ABC Learning Centres Ltd (Administrators Appointed) (Receivers & Managers Appointed) ACN 079 736 664 v Honey

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT 1 I have before me a further interlocutory process filed in relation to the administration of the ABC group of companies (the ABC Group). The first plaintiffs in the proceeding, Peter Walker and Gregory Maloney (the Administrators), were appointed administrators of each of the companies in the ABC Group. On the same day, Christopher Honey, Murray Smith and John Crone (the Receivers) were appointed receivers and managers of the same companies. At the time of the appointments, ABC Learning Centres Limited, the holding company, was a listed company. The group provides early childhood development day care and education programs to children throughout Australia and overseas. 2 Since their appointment, the Receivers have had control of the business of the ABC Group and only limited funds have been made available to the Administrators by the Receivers. On 21 August 2009 I made orders extending the convening period for the second meeting of the creditors of each of the companies in the ABC Group to 31 March 2010. The principal reason for making those orders was to facilitate the disposal of the businesses of the ABC Group as a going concern. 3 On 8 March 2010, the Receivers requested the Administrators convene the second meetings of creditors of the ABC Group. It is proposed to hold the second meetings on 26 March 2010. However, on 3 February 2010 summonses for the public examination of various persons were issued by the Court. The examinations are to begin on 12 April 2010. To ensure that sufficient time was available to have the summonses reissued, should a liquidator be appointed at the second meetings, it is necessary that the Administrators convene the meetings as soon as possible. It is proposed that the Administrators will recommend that the second meetings of creditors be adjourned to avoid the complications that might arise if the companies proceed to liquidation before the examinations have been completed. At this stage no deed of company arrangement has been proposed in relation to any of the companies. 4 Several orders for public examination had been made prior to the orders of 3 February 2010. On 9 November 2009 orders for the examination of seven persons were made and on 8, 9 and 10 December 2009 the Administrators conducted examination of those seven persons in Brisbane. On 30 November 2009, further orders were made for examination of other individuals and for the production of documents by various individuals. The orders made on 30 November 2009 required the persons to be examined to appear in Sydney on 1 March 2010. However, it was not possible to review and analyse all of the documents produced in answer to the summonses by 1 March 2010. 5 The Administrators, therefore, considered that it was appropriate to have the orders for examination vacated and for fresh summonses to be issued, returnable at later dates so that sufficient time would be available for the production and review of documents produced pursuant to the orders made on 30 November 2009. The Administrators consider that the most effective and efficient manner in which to proceed with the examination is to divide the further examinations into two tranches. The first tranche consists of the examination of certain management staff. The second consists of the examination of directors, further senior management staff, banking syndicate representatives and third party representatives who have had dealings with the ABC Group. The orders made on 3 February 2010 were for the first tranche of examinations. Those examinations were conducted in Brisbane in the week of 8 March 2010. The examinations in the second tranche are proposed to be conducted in Sydney in the period commencing 12 April 2010. 6 The Administrators have formed the view that at the second meetings of creditors the companies in the ABC Group will be placed into liquidation. It is because of that possibility that it is proposed to recommend the adjournment of those meetings, lest the summonses for examination cease to be valid, following the appointment of liquidators. 7 There are 39 companies in the ABC Group. It is impracticable to conduct creditors meetings of such a large number of related companies separately. To do so often leads to confusion in the minds of creditors, as well as to an increase in the costs involved, in that the meetings invariably take much more time to conduct. The Administrators, therefore, propose that the second meetings of the members of the ABC Group be combined, and held, concurrently, without the need for the creditors of each company resolving to that effect. 8 Since it is proposed that the meetings be adjourned, the Administrators consider that it would be convenient for a facility to be put in place, whereby the second meetings of each of the companies in the ABC Group might be adjourned by a single resolution. However, it is proposed that, if the creditors of any single company wish to have a separate vote, then a separate vote would be conducted in relation to that company. 9 The Administrators are aware of more than 650 creditors of the ABC Group. That information has been gleaned from the report as to affairs, lodged with the Administrators, together with proofs of debt. The total number of potential employee creditors still employed by the members of the ABC Group is in excess of 10,000. ABC Learning Centres Limited continues to maintain an internal email communications system, by which communication is maintained with each centre director. The Administrators propose that notice of the second meetings of creditors be sent by email to each centre, by means of that internal email system. Each centre director would be instructed to place a copy of the notification in each employee's pigeon hole, located at the centre in which the employee works. 10 The notification would state that a copy of the Administrator's report may be obtained, either from the Administrator's web site, or by making a request for a copy to be sent by post. The Administrators have estimated that the cost saving, by notification of the meetings in the manner proposed, would be between approximately $15,000 and $35,000. 11 The application before me is for an order, under s 447A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Act), that Part 5.3A of the Act operate, in relation to the second meetings of creditors, in the following way: (1) There will be a combined notice of meeting for all companies. (2) Creditors will only be notified individually if the creditor has notified the Administrators of a fax number or email address, or has lodged a proof of debt, or is otherwise known to the Administrators. (3) Notification of the meetings to creditors will otherwise be by way of advertisement in daily newspapers and on the Administrators' web site. (4) Notification to current employees will be by the means already described. (5) The notices of meeting will not be accompanied by the Administrators' report but the notice will state that it can be seen on the Administrators' web site or can be made available in hard copy, by post, on request. (6) The meetings of all 39 companies will be combined and held concurrently. (7) If an adjournment resolution is moved, it may be passed by a single resolution of all creditors present, with the safeguard that any creditor of a particular company may request that a separate resolution be passed in relation to that company. 12 In all of the circumstances I am satisfied that the order under s 447A sought by the Administrators is appropriate and, accordingly, I propose to make the order sought.

