Compliance with the Torres Strait Fisheries Act 1984 (Qld) requires an understanding of the interplay between State and Commonwealth law, and between the Act and the Fisheries Act 1994. The following steps are necessary for operators, regulators, and traditional inhabitants.
First, determine whether the activity in question falls within the Torres Strait area as defined in section 4. If the activity is within the Protected Zone, the Act applies. If it is outside the Protected Zone but within an area adjacent to it for which a proclamation under section 15 of the Commonwealth Act is in force, and the activity is specified in the proclamation, the Act also applies (s 4(1)). If neither condition is met, the Act does not apply, and the Fisheries Act 1994 (Qld) applies without the modifications in this Act.
Second, classify the fishing activity. If the activity is traditional fishing (taking for consumption or traditional use by traditional inhabitants), it is not commercial fishing and is not subject to licensing under this Act, but may be subject to conservation measures adopted under the Treaty schedule (Article 15(2)). Ensure that the method, equipment or vessel is not of a kind specified in a notice under section 3(2) of the Commonwealth Act; if it is, the activity is not traditional fishing under the Act and becomes commercial fishing (s 6(1) def traditional fishing). If the activity is commercial fishing, determine whether it falls within community fishing. Community fishing is only available to persons who are both traditional inhabitants and Australian citizens and who are not under an obligation to act in accordance with directions of a non-citizen/non-traditional inhabitant (s 6(1) def community fishing). If the commercial fisher does not meet these criteria, they are engaged in ordinary commercial fishing.
Third, ascertain management arrangements. Check whether there is an arrangement in force under Part 3 for the relevant fishery. If there is, the fishery may be managed by the Protected Zone Joint Authority under either Commonwealth or State law. If the fishery is managed under Commonwealth law, the Fisheries Act 1994 does not apply to the taking of fish for that fishery (s 5), and State inspectors are authorised to enforce Commonwealth law (s 23). If the fishery is managed under State law, the Joint Authority exercises licensing powers under the Fisheries Act 1994 instead of the Minister (s 20(2)). Existing authorities under the Fisheries Act 1994 that apply to the fishery may cease to apply (s 20(5)). Ensure that any fishing is carried out under an authority issued by the Joint Authority, not under an ordinary State licence.
Fourth, for commercial fishing in a Protected Zone Joint Authority fishery, obtain the appropriate licence. If the licence is issued by the Commonwealth and bears a current endorsement under section 20 of the Commonwealth Act, it is deemed to be a State licence of a similar kind (s 8). If the licence is issued by the Joint Authority under State law, it must be limited to Joint Authority fisheries (s 20(3)). Foreign boats cannot be licensed by the Joint Authority under State law (s 20(6)); they must be licensed under Commonwealth law.
Fifth, comply with the relevant fisheries laws and regulations. If fishing in areas under the jurisdiction of the other Party (e.g. an Australian fishing in Papua New Guinea waters), the laws and regulations of that Party apply, but the fisher is exempt from licensing fees, levies and other charges of that Party (Schedule, Article 26(2)). It is an offence under the fisheries laws of each Party to fish without authorisation or in breach of conditions in areas under the other Party's jurisdiction (Schedule, Article 28(3)).
Sixth, traditional inhabitants exercising traditional fishing rights should familiarise themselves with any conservation measures adopted under Article 15(2) of the Treaty that may limit traditional fishing. Those measures must be necessary for conservation and must minimise restrictive effects on traditional fishing, but they are binding.
Seventh, for regulators, ensure that arrangements under Part 3 are properly made in accordance with section 32 of the Commonwealth Act (s 17(1)). Before an arrangement takes effect, licences and regulations may be prepared but do not have effect until the arrangement takes effect (s 17(3)). When an arrangement terminates, all instruments and regulations made under it cease to have effect (s 17(4)). The Joint Authority must keep the condition of the fishery under consideration and formulate policies for good management (s 19). The Governor in Council must make regulations or amend existing ones to give effect to Joint Authority decisions (s 22). Reports of the Joint Authority must be laid before the Legislative Assembly (s 16).
Finally, ensure that the Torres Strait Treaty's broader obligations are met. The Act's objectives require regard to traditional inhabitants' way of life (s 7). The Treaty schedule requires protection of the marine environment (Article 13), protection of fauna and flora (Article 14), and prohibition of mining and drilling of the seabed (Article 15). These obligations are given effect through the Act's regulation-making power (s 24) and through the management arrangements under Part 3.