssec.5) The Supreme Court must not make a declaration of incompatibility unless the court is satisfied— a notice has been given to the Attorney-General and the commission under subsection (4) ; and a reasonable opportunity has been given to the Attorney-General and the commission to intervene in the proceeding or to make submissions about the proposed declaration.
(sec.53-ssec.6) For the Supreme Court of Queensland Act 1991 , section 62 , a declaration of incompatibility is taken to be an order of the court in the Trial Division.
- (a) in a proceeding in the Supreme Court a question of law arises that relates to the application of this Act or a question arises in relation to the interpretation of a statutory provision in accordance with this Act; or
- (b) a question is referred to the Supreme Court under section 49 ; or
- (c) an appeal before the Court of Appeal relates to a question mentioned in paragraph (a) .
- (a) a notice has been given to the Attorney-General and the commission under subsection (4) ; and
- (b) a reasonable opportunity has been given to the Attorney-General and the commission to intervene in the proceeding or to make submissions about the proposed declaration.