Schedule 1 All in Administration Receivers and Managers Appointed Company Name A.B.C. Learning Centres Limited Child Care Centres Australia Limited Hutchinson's Child Care Services Limited Kids Campus Limited Peppercorn Management Group Limited A.B.C. Canadian Holdings Pty Limited A.B.C. Corporate Care Pty Limited A.B.C. Developmental Learning A.B.C. Early Childhood Training A.B.C. Education Services Pty Limited A.B.C. Employment Services Pty Limited A.B.C. European Holdings No.1 Pty Limited A.B.C. European Holdings No.2 Pty Limited A.B.C. European Holdings No.3 Pty Limited A.B.C. Land Holdings Pty Limited A.B.C. Learning Centres Finance Pty Limited A.B.C. New Ideas Pty Limited A.B.C. Queensland Pty Limited A.B.C. USA Holdings Pty Limited A.B.C. USA Property Holdings No.1 Pty Limited A.B.C. USA Property Holdings No.2 Pty Limited Childcare Development Solutions DPPA Pty Limited Flel Pty Limited FutureOne Pty Limited HCCS Operations Pty Limited Kids Campus (W.A.) Pty Limited Kids Campus Australia Pty Limited Kids Campus Holdings Pty Limited Klendo Pty Limited Marshen Pty Limited Peppercorn Holdings No.1 Pty Limited Peppercorn Holdings No.2 Pty Limited Peppercorn Holdings No.3 Pty Limited Peppercorn Holdings No.4 Pty Limited Peppercorn Holdings No.5 Pty Limited Peppercorn Holdings No.6 Pty Limited Premier Early Learning Centres Pty Limited Select Child Care Management Pty Limited ACN 079 736 664 100 250 646 100 493 874 099 815 472 087 155 860 126 839 941 098 738 928 Centres Pty Limited 010 788 502 College Pty Limited 069 159 566 107 310 743 130 442 394 122 710 123 122 710 132 128 132 829 108 964 227 125 820 395 112 237 377 129 029 769 121 360 147 126 641 665 126 641 674 Pty Limited ATF the Childcare Development Solutions Unit Trust 107 241 181 114 743 092 096 172 075 009 221 470 097 846 707 112 150 099 104 407 187 107 379 751 098 366 968 101 400 104 095 599 250 099 074 781 100 679 374 101 236 766 103 201 136 103 210 751 100 831 856 093 925 056

At a glance

Court

Decision date

Before

Catchwords

Source

Catchwords

Judgment (8 paragraphs)

Parties

Legislation Cited (1)