//
© 2026 Zoe. All rights reserved.
Zoe is a legal information platform. Always consult the Federal Register of Legislation for authoritative text.
[2008] FCA 1943
Federal Court of Australia
2008-11-07
Emmett J
Original judgment source is linked above.
THE COURT ORDERS THAT: 1. The Plaintiff have leave to file in the Registry an originating process in the form initialled and dated with today's date by the Honourable Justice Emmett. 2. Pursuant to s 447A(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Act) Part 5.3A of the Act is to operate in relation to each of the Second Plaintiffs such that notice of the first meeting of creditors of the Second Plaintiffs convened pursuant to s 436E of the Act will be validly given to any creditors who appear from the books and records of the Second Plaintiffs to be employees of any of the Second Plaintiffs by: (a) sending notice of the meeting to the personal electronic addresses of each employee creditor of the Second Plaintiffs at such addresses as are recorded in the books and records of the Second Plaintiffs; (b) directing each director, of each childcare centre operated by any of the Second Plaintiffs, to distribute the notice to each employee using each employee's pigeon hole located at the centre at which the employee works; (c) causing notice of the meeting to be published in The Australian newspaper; and (d) placing notice of the meeting on the website that is maintained by the Administrators at least 5 business days before the first meeting. 3. The costs and expenses of this proceeding be costs and expenses of the administration of the Second Plaintiffs. Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
Schedule 1 All in Administration and with Receivers and Managers Appointed Company Name ACN A.B.C. Learning Centres Limited 079 736 664 Child Care Centres Australia Limited 100 250 646 Hutchinson's Child Care Services Limited 100 493 874 Kids Campus Limited 099 815 472 Peppercorn Management Group Limited 087 155 860 A.B.C. Canadian Holdings Pty Limited 126 839 941 A.B.C. Corporate Care Pty Limited 098 738 928 A.B.C. Developmental Learning Centres Pty Limited 010 788 502 A.B.C. Early Childhood Training College Pty Limited 069 159 566 A.B.C. Education Services Pty Limited 107 310 743 A.B.C. Employment Services Pty Limited 130 442 394 A.B.C. European Holdings No.1 Pty Limited 122 710 123 A.B.C. European Holdings No.2 Pty Limited 122 710 132 A.B.C. European Holdings No.3 Pty Limited 128 132 829 A.B.C. Land Holdings Pty Limited 108 964 227 A.B.C. Learning Centres Finance Pty Limited 125 820 395 A.B.C. New Ideas Pty Limited 112 237 377 A.B.C. Queensland Pty Limited 129 029 769 A.B.C. USA Holdings Pty Limited 121 360 147 A.B.C. USA Property Holdings No.1 Pty Limited 126 641 665 A.B.C. USA Property Holdings No.2 Pty Limited 126 641 674 Childcare Development Solutions Pty Limited ATF the Childcare Development Solutions Unity Trust 107 241 181 DPPA Pty Limited 114 743 092 Flel Pty Limited 096 172 075 FutureOne Pty Limited 009 221 470 HCCS Operations Pty Limited 097 846 707 Kids Campus (W.A.) Pty Limited 112 150 099 Kids Campus Australia Pty Limited 104 407 187 Kids Campus Holdings Pty Limited 107 379 751 Klendo Pty Limited 098 366 968 Marshen Pty Limited 101 400 104 Peppercorn Holdings No.1 Pty Limited 095 599 250 Peppercorn Holdings No.2 Pty Limited 099 074 781 Peppercorn Holdings No.3 Pty Limited 100 679 374 Peppercorn Holdings No.4 Pty Limited 101 236 766 Peppercorn Holdings No.5 Pty Limited 103 201 136 Peppercorn Holdings No.6 Pty Limited 103 210 751 Premier Early Learning Centres Pty Limited 100 831 856 Select Child Care Management Pty Limited 093 925 056
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY NSD 1749 of 2008
IN THE MATTER OF ABC LEARNING CENTRES LIMITED & ORS, PETER WALKER & GREGORY MOLONEY (IN THEIR CAPACITY AS VOLUNTARY ADMINISTRATORS OF ABC LEARNING CENTRES LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) (RECEIVERS & MANAGERS APPOINTED) ACN 079 736 664 & THE COMPANIES LISTED IN SCHEDULE 1
AND ABC LEARNING CENTRES LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) (RECEIVERS & MANAGERS APPOINTED) ACN 079 736 664 & THE COMPANIES LISTED IN SCHEDULE 1
