Scenario 1: Annual financial audit
A NSW Government agency prepares its annual financial statements under the Government Sector Finance Act 2018. The Audit Office conducts its audit, reviews internal controls, and provides an audit opinion. If the agency has material errors in its accounts or breaches financial management requirements, the Auditor-General may qualify the opinion. The qualified report is tabled in Parliament. The Public Accounts Committee may then call the agency head to explain.
Scenario 2: Performance audit
The Auditor-General decides to conduct a performance audit of a NSW Government program to assess value for money. The Auditor-General has regard to whether there has been wastage of public resources (section 27B(5)). The audit report criticises program management but specifically does not question the Government's policy objective of the program that limit (section 27B(6)) applies even if the Auditor-General believes the policy itself is misconceived.
Scenario 3: Ministerial audit request
A Minister wants an audit of a particular government-owned corporation's IT procurement. Before making the request under section 27B(3)(c), the Minister must consult with the Auditor-General about the scope of the proposed service. Once the audit is conducted, the Minister reimburses the Auditor-General for costs.
Scenario 4: Auditor-General's independence tested
A government agency objects that the Auditor-General's performance audit has strayed into questioning the merit of a Government-endorsed initiative. The Auditor-General must be able to demonstrate that the audit focused on probity, financial prudence, or resource efficiency (section 27B(5)) rather than the underlying policy choice (section 27B(6)). The distinction between auditing "implementation" and questioning "policy" is real but fact-sensitive. The Auditor-General should document the audit rationale carefully to withstand challenge.
Scenario 5: University audit
The University of Sydney (a controlled entity within the meaning of the Government Sector Finance Act 2018) is an auditable entity under this Act. The Auditor-General audits the university's financial reports as part of the annual audit cycle. Any qualification of the university's financial statements is reported to Parliament, which places the matter on the public record.
The Act's audit framework, combined with the financial management obligations in the Government Sector Finance Act 2018, creates a comprehensive accountability system for NSW public resources across all levels of the government sector from central government agencies to statutory bodies, universities, and government-owned corporations.