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT 1 I have before me an application for orders pursuant to s 447A(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Act). Section 447A(1) provides that the Court may make such order as it thinks appropriate about how Part 5.3A of the Act is to operate in relation to a particular company. Part 5.3A is concerned generally with the administration of a company's affairs with a view to executing a deed of company arrangement. Under s 436A, a company may appoint an administrator of the company if its board has resolved to the effect that, in the opinion of the directors, the company is insolvent and an administrator of the company should be appointed. 2 Section 436E of the Act provides that the administrator of a company under administration must convene a meeting of the company's creditors in order to determine whether to appoint a committee of creditors and, if so, who are to be the committee's creditors. Section 436E provides that such a meeting must be convened at least two business days before the meeting, by giving written notice of the meeting to as many of the company's creditors as is reasonably practicable, and causing notice of the meeting to be published in a national newspaper. 3 The First Plaintiffs, Messrs Peter Walker and Gregory Maloney (the Administrators), were appointed as joint administrators of each of the Second Plaintiffs on 6 November 2008. The Second Plaintiffs consist of ABC Learning Centres Limited (ABC) and other companies associated with ABC. There are some 39 companies in the group and the Administrators have been appointed to each of them. On the same day, Messrs Christopher Honey, Murray Smith and John Cronin (the Receivers) were also appointed joint receivers and managers of each of the Second Plaintiffs. 4 ABC is a public, listed company. Its business involves providing early childhood development, day care and education programs to children throughout Australia in both franchised and managed childcare centres. Having regard to the recency of the Administrators' appointment, they are unable to provide any more detailed analysis of the activities of the companies in the group. The group employs permanent staff who work at 1075 centres throughout Australia. 5 ABC Developmental Learning Centres Pty Limited (ABC Developmental Learning) is one of the plaintiffs. ABC Developmental Learning is the actual employer of all of the permanent staff of the Group. The books and records of ABC Developmental Learning indicate that there are approximately 16,000 employees, although the precise number fluctuates according to factors such as seasonal considerations, holidays, family movements and the like. ABC Development Learning maintains an internal email communication system, called Communications Central, by which communication is maintained with each centre director. 6 The group also employ a significant number of casual staff. The casual staff, however, are provided by a recruitment placement agency known as 123 Careers. The books and records of the Second Plaintiffs do not record such casual staff as direct creditors. However, 123 Careers is shown as a creditor in respect of remuneration due to the casual staff. 7 All permanent employees have personal email addresses with ABC Developmental Learning and the Administrators have considered obtaining notifications from employee creditors of their email address to have notices sent to them by email pursuant to s 600G of the Act. Section 600G provides that, if a person is authorised or required to give or send a notice to a person under various provisions of the Act, including s 436E, a fax number or electronic address may be notified, in which case notice to that address will be sufficient. The Administrators are concerned that there is not sufficient time to obtain responses from all employee creditors confirming that they are willing to be notified by email and thus for s 600G to apply. 8 Because of the appointment of the Receivers to the Second Plaintiffs, there are only limited funds available to the Administrators to fund the administration of the Second Plaintiffs. The administrators have estimated that the cost of mailing circulars giving notice to the permanent employees of the first meeting of creditors would be between $42,600 and $47,600. In the circumstances, the Administrators have asked the Court to order, pursuant to s 447A, that Part 5.3A is to operate in relation to each of the Second Plaintiffs, such that notice of the first meeting of creditors will be validly given to any creditors who appear in the books and records of the second plaintiffs as employees, by sending notice of the meeting to the personal electronic addresses to which I have referred, and having each director of a childcare centre distribute the notice to each employee by using the employee's pigeonhole. It is also proposed to cause notice of the meeting to be published in The Australian newspaper, which circulates throughout Australia, and by placing notice of the meeting on the website maintained by the Administrators. 9 In all of the circumstances, having regard to the nature of the functions to be performed at the first meeting, it is appropriate to accede to the Administrators' application. I certify that the preceding nine (9) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Reasons for Judgment herein of the Honourable Justice Emmett.
Associate: Dated: 9 December 2008 Counsel for the Plaintiffs: Mr M Oakes SC Solicitor for the Plaintiffs: Kemp Strang Date of Hearing: 7 November 2008 Date of Judgment: 7 November 